Looking at the posts right now, I think either Bella or Broncos is werewolf. Not sure about Nerd, obviously.
Not sure if this is just sus transferring over from the UM game (heh), but I agree Broncos is my most sus atm. I haven’t formed much of an opinion on anyone else, really.
I'm kinda sus a bit with Bella too with her so called role claim but not telling. Cuz we gotta know that the werewolf can take a peek at the deck to fake claim.
They must have chosen whichever card isn’t werewolf/minion. Song, did you get to see all 3 cards or just the two?
Song can only see two, I believe.
So we don’t know the card the werewolf saw to use as a fake claim 😕
I’m not sure Bella’s the werewolf, but she might be the best shot we have. I do want to hear from her what DeKay’s card is she stole.
Yeah, I'm curious too. If she's bad, she might try to use elimination method and try to figure out which roles have not been claimed to guess what is mine.
Assuming nothing else happened with your card, you should be a robber because we swapped cards.
Well, I didn't get any notification that my card was swapped but yeah, I was a villager, if you are telling the truth.
I think 12 hours of day might be too short tho since Nerd is totally missing and also time zone differences. I think most of you guys are already gonna go to bed now. 😅
Looking at the posts right now, I think either Bella or Broncos is werewolf. Not sure about Nerd, obviously.
Not sure if this is just sus transferring over from the UM game (heh), but I agree Broncos is my most sus atm. I haven’t formed much of an opinion on anyone else, really.
I'm kinda sus a bit with Bella too with her so called role claim but not telling. Cuz we gotta know that the werewolf can take a peek at the deck to fake claim.
I think that’s valid town. Like, if I’d seen a non-scum card I wouldn’t have said anything about it, I’d instead wait for the werewolf to claim and then catch them.
Looking at the posts right now, I think either Bella or Broncos is werewolf. Not sure about Nerd, obviously.
Not sure if this is just sus transferring over from the UM game (heh), but I agree Broncos is my most sus atm. I haven’t formed much of an opinion on anyone else, really.
I'm kinda sus a bit with Bella too with her so called role claim but not telling. Cuz we gotta know that the werewolf can take a peek at the deck to fake claim.
They must have chosen whichever card isn’t werewolf/minion. Song, did you get to see all 3 cards or just the two?
I saw just two. However it’s possible since the werewolf only sees one card that they saw werewolf or minion, which they can’t claim very well.
Looking at the posts right now, I think either Bella or Broncos is werewolf. Not sure about Nerd, obviously.
Not sure if this is just sus transferring over from the UM game (heh), but I agree Broncos is my most sus atm. I haven’t formed much of an opinion on anyone else, really.
I'm kinda sus a bit with Bella too with her so called role claim but not telling. Cuz we gotta know that the werewolf can take a peek at the deck to fake claim.
They must have chosen whichever card isn’t werewolf/minion. Song, did you get to see all 3 cards or just the two?
Song can only see two, I believe.
So we don’t know the card the werewolf saw to use as a fake claim 😕
I’m not sure Bella’s the werewolf, but she might be the best shot we have. I do want to hear from her what DeKay’s card is she stole.
Yeah, I'm curious too. If she's bad, she might try to use elimination method and try to figure out which roles have not been claimed to guess what is mine.
I feel like that’s super risky. I trust Bella here.
Hey guys! Just popping in to let you guys know that I won't be able to be active for another few hours since I'm going skiing. I'll be back (hopefully) before day ends though!
I think day ends in a few hours so I’ll say who I’ve voted at the moment. I’ve voted Song. Earlier Broncos said that he’s sure he’s not werewolf. I said I don’t believe you to get a reaction out of other people. Bella said I don’t either and then Song said they don’t beleive them also. It seemed a lot like a bandwagon and attempts to join in. They also haven’t posted very much but then again it’s the morning of Christmas Eve where I am so that’s understandable if they just are busy or asleep. Of course going with the reasoning I said Bella could technically be werewolf also but i just found it odd that he was the 3rd person to say it over something so simple as “I’m pretty sure.”
I think day ends in a few hours so I’ll say who I’ve voted at the moment. I’ve voted Song. Earlier Broncos said that he’s sure he’s not werewolf. I said I don’t believe you to get a reaction out of other people. Bella said I don’t either and then Song said they don’t beleive them also. It seemed a lot like a bandwagon and attempts to join in. They also haven’t posted very much but then again it’s the morning of Christmas Eve where I am so that’s understandable if they just are busy or asleep. Of course going with the reasoning I said Bella could technically be werewolf also but i just found it odd that he was the 3rd person to say it over something so simple as “I’m pretty sure.”
I see what you’re saying here, and if she is there werewolf, she’s know if there was one or two, I’m not sure if she’d know there was a minion in the middle, I’ll have to check. I think claiming seer is incredibly risky but maybe she thought she could win a counterclaim battle?
Do you like solving a mystery? Come join a mafia game!
Link: here!
