Plumbob, give me a reason to not vote you. Kitty did say some nice things about you in Day 1.
Because I'm your friend
Sorry that's all I got, I am town, but I'm not sure how else to convince you. If I were SK I wouldn't have killed Kitty because she was the only one yesterday who seemed to be on my side. I'm also not her buddy. I think Rose is the SK and killed Kitty because killing me would've been obvious that it was her (because I was the only one who was suspicious of her, I think), so by killing Kitty I wouldn't have had a backup.
So I don't think Plumbob is SK, because killing Kitty would draw too much attention to him, as we're seeing right now. It's possible he's mafia but I don't think Kitty would so openly defend her buddy. I guess that means he's town by process of elimination.
I can see Rose killing Kitty, though it's risky since she's already under a lot of scrutiny. I think it's more likely that she's mafia and she and Kitty suspected different people to look less associated.
Bubbz I have no idea about.
I'd like to hear what Nerd thinks about this kill. She seemed town enough day 1.
DeKay could go either way. I could see her being SK. She didn't seem that associated with Kitty but I'll read back.
I feel like this makes no sense, sorry. I have a really bad headache right now.
Rose - I feel like Rose is SK, after me, Kitty was who was most suspicious of her. It wouldn't have made sense to kill me, because she could easily try and persuade everyone to vote me off, but killing Kitty makes sure that I don't have any one to back me up... I think Rose killed Kitty last night.
Edited some of the quote out. Here's my question to you Plumbob. You would think I know better by now then to kill someone who is suspicious of me. What do you mean by the bolded section?
Edited some of the quote out. The biggest reason I can give you no to vote me is that Kitty was defending Plumbob a lot and I can see Plumbob being mafia because of how buddy-buddy they were. Something else that concerns me is this. I read back on Day 1 a bit and noticed these posts.
So after thinking it over, I think Plumbob is fine for now. Alexa is the only other one that Im getting even slightly acummy vibes from. I usually like to keep new memvers around, but I'm not sure what to do.....Vote Alexa
I'm kinda tempted to vote for Alexa, I think she's been acting the strangest today, at the same time, I don't want to vote for a new player though 🤔
You know what, I think I'm gonna Vote Alexa
Posted at 5:25pm CDT
You'll notice that Plumbob went from saying he didnt want to vote for a new person to voting Alexa 5 minutes later....only after I swapped my vote to Alexa. To me, It seems like he took the chance to get the majority away from him and onto someone else. Yes, I changed my vote in the same matter, but mine was over at least a few hours where as he changed his position in 5 minutes.
Plumbob, give me a reason to not vote you. Kitty did say some nice things about you in Day 1.
Because I'm your friend
Sorry that's all I got, I am town, but I'm not sure how else to convince you. If I were SK I wouldn't have killed Kitty because she was the only one yesterday who seemed to be on my side. I'm also not her buddy. I think Rose is the SK and killed Kitty because killing me would've been obvious that it was her (because I was the only one who was suspicious of her, I think), so by killing Kitty I wouldn't have had a backup.
The bolded section is exactly why I think your the other mafia instead of the SK. I do think the SK is more dangerous since they can nightkill, but this is the only lead I have.
So I don't think Plumbob is SK, because killing Kitty would draw too much attention to him, as we're seeing right now. It's possible he's mafia but I don't think Kitty would so openly defend her buddy. I guess that means he's town by process of elimination.
I divided City's post into separate quotes so it was easier to address everything. I agree that Plumbob is not the SK. I think based on the evidence I provided above Plumbob could very well be mafia. Kitty could have planned to openly defend Plumbob to trick us into thinking they arent buddies.
I think it's more likely that she's mafia and she and Kitty suspected different people to look less associated.
We all know how bad I am at being mafia. I would not be able to pull this off and it would have been obvious that I was associated with Kitty.
I am not the SK. I am not Mafia. I am a VT, and I believe that the evidence that I posted above makes Plumbob seem suspicious. I may be wrong, but I don't think I am. If I am, then I apologize. This is what I think. Vote Plumbob
Even the Most Beautiful Rose has been through the Dirt
Rose - I feel like Rose is SK, after me, Kitty was who was most suspicious of her. It wouldn't have made sense to kill me, because she could easily try and persuade everyone to vote me off, but killing Kitty makes sure that I don't have any one to back me up... I think Rose killed Kitty last night.
Edited some of the quote out. Here's my question to you Plumbob. You would think I know better by now then to kill someone who is suspicious of me. What do you mean by the bolded section?
Edited some of the quote out. The biggest reason I can give you no to vote me is that Kitty was defending Plumbob a lot and I can see Plumbob being mafia because of how buddy-buddy they were. Something else that concerns me is this. I read back on Day 1 a bit and noticed these posts.
So after thinking it over, I think Plumbob is fine for now. Alexa is the only other one that Im getting even slightly acummy vibes from. I usually like to keep new memvers around, but I'm not sure what to do.....Vote Alexa
I'm kinda tempted to vote for Alexa, I think she's been acting the strangest today, at the same time, I don't want to vote for a new player though 🤔
You know what, I think I'm gonna Vote Alexa
Posted at 5:25pm CDT
You'll notice that Plumbob went from saying he didnt want to vote for a new person to voting Alexa 5 minutes later....only after I swapped my vote to Alexa. To me, It seems like he took the chance to get the majority away from him and onto someone else. Yes, I changed my vote in the same matter, but mine was over at least a few hours where as he changed his position in 5 minutes.
Plumbob, give me a reason to not vote you. Kitty did say some nice things about you in Day 1.
