I had this post on the end of the last post but i went on a tangent about mafia docs and want confirmation that they can/cannot protect each other, so i'll leave that one out in the open.
Luna, a Compulsive Vigilante; Song, a Compulsive Vigilante; Nerd, a Doctor; and Dekay, a Doctor have been killed. It is now Day 2. Day 2 will end at 6pm CDT on 7/2/20. With 7 alive, it takes 4 to hammer.
Maybe we should try to figure out who killed who? It might give us a clue who is mafia.
Vigs aren't dangerous to the SK because they are bulletproof , right? So I think it's most likely Luna was killed by mafia since she claimed.
DeKay might have been shot by Song since she started a wagon on her or maybe the SK killed her because they were intimidated or suspected maybe?
Or did Luna suspect DeKay? I think she was townreading her.
And Nerd idk she hasn't been around at all. Could haave also been the mafia kill to hide their trace.
Well idk if that helped so much lol
Luna- I can see anyone killing luna because of that claim. But what I don't understand is why didn't more people protect luna? I'm gonna come right up right now and say i'm really sorry, i thought i did protect luna. i sent rose and nush a list way earlier of just people i was thinking might be good and luna was at the top. when luna claimed, i remembered that list but forgot i sent another list and went to bed without double checking my protection i changed my first protection to keyen. luna went down to third lol i was highly suspicious of caro originally because i thought maybe i was blocked, but then i checked and i didn't even protect luna after all. so maybe caro was blocked. her post coming in was still sketch AF but i'm giving her a pass for now until i look at other people and catch up
Song- I think this was a vig shot. DeKay voted song and then unvoted song and was suspecting song a lot. they had a lot of interaction day 1.
Nerd- seems like a vig shot too
Dekay- seems like a scum kill because of what i said earlier about dekay kills being more due to feeling intimidated as opposed to... not. (i did not post this earlier. i wrote it below but i wrote it earlier than i wrote this lol) plus song and nerd just seem like "let's see if they're scum" kills because we had such trouble reading them last time
unless rose is following a kill reveal order like mafia>sk>vigs in which case maf killed luna, sk killed song and the vigs killed nerd and dekay.
true but also like what i said in a past game, dekay kills are usually done out of intimidation rather than strategical and i think in this case, it was still an intimidation kill. probably by someone who's played a fair few games with her but still feel someone intimidated. idk that points me towards... keyen? maybe bella? but i don't see bella being bad this game idk. oh yeah i need to go read back her posts once i catch up. maybe sophia. maybe city. not broncos or caro. although maybe caro. lol.
Waiting to see what Broncos has to say. Unsure about Keyen and Sophia, but maybe they're just a bit overexcited. Idk. Also Caro? I think, mentioned how DeKay seems a bit excitable, or was at the start of the game. Is it a scum tell? Luna? was saying it's more of a towny tell but then DeKay was town the last game she played and wasn't like this... Maybe not specifically scum as in mafia, but maybe an SK? I can see DeKay being excited to be a solo killer.
I could see DeKay being excited to be a town vig. If I remember correctly, she usually does pretty well with her shots.
Hmm, maybe.
Maybe DeKay was killed because someone thought she might be vig.
That could be too. I thought she might have been Vig based on her energy, but I guess not.
I did see that Bella post as well. I want to say it was the UM game I played recently where someone said off-topic chatter could make Choco scummy, then he ended up being scum? Did I make that up? I want to say Skelda or Lala said it. idk but Bella was in that game so maybe she's trying to use that same idea?
I think in general, yeah, off topic chatter/a hyper focus on mechanics can be a scumtell because it's nervousness and avoiding the topic that they have to lie about
Mousselline said keyen broncos skelda
Broncos said dekay me mouse
Nerd said Bella keyen icey
Song said broncos Bella Sophia
I said Sophia Bella icey and dekay
Bella has a naturally suspicious name. Keyen, broncos, dekay, icey and Sophia come second. Interesting? Oh yes definitely. Let's pretend this holds substance.