I think day ends in a few hours so I’ll say who I’ve voted at the moment. I’ve voted Song. Earlier Broncos said that he’s sure he’s not werewolf. I said I don’t believe you to get a reaction out of other people. Bella said I don’t either and then Song said they don’t beleive them also. It seemed a lot like a bandwagon and attempts to join in. They also haven’t posted very much but then again it’s the morning of Christmas Eve where I am so that’s understandable if they just are busy or asleep. Of course going with the reasoning I said Bella could technically be werewolf also but i just found it odd that he was the 3rd person to say it over something so simple as “I’m pretty sure.”
Lol I never said I didn’t believe them. Here’s what I said:
Looking at the posts right now, I think either Bella or Broncos is werewolf. Not sure about Nerd, obviously.
Not sure if this is just sus transferring over from the UM game (heh), but I agree Broncos is my most sus atm. I haven’t formed much of an opinion on anyone else, really.
Mouse, you haven’t claimed anything, I don’t think. Why? If we’re believing everyone’s claims, it’s got to be you or nerd.
DeKay and Bella are confirmed, basically. Vanilla is an easy thing to claim from Broncos, but I somewhat trust it - until someone else claims vanilla, then we’ve got a problem.
The first page says the werewolves don’t know if there’s a minion or who it could be so I don’t believe Song faked her claim. Even if it were a fake claim for a werewolf, I don’t see how she could have been so sure so early in the game that there’s no minion in the game.
Do you like solving a mystery? Come join a mafia game!
Link: here!
I think day ends in a few hours so I’ll say who I’ve voted at the moment. I’ve voted Song. Earlier Broncos said that he’s sure he’s not werewolf. I said I don’t believe you to get a reaction out of other people. Bella said I don’t either and then Song said they don’t beleive them also. It seemed a lot like a bandwagon and attempts to join in. They also haven’t posted very much but then again it’s the morning of Christmas Eve where I am so that’s understandable if they just are busy or asleep. Of course going with the reasoning I said Bella could technically be werewolf also but i just found it odd that he was the 3rd person to say it over something so simple as “I’m pretty sure.”
Lol I never said I didn’t believe them. Here’s what I said:
Looking at the posts right now, I think either Bella or Broncos is werewolf. Not sure about Nerd, obviously.
Not sure if this is just sus transferring over from the UM game (heh), but I agree Broncos is my most sus atm. I haven’t formed much of an opinion on anyone else, really.
Mouse, you haven’t claimed anything, I don’t think. Why? If we’re believing everyone’s claims, it’s got to be you or nerd.
DeKay and Bella are confirmed, basically. Vanilla is an easy thing to claim from Broncos, but I somewhat trust it - until someone else claims vanilla, then we’ve got a problem.
I was waiting for someone to claim my role. No one did. But if we are believing everyone’s claims like you say then we aren’t going to be able to catch werewolf anytime soon. I think Nerd would put more effort in if she was werewolf. I’m insomniac
I think day ends in a few hours so I’ll say who I’ve voted at the moment. I’ve voted Song. Earlier Broncos said that he’s sure he’s not werewolf. I said I don’t believe you to get a reaction out of other people. Bella said I don’t either and then Song said they don’t beleive them also. It seemed a lot like a bandwagon and attempts to join in. They also haven’t posted very much but then again it’s the morning of Christmas Eve where I am so that’s understandable if they just are busy or asleep. Of course going with the reasoning I said Bella could technically be werewolf also but i just found it odd that he was the 3rd person to say it over something so simple as “I’m pretty sure.”
Lol I never said I didn’t believe them. Here’s what I said:
Looking at the posts right now, I think either Bella or Broncos is werewolf. Not sure about Nerd, obviously.
Not sure if this is just sus transferring over from the UM game (heh), but I agree Broncos is my most sus atm. I haven’t formed much of an opinion on anyone else, really.
Mouse, you haven’t claimed anything, I don’t think. Why? If we’re believing everyone’s claims, it’s got to be you or nerd.
DeKay and Bella are confirmed, basically. Vanilla is an easy thing to claim from Broncos, but I somewhat trust it - until someone else claims vanilla, then we’ve got a problem.
It’s possible the werewolf will still try to claim villager and say I’m lying. Song said there’s a werewolf and a minion card in the middle, so there’s a chance that the werewolf did a get a fake claim that nobody will be able to counterclaim. It’s not the best of chances, but still could have happened
Do you like solving a mystery? Come join a mafia game!
Link: here!
Looking at the posts right now, I think either Bella or Broncos is werewolf. Not sure about Nerd, obviously.
Not sure if this is just sus transferring over from the UM game (heh), but I agree Broncos is my most sus atm. I haven’t formed much of an opinion on anyone else, really.
I'm kinda sus a bit with Bella too with her so called role claim but not telling. Cuz we gotta know that the werewolf can take a peek at the deck to fake claim.
