I do agree that the Strongman is way too overpowered.
So I guess I’ll vote:
Cop and Doctor
Edit: Okay nevermind, I just realized that the Doctor can’t protect people from the Strongman. So to me the role to me is sorta useless. Then I guess I’ll vote:
Cop and Watcher
Try not to edit your posts. We are not allowed to edit. You can just quote yourself and correct it in a new post.
Oops, sorry. I didn’t know.
Gurl, you edited again. -.-
Woops! I thought you meant we only weren’t allowed to edit the vote posts..
No, it's for every post. This is to disallow cheating, or cover ups of slip ups, etc.
The way the setup works is that the mafia choose a role in there pm pregame and aftert that, everyone votes for a town role like you would lynch someone (except you vote for the one you want.) It functions like a normal day would.
Assuming that she understood my explanation correctly, which I'm assuming she did since she changed to having a D0, the mafia already chose there pm. So I think we're safe to assume that the maf already know their role.
I'm going to go ahead and Vote cop based on my explanation at the beginning of day. I'm still torn wether to go for Tracker or watcher. I'mma go back and look at which is which cause I always mix them up.
Tracker means you target a person and you find out if that person visited anyone.
Watcher means you target a person and you find out who else visited that person.
Ok. Thanks. As expected, I mixed them up at the beginning of day which is why I said Watcher. Tracker would be better because we can see if our target visits anyone which will give us info as to whether or not the are a maf/pr. Watcher on the other hand just finds out if Someone visits them, so if the target gets visited by say the ninja and the town pr, the town pr would be wrongfully accused. Where as the tracker eliminates that posibility becausr the tracker only shows who theh visited...am I making sense? Its 4am here. XD.
Anyway, Vote Tracker as my second vote.
I think it's the same either way depending on the circumstances. A tracker can also track a townie who somehow visits the same person who also gets killed and can wrongfully accuse them.
That sounds confusing. XD
I meant like a tracker can track Person A and got a result that Person A visited Person B and then Person B died.
Yeah. I understood what you meant.
Even the Most Beautiful Rose has been through the Dirt
And also at least if the watcher gets two names, let's say Person A and Person B, and let's say Person A is a mafia, then Person B can claim that they're town. And if Person A is a ninja, then we are just back to square one cuz we won't know who the actual mafia is.
It's really like there's pros and cons to all the townie PRs.
I feel like a tracker can be good if you are good at aiming for a mafia. But a watcher is better as it gives more results on which players have a PR and target that one person, but at the same time we won't want that as mafia would want to kill all the PRs as soon as possible. A watcher is also good if you are someone who is good at predicting who will be killed that night and thus watching that person.
I just like the tracker role cuz I love being the tracker that one time I was one. Hahaha. So I'm kinda biased.
The way the setup works is that the mafia choose a role in there pm pregame and aftert that, everyone votes for a town role like you would lynch someone (except you vote for the one you want.) It functions like a normal day would.
Assuming that she understood my explanation correctly, which I'm assuming she did since she changed to having a D0, the mafia already chose there pm. So I think we're safe to assume that the maf already know their role.
I'm going to go ahead and Vote cop based on my explanation at the beginning of day. I'm still torn wether to go for Tracker or watcher. I'mma go back and look at which is which cause I always mix them up.
Tracker means you target a person and you find out if that person visited anyone.
Watcher means you target a person and you find out who else visited that person.
Ok. Thanks. As expected, I mixed them up at the beginning of day which is why I said Watcher. Tracker would be better because we can see if our target visits anyone which will give us info as to whether or not the are a maf/pr. Watcher on the other hand just finds out if Someone visits them, so if the target gets visited by say the ninja and the town pr, the town pr would be wrongfully accused. Where as the tracker eliminates that posibility becausr the tracker only shows who theh visited...am I making sense? Its 4am here. XD.
Anyway, Vote Tracker as my second vote.
I didn’t think about that. I guess I’ll change my vote then.
New Vote: Cop and Tracker
Do you like games that involve strategy? Do you like solving a mystery?
Hi there!
Had to read through 2 pages and I´m still a bit confused about this game.
The cop is the most useful role for townies in this game.