Because I'm your friend
Sorry that's all I got, I am town, but I'm not sure how else to convince you. If I were SK I wouldn't have killed Kitty because she was the only one yesterday who seemed to be on my side. I'm also not her buddy. I think Rose is the SK and killed Kitty because killing me would've been obvious that it was her (because I was the only one who was suspicious of her, I think), so by killing Kitty I wouldn't have had a backup.
The bolded section is exactly why I think your the other mafia instead of the SK. I do think the SK is more dangerous since they can nightkill, but this is the only lead I have.
So I don't think Plumbob is SK, because killing Kitty would draw too much attention to him, as we're seeing right now. It's possible he's mafia but I don't think Kitty would so openly defend her buddy. I guess that means he's town by process of elimination.
I divided City's post into separate quotes so it was easier to address everything. I agree that Plumbob is not the SK. I think based on the evidence I provided above Plumbob could very well be mafia. Kitty could have planned to openly defend Plumbob to trick us into thinking they arent buddies.
I think it's more likely that she's mafia and she and Kitty suspected different people to look less associated.
We all know how bad I am at being mafia. I would not be able to pull this off and it would have been obvious that I was associated with Kitty.
I am not the SK. I am not Mafia. I am a VT, and I believe that the evidence that I posted above makes Plumbob seem suspicious. I may be wrong, but I don't think I am. If I am, then I apologize. This is what I think. Vote Plumbob
No, no no. I don't think Plumbob is mafia. It's too risky for them two to associate each other like that knowing The SK can kill Kitty in this case (if let's say Plumbob was actually lynched one day 1 and flipped mafia). Kitty is a good player with good strategies but I don't think she would risk going this route of "reverse psychology".
That being said, I think you should reconsider the Plumbob vote cuz after some thinking, I think he might not be SK since he forgot about the night phase in the beginning.
I feel like Bubbz is probably not SK since she's most likely to kill me.
Nerd, I think can go either way. She could be SK or mafia.
Rose, I think could be SK or mafia. I know she and Kitty had some exchanges on D1 but to me, they look kinda like pretending that they're not buddies. 😂
And for City, I think she's okay for now. I'm actually a bit worried that I'm not worried about her. 😂 I think it's possible that she could pull a plot twist and turn out the be mafia.
Comments
Rose, give me a reason to not vote you.
Plumbob, give me a reason to not vote you. Kitty did say some nice things about you in Day 1.
Okay, I think Rose is the mafia and Plumbob is the SK. I don't really think Bubbz is the SK. It's possible she's mafia tho.
Plumbob votes Rose
@Mouselline : please tell me, who´s who!
https://forums.thesims.com/en_US/discussion/953447/streuner-a-cat-s-tale
Because I'm your friend
Sorry that's all I got, I am town, but I'm not sure how else to convince you. If I were SK I wouldn't have killed Kitty because she was the only one yesterday who seemed to be on my side. I'm also not her buddy. I think Rose is the SK and killed Kitty because killing me would've been obvious that it was her (because I was the only one who was suspicious of her, I think), so by killing Kitty I wouldn't have had a backup.
I can see Rose killing Kitty, though it's risky since she's already under a lot of scrutiny. I think it's more likely that she's mafia and she and Kitty suspected different people to look less associated.
Bubbz I have no idea about.
I'd like to hear what Nerd thinks about this kill. She seemed town enough day 1.
DeKay could go either way. I could see her being SK. She didn't seem that associated with Kitty but I'll read back.
I feel like this makes no sense, sorry. I have a really bad headache right now.
Huh?
The stuff is the same as the last post so I just quoted it and posted that
Edited some of the quote out. The biggest reason I can give you no to vote me is that Kitty was defending Plumbob a lot and I can see Plumbob being mafia because of how buddy-buddy they were. Something else that concerns me is this. I read back on Day 1 a bit and noticed these posts.
Posted at 5:23pm CDT
Posted at 5:25pm CDT
The bolded section is exactly why I think your the other mafia instead of the SK. I do think the SK is more dangerous since they can nightkill, but this is the only lead I have.
I divided City's post into separate quotes so it was easier to address everything. I agree that Plumbob is not the SK. I think based on the evidence I provided above Plumbob could very well be mafia. Kitty could have planned to openly defend Plumbob to trick us into thinking they arent buddies.
Exactly this. It's risky, and I would not take that chance as I'm not much of a risky player.
We all know how bad I am at being mafia. I would not be able to pull this off and it would have been obvious that I was associated with Kitty.
I am not the SK. I am not Mafia. I am a VT, and I believe that the evidence that I posted above makes Plumbob seem suspicious. I may be wrong, but I don't think I am. If I am, then I apologize. This is what I think. Vote Plumbob
No, no no. I don't think Plumbob is mafia. It's too risky for them two to associate each other like that knowing The SK can kill Kitty in this case (if let's say Plumbob was actually lynched one day 1 and flipped mafia). Kitty is a good player with good strategies but I don't think she would risk going this route of "reverse psychology".
That being said, I think you should reconsider the Plumbob vote cuz after some thinking, I think he might not be SK since he forgot about the night phase in the beginning.
Nerd, I think can go either way. She could be SK or mafia.
Rose, I think could be SK or mafia. I know she and Kitty had some exchanges on D1 but to me, they look kinda like pretending that they're not buddies. 😂
Plumbob votes Rose
Dekay votes Plumbob
Uh....I voted Plumbob and Dekay voted Nerd. I might suggest you read back and look at the votes again.
The Rose one before the Plumbob one.