But then if we had on votes then Sophia,s suspicion level DOUBLES. Amazing statisticalness. Me and skelda also join the club of next in line in suspicion. So then I believe the hierarchy goes-- Sophia, Bella and then keyen broncos dekay icey me and skelda
But that's just too many names so therefore we will forget about all the 2s
That leaves Sophia and Bella.
And now who wasn't included at all?
Rose
City
Mouselline
Nerd
Song
But now we must remove mouse and nerd because they did get mentioned/voted for.
Rose/replaced by plumbob
City
Song
That sounds like a song I'd like to write. Very poetic. Rose City Song.
Bella Sophia.
I think that we should lynch out of rose, city, song, Bella and Sophia today because my logic is flawless.
[City, Sophia and Mouse were scum]
worked SO well last game in revealing a whole ONE scum, I'm going to do it again.
************
EMMM
DeKay says Song, Em, Keyen, Caro
Broncos says Bella, Caro, Keyen, City
Mouse says Broncos, Keyen, and City
Sophia says Mouse, Broncos, & Caro
I say Luna, DeKay, Song and Caro
So far I don't think Sophia's added to the game conversation much (but Keyen hasn't helped with this), and I'm not sure if that's a scum tell or not...
1. Luna
2. Broncos
3. Bella
4. Song
5. Mouse
6. Dekay
7. Nerd
8. Emzy
9. Sophia
10. Keyen
11. Caro
12. City
I've only got townreads, no scum reads so far xD. We're dealing with a mafia team of 3, plus a SK. And like 2ish hours to decide on an elimination. Anyone have any leads?
Right now, my PoE is Song -> Keyen -> Nerd. I do think Keyen is acting more accusatory than usual, similar to how he plays as scum.
I don’t think Nerd even realized that she replaced Plumbob.
I agree with this.
HOWWWWWWWWWWWWW
Seemed a bit like too much of an exasperated reaction to be townish, but then maybe it's just a keyen reaction. but also i'm kinda thinking he's acting quite similarly as he did in the last game on UM, and he was scum there.
Em figured out the whole game. We can go home now.
yes i claim nicki minaj
But is Nicki Minaj town tho...🤔🤔🤔
I think she's SK
It's also weird how you're set on me being SK since early D1. I don't know where you're getting this accusation but it sounds like you're trying to frame me as bad. This doesn't also sound very random.
I found that a bit sketch too., Why is she focused on sk? is sk a threat to her? or is SHE sk and is trying to distance herself from being the serial killer?
maf doc, maf docblock, bp sk, 4 docs
So hold on. mafia can protect each other from the sk, yes? And sk is protected from the maf. So we need to lynch them all and it's absolutely crucial that we protect each other. interesting mechanic now that the vigs are gone. odds are feeling very against us rn. mafia can protect themselves, kill us, and block us. sk can protect themselves and kill us. wait.
mafia can't self protect can they?
1. Daystart
2. Each Doctor protects against a single nightkill.
3. Doctors cannot self-protect. 4. The Docblocker is a specialised Roleblocker that only blocks Doctors' actions.
5.The Serial Killer is Bulletproof
6. Compulsive means that both Vigs and SK must submit a kill each night. Failure to submit a kill results in them targeting a random player, possibly resulting in killing themselves (the SK is not immune to its own NK).
7.Kill flavours are not distinguished.
"doctors cannot self-protect" so the mafia doc can't either? but can the mafia doc protect their partner?
The mafia doc can very well protect their partner.
Mouse, a Mafia Goon, has been eliminated. It is now Night 1. Night 1 ends at 9pm CDT.
This is a quite surprising but not unexpected turn of events. That quick wagon really brought us somewhere.