But I am torn between tracker and watcher but really don´t know who is more useful.
To chose the doctor just makes sence if we already knew who could be mafia, which we don´t.
Atm I can´t decide for the second vote, my first one would likely be cop.
The way the setup works is that the mafia choose a role in there pm pregame and aftert that, everyone votes for a town role like you would lynch someone (except you vote for the one you want.) It functions like a normal day would.
Assuming that she understood my explanation correctly, which I'm assuming she did since she changed to having a D0, the mafia already chose there pm. So I think we're safe to assume that the maf already know their role.
I'm going to go ahead and Vote cop based on my explanation at the beginning of day. I'm still torn wether to go for Tracker or watcher. I'mma go back and look at which is which cause I always mix them up.
Tracker means you target a person and you find out if that person visited anyone.
Watcher means you target a person and you find out who else visited that person.
Ok. Thanks. As expected, I mixed them up at the beginning of day which is why I said Watcher. Tracker would be better because we can see if our target visits anyone which will give us info as to whether or not the are a maf/pr. Watcher on the other hand just finds out if Someone visits them, so if the target gets visited by say the ninja and the town pr, the town pr would be wrongfully accused. Where as the tracker eliminates that posibility becausr the tracker only shows who theh visited...am I making sense? Its 4am here. XD.
Anyway, Vote Tracker as my second vote.
I didn’t think about that. I guess I’ll change my vote then.
New Vote: Cop and Tracker
Dekay just told me earlier that the same thing could happen for tracker.
...a tracker can track Person A and got a result that Person A visited Person B and then Person B died.
In other words, if Person A is the Town PR, Person B is killed, and Person C is the Mafia Ninja, if A and C both visit B, C won't show up, so A will be wrongfully accused. Kinda like the Watcher situation I described. I didn't think about that, So really, they are about equal. It doesn't matter to much which one we choose.
Even the Most Beautiful Rose has been through the Dirt
Well, since the mafia has already decided a role beforehand. Unless they predicted that we would think they chose strongman and opted for a ninja instead, a doctor would be powerless against a strongman.
I have another question. It’s been a long time since I last played so I’m unsure about this, but in the case that they choose a strongman, is it possible for the strongman to send the kill every night? Or should the two alternate each night? If it’s the former, then I’ll have to choose tracker for my other vote.
Vote: cop
Not sure what for the 2nd vote.
You guys say doctor is useless against strongman but then that mafia might guess we'd anticipate strongman and then pick ninja instead. I was doc once and it was a total shot in the dark, spin the bottle sorta thing. If anyone could have advised me, say a tracker or watcher, but it was just blind both times I got to use the role, and both times, I protected the mafia. 🤪so doc wouldn't be useless with some intel. But without it, useless.
Racism is EVERYONE's fight #BLM #StopAsianHate
Let's make Liberty and Justice For All a reality.
Well, since the mafia has already decided a role beforehand. Unless they predicted that we would think they chose strongman and opted for a ninja instead, a doctor would be powerless against a strongman.
I have another question. It’s been a long time since I last played so I’m unsure about this, but in the case that they choose a strongman, is it possible for the strongman to send the kill every night? Or should the two alternate each night? If it’s the former, then I’ll have to choose tracker for my other vote.
Vote: Cop
The strongman can kill every night as long as they are still alive.
Vote: cop
Not sure what for the 2nd vote.
You guys say doctor is useless against strongman but then that mafia might guess we'd anticipate strongman and then pick ninja instead. I was doc once and it was a total shot in the dark, spin the bottle sorta thing. If anyone could have advised me, say a tracker or watcher, but it was just blind both times I got to use the role, and both times, I protected the mafia. 🤪so doc wouldn't be useless with some intel. But without it, useless.
I rather just have some kinda investigative role than the doc, so yeah. Doc is kinda useless most of the time due to bad luck. I've played probably many tens of games with a doctor and probably only seen the doctor saving a person like fewer than 10 times. A doc is more useful when there are fewer people. But with an investigative role, there's a chance that we can know if the person is a townie or not (while taking into account the ninja or godfather).
The strongman can kill every night as long as they are still alive.