They must have chosen whichever card isn’t werewolf/minion. Song, did you get to see all 3 cards or just the two?
Song can only see two, I believe.
So we don’t know the card the werewolf saw to use as a fake claim 😕
I’m not sure Bella’s the werewolf, but she might be the best shot we have. I do want to hear from her what DeKay’s card is she stole.
Yeah, I'm curious too. If she's bad, she might try to use elimination method and try to figure out which roles have not been claimed to guess what is mine.
Assuming nothing else happened with your card, you should be a robber because we swapped cards.
Well, I didn't get any notification that my card was swapped but yeah, I was a villager, if you are telling the truth.
By the rules, I'm not sure you're supposed to get notified of a card swap. But I'm not lying when I say that it happened.
Most likely caught as scum and best theme-Google Translate, 4th annual Scummies win!
I would say that DeKay and Bella are cleared. I don’t see a way either of them could be lying.
As for Song, seer could have been a fake claim for the werewolf and obviously she’d know there was another werewolf card in the middle if it’s just her. The minion thing is keeping me believing her. I think it said on the first page that the minion knows who the werewolf is so maybe they’re keeping quiet, but I don’t see that plan working out in the end. If we were to elim the minion, we’d then know it’s Song. The whole thing doesn’t make sense. So I’m inclined to believe Song
Mouse I’m going to believe as long as nobody counterclaims. It could have been a fake claim pulled from the middle for her, but I’ll choose to believe her for now.
So that leaves Nerd. I don’t know what to say about her since she hasn’t posted on topic
Do you like solving a mystery? Come join a mafia game!
Link: here!
Like I said before, I feel like Nerd would’ve made more of an effort if she was werewolf, tho that’s hard to say since she did say she was going skiing
Like I said before, I feel like Nerd would’ve made more of an effort if she was werewolf, tho that’s hard to say since she did say she was going skiing
Comments
Well, I didn't get any notification that my card was swapped but yeah, I was a villager, if you are telling the truth.
Link: here!
I think that’s valid town. Like, if I’d seen a non-scum card I wouldn’t have said anything about it, I’d instead wait for the werewolf to claim and then catch them.
I saw just two. However it’s possible since the werewolf only sees one card that they saw werewolf or minion, which they can’t claim very well.
I feel like that’s super risky. I trust Bella here.
I see what you’re saying here, and if she is there werewolf, she’s know if there was one or two, I’m not sure if she’d know there was a minion in the middle, I’ll have to check. I think claiming seer is incredibly risky but maybe she thought she could win a counterclaim battle?
Link: here!
Lol I never said I didn’t believe them. Here’s what I said:
Mouse, you haven’t claimed anything, I don’t think. Why? If we’re believing everyone’s claims, it’s got to be you or nerd.
DeKay and Bella are confirmed, basically. Vanilla is an easy thing to claim from Broncos, but I somewhat trust it - until someone else claims vanilla, then we’ve got a problem.
Link: here!
I was waiting for someone to claim my role. No one did. But if we are believing everyone’s claims like you say then we aren’t going to be able to catch werewolf anytime soon. I think Nerd would put more effort in if she was werewolf. I’m insomniac
It’s possible the werewolf will still try to claim villager and say I’m lying. Song said there’s a werewolf and a minion card in the middle, so there’s a chance that the werewolf did a get a fake claim that nobody will be able to counterclaim. It’s not the best of chances, but still could have happened
Link: here!
So if you're insomniac that means it's Nerd.
Most likely caught as scum and best theme-Google Translate, 4th annual Scummies win!
How did that work? Did you get a new card at the end of the night?
Link: here!
The way I've played it, they don't get a new card.
Most likely caught as scum and best theme-Google Translate, 4th annual Scummies win!
Well, not unless they've been given one by like the robber or something.
Most likely caught as scum and best theme-Google Translate, 4th annual Scummies win!
By the rules, I'm not sure you're supposed to get notified of a card swap. But I'm not lying when I say that it happened.
Most likely caught as scum and best theme-Google Translate, 4th annual Scummies win!
As for Song, seer could have been a fake claim for the werewolf and obviously she’d know there was another werewolf card in the middle if it’s just her. The minion thing is keeping me believing her. I think it said on the first page that the minion knows who the werewolf is so maybe they’re keeping quiet, but I don’t see that plan working out in the end. If we were to elim the minion, we’d then know it’s Song. The whole thing doesn’t make sense. So I’m inclined to believe Song
Mouse I’m going to believe as long as nobody counterclaims. It could have been a fake claim pulled from the middle for her, but I’ll choose to believe her for now.
So that leaves Nerd. I don’t know what to say about her since she hasn’t posted on topic
Link: here!
I don’t want to vote and whack her before she can say anything because if we don’t whack her, we lose.
Race Against the Clock: Can your elder sim turn back the clock before their time runs out?
that's true. She might have said something.
Most likely caught as scum and best theme-Google Translate, 4th annual Scummies win!