Mouse (3)- Luna, Dekay, Broncos
Song (1)- Caro
Very townish wagon on mouse. Luna and dekay are obviously dead townies and broncos i'm townreading for now because she's acting very much the same as she did the past games and seems very chill and helpful as always.
I went back and checked, and it seems like Keyen and sophia were around at the end of the day and didn't vote. caro was around too, but not for when the wagon was formed. it was only really luna, dekay and broncos around for that wagon. i was hoping to get something out of this but not really. if anything, it helped me townread broncos a bit more. and that's never a bad thing.
I don’t think Mouse has done anything that screamed scummy to me. I don’t remember if they’ve even actually posted either.
I’m down with a Song or no elim today. But I’d slightly prefer an elim instead of a no elim.
Although Sophia unvoted Mouse. Idk why she would vote her buddy in the beginning just to unvote her later though.
Could she have been trying to distance herself from Mouse? I wonder if Sophia has ever voted a partner early on before.
It could be, but then again the quickwagon to Mouse was really quick. If Sophia is really Mouse's buddy, she wouldn't have unvoted and participated on the Mouse elim.
Waiting to see what Broncos has to say. Unsure about Keyen and Sophia, but maybe they're just a bit overexcited. Idk. Also Caro? I think, mentioned how DeKay seems a bit excitable, or was at the start of the game. Is it a scum tell? Luna? was saying it's more of a towny tell but then DeKay was town the last game she played and wasn't like this... Maybe not specifically scum as in mafia, but maybe an SK? I can see DeKay being excited to be a solo killer.
I could see DeKay being excited to be a town vig. If I remember correctly, she usually does pretty well with her shots.
I'll do horribly with mine.
Same. I can't be trusted with vig shots
Did you also just...?
I also don't think I'll do very well with my vig shots
This post makes me think Em is SK.
Since both vigs are dead.
Em's post didn't sit right with me from the start. If she's a doctor, why would she jump on Luna's claim and claim for herself? It's unfortunate for her that both Vigs died night, because if she was claiming, it's blown now.
I just checked Luna's game where Sophia was scum and her EMMM vote was Nerd, who ended up flipping town. Sophia is still a neutral read, she hasn't done anything that's made me feel one way or the other.
I think Soph might be more careful when she's scum and I honestly don't feel it on her, but the lack of her posts reminds me of Luna's game where she's just there but not really there and she's scum at that time.
Yeah. Like she was there when she had to be and was very town, but then when she didn't exactly have to be around she was away with the fairies.
true but also like what i said in a past game, dekay kills are usually done out of intimidation rather than strategical and i think in this case, it was still an intimidation kill. probably by someone who's played a fair few games with her but still feel someone intimidated. idk that points me towards... keyen? maybe bella? but i don't see bella being bad this game idk. oh yeah i need to go read back her posts once i catch up. maybe sophia. maybe city. not broncos or caro. although maybe caro. lol.
I never was intimidated by DeKay lol. I've even pushed for her lynched Day 1 when I was scum.
Luna, a Compulsive Vigilante; Song, a Compulsive Vigilante; Nerd, a Doctor; and Dekay, a Doctor have been killed. It is now Day 2. Day 2 will end at 6pm CDT on 7/2/20. With 7 alive, it takes 4 to hammer.
He is fake crying in that gif. are you also fake crying?
1. Luna
2. Broncos
3. Bella
4. Song
5. Mouse
6. Dekay
7. Nerd
8. Emzy
9. Sophia
10. Keyen
11. Caro
12. City
I've only got townreads, no scum reads so far xD. We're dealing with a mafia team of 3, plus a SK. And like 2ish hours to decide on an elimination. Anyone have any leads?
Right now, my PoE is Song -> Keyen -> Nerd. I do think Keyen is acting more accusatory than usual, similar to how he plays as scum.
I don’t think Nerd even realized that she replaced Plumbob.
I agree with this.
HOWWWWWWWWWWWWW
Seemed a bit like too much of an exasperated reaction to be townish, but then maybe it's just a keyen reaction. but also i'm kinda thinking he's acting quite similarly as he did in the last game on UM, and he was scum there.
And I am exasperated because as far as I know, I've never been pushy with anyone. If you think this a scum keyen, then you must agree I've been more accusatory than usual. If so, what posts of mine do you think I'm being accusatory?
Em figured out the whole game. We can go home now.
yes i claim nicki minaj
But is Nicki Minaj town tho...🤔🤔🤔
I think she's SK
It's also weird how you're set on me being SK since early D1. I don't know where you're getting this accusation but it sounds like you're trying to frame me as bad. This doesn't also sound very random.
I found that a bit sketch too., Why is she focused on sk? is sk a threat to her? or is SHE sk and is trying to distance herself from being the serial killer?
Luna, a Compulsive Vigilante; Song, a Compulsive Vigilante; Nerd, a Doctor; and Dekay, a Doctor have been killed. It is now Day 2. Day 2 will end at 6pm CDT on 7/2/20. With 7 alive, it takes 4 to hammer.
He is fake crying in that gif. are you also fake crying?
He isn’t fake crying. He’s shocked & disappointed.
Do you like games that involve strategy? Do you like solving a mystery?
Mouse, a Mafia Goon, has been eliminated. It is now Night 1. Night 1 ends at 9pm CDT.
This is a quite surprising but not unexpected turn of events. That quick wagon really brought us somewhere.
Mouse (3)- Luna, Dekay, Broncos
Song (1)- Caro
Very townish wagon on mouse. Luna and dekay are obviously dead townies and broncos i'm townreading for now because she's acting very much the same as she did the past games and seems very chill and helpful as always.
I went back and checked, and it seems like Keyen and sophia were around at the end of the day and didn't vote. caro was around too, but not for when the wagon was formed. it was only really luna, dekay and broncos around for that wagon. i was hoping to get something out of this but not really. if anything, it helped me townread broncos a bit more. and that's never a bad thing.
As soon as I posted that I'm going to sleep, I went to discord, hanged with yall, then went to sleep and never check the forums. I wasn't around when day ended.
With 7 alive it takes 4 to hammer.
Day ends in about 14 hr.
4 to hammer? I urge you to unvote right now, unless you're scum then i'll forgive. but you guys slipped in with votes so easily. it feels like there's still a fair few of us and a wagon can (evidently) form very quickly. we can't exactly afford a mislynch, as caro pointed out.
Luna, a Compulsive Vigilante; Song, a Compulsive Vigilante; Nerd, a Doctor; and Dekay, a Doctor have been killed. It is now Day 2. Day 2 will end at 6pm CDT on 7/2/20. With 7 alive, it takes 4 to hammer.
He is fake crying in that gif. are you also fake crying?
I'm honestly not surprised if Mouse/Soph/City are the scumteam and Caro is the SK.
Mouse, a Mafia Goon, has been eliminated. It is now Night 1. Night 1 ends at 9pm CDT.
This is a quite surprising but not unexpected turn of events. That quick wagon really brought us somewhere.
Mouse (3)- Luna, Dekay, Broncos
Song (1)- Caro
Very townish wagon on mouse. Luna and dekay are obviously dead townies and broncos i'm townreading for now because she's acting very much the same as she did the past games and seems very chill and helpful as always.
I went back and checked, and it seems like Keyen and sophia were around at the end of the day and didn't vote. caro was around too, but not for when the wagon was formed. it was only really luna, dekay and broncos around for that wagon. i was hoping to get something out of this but not really. if anything, it helped me townread broncos a bit more. and that's never a bad thing.
As soon as I posted that I'm going to sleep, I went to discord, hanged with yall, then went to sleep and never check the forums. I wasn't around when day ended.
Waiting to see what Broncos has to say. Unsure about Keyen and Sophia, but maybe they're just a bit overexcited. Idk. Also Caro? I think, mentioned how DeKay seems