Welp. Although it’s a useful role, in this kind of scenario, a doctor would be quite powerless if the mafia had chosen a strongman. Given that role’s powers, it’s likely that they did. It’s better to choose investigative roles, I guess.
Hey guys, just read back. I'm going to go ahead and Vote Cop
Definitely don't think we should pick Doctor. It's not that helpful in a larger group like we have now like DeKay said and it's a lot of guessing tbh.
I also agree with those of you that said that the mafia wouldn't have picked Godfather, can't do as much damage with it, I think if I were mafia I'd choose Ninja. Puts them at risk for a roleblocker, but they were probably able to predict that we wouldn't choose Doctor. Still not sure what other PR we should get but I'm leaning towards tracker atm.
I also agree with those of you that said that the mafia wouldn't have picked Godfather, can't do as much damage with it, I think if I were mafia I'd choose Ninja. Puts them at risk for a roleblocker, but they were probably able to predict that we wouldn't choose Doctor. Still not sure what other PR we should get but I'm leaning towards tracker atm.
Sorry for spam but I forgot to add that the reason I think we should go for tracker instead of watcher is that watcher requires you to try and predict who the mafia's going to kill while trackers can just go for who they think is mafia if that makes sense. Just seems to me like tracker is less guessing.
So, don't tracker and watcher share the same Achilles' heel, in that you can tell whom your target visited in the first case, and in the second, can detect that your target WAS visited, but in neither case can you tell the name or alliance of either party?
Racism is EVERYONE's fight #BLM #StopAsianHate
Let's make Liberty and Justice For All a reality.
So, don't tracker and watcher share the same Achilles' heel, in that you can tell whom your target visited in the first case, and in the second, can detect that your target WAS visited, but in neither case can you tell the name or alliance of either party?
whoops not name. I mean you'd know the name of the person you chose to either tale, or sit in stakeout watching. But would you at least know the name of the person they either went to visit, or else were visited by? The name, but not anything else?
Racism is EVERYONE's fight #BLM #StopAsianHate
Let's make Liberty and Justice For All a reality.
So, don't tracker and watcher share the same Achilles' heel, in that you can tell whom your target visited in the first case, and in the second, can detect that your target WAS visited, but in neither case can you tell the name or alliance of either party?
whoops not name. I mean you'd know the name of the person you chose to either tale, or sit in stakeout watching. But would you at least know the name of the person they either went to visit, or else were visited by? The name, but not anything else?
Yeah you just find out the name, only Cops know alignments
As everynody else my first vote is easy. Vote Cop
But I´m still unsure what is better to vote, tracker or watcher.....
Both have their pros and cons. I tend to the tracker more but both of them don´t really know exactly the name of a mafia so for the game they aren´t so useful, because we still have to guess what they really have seen. The mafia has a lot of benefits in this game.
So, am I the only person who hasn't posted yet?
Anyways, I think I'm going to Vote Cop and Watcher because they seem the most useful.
The cop alignment seems most reliable for a Town Victory, and from my understanding Watcher and Tracker are pretty much the same thing, and I want to have one of them.
Nush by the way when you votes you didn’t bold or all caps it so it doesn’t count. And Dekay to answer your question, yes the mafia already voted for their role before the game
Comments
Yeah. I understood what you meant.
It's really like there's pros and cons to all the townie PRs.
I feel like a tracker can be good if you are good at aiming for a mafia. But a watcher is better as it gives more results on which players have a PR and target that one person, but at the same time we won't want that as mafia would want to kill all the PRs as soon as possible. A watcher is also good if you are someone who is good at predicting who will be killed that night and thus watching that person.
I just like the tracker role cuz I love being the tracker that one time I was one. Hahaha. So I'm kinda biased.
I didn’t think about that. I guess I’ll change my vote then.
New Vote: Cop and Tracker
Had to read through 2 pages and I´m still a bit confused about this game.
The cop is the most useful role for townies in this game.
But I am torn between tracker and watcher but really don´t know who is more useful.
To chose the doctor just makes sence if we already knew who could be mafia, which we don´t.
Atm I can´t decide for the second vote, my first one would likely be cop.
https://forums.thesims.com/en_US/discussion/953447/streuner-a-cat-s-tale
Dekay just told me earlier that the same thing could happen for tracker.
In other words, if Person A is the Town PR, Person B is killed, and Person C is the Mafia Ninja, if A and C both visit B, C won't show up, so A will be wrongfully accused. Kinda like the Watcher situation I described. I didn't think about that, So really, they are about equal. It doesn't matter to much which one we choose.
I have another question. It’s been a long time since I last played so I’m unsure about this, but in the case that they choose a strongman, is it possible for the strongman to send the kill every night? Or should the two alternate each night? If it’s the former, then I’ll have to choose tracker for my other vote.
Vote: Cop
Not sure what for the 2nd vote.
You guys say doctor is useless against strongman but then that mafia might guess we'd anticipate strongman and then pick ninja instead. I was doc once and it was a total shot in the dark, spin the bottle sorta thing. If anyone could have advised me, say a tracker or watcher, but it was just blind both times I got to use the role, and both times, I protected the mafia. 🤪so doc wouldn't be useless with some intel. But without it, useless.
Let's make Liberty and Justice For All a reality.
The strongman can kill every night as long as they are still alive.
I rather just have some kinda investigative role than the doc, so yeah. Doc is kinda useless most of the time due to bad luck. I've played probably many tens of games with a doctor and probably only seen the doctor saving a person like fewer than 10 times. A doc is more useful when there are fewer people. But with an investigative role, there's a chance that we can know if the person is a townie or not (while taking into account the ninja or godfather).
Welp. Although it’s a useful role, in this kind of scenario, a doctor would be quite powerless if the mafia had chosen a strongman. Given that role’s powers, it’s likely that they did. It’s better to choose investigative roles, I guess.
Vote: Tracker
Definitely don't think we should pick Doctor. It's not that helpful in a larger group like we have now like DeKay said and it's a lot of guessing tbh.
Sorry for spam but I forgot to add that the reason I think we should go for tracker instead of watcher is that watcher requires you to try and predict who the mafia's going to kill while trackers can just go for who they think is mafia if that makes sense. Just seems to me like tracker is less guessing.
Let's make Liberty and Justice For All a reality.
whoops not name. I mean you'd know the name of the person you chose to either tale, or sit in stakeout watching. But would you at least know the name of the person they either went to visit, or else were visited by? The name, but not anything else?
Let's make Liberty and Justice For All a reality.
Yeah you just find out the name, only Cops know alignments
Vote Cop
But I´m still unsure what is better to vote, tracker or watcher.....
Both have their pros and cons. I tend to the tracker more but both of them don´t really know exactly the name of a mafia so for the game they aren´t so useful, because we still have to guess what they really have seen. The mafia has a lot of benefits in this game.
https://forums.thesims.com/en_US/discussion/953447/streuner-a-cat-s-tale
Anyways, I think I'm going to Vote Cop and Watcher because they seem the most useful.
The cop alignment seems most reliable for a Town Victory, and from my understanding Watcher and Tracker are pretty much the same thing, and I want to have one of them.
Cop - Dekay, Sophia, Rose, Alexa, Wagashi, City, Nerd
Tracker - Dekay, Sophia, Wagashi
Watcher - Nerd
Nush by the way when you votes you didn’t bold or all caps it so it doesn’t count. And Dekay to answer your question, yes the mafia already voted for their role before the game
Tahnks mouse
VOTE : COP and Watcher
Let's make Liberty and Justice For All a reality.
VOTE: COP
VOTE: WATCHER
Let's make Liberty and Justice For All a reality.
Oops, didn't see your comment, but yes, I can be!
Most likely caught as scum and best theme-Google Translate, 4th annual Scummies win!
Cop: Dekay, Sophia, Wagashi, Rose, Alexa, Nush, NASCAR, City, Nerd
Tracker: Sophia, Dekay, Wagashi, NASCAR Watcher: Nerd, Nush
Day 0 ends in 7 hours. Right now Cop and Tracker will be selected
Edited that cause it was annoying me that Tracker and Watcher were on the same line and it looked like tracker had more votes than it does. XD
Also, you missed my Tracker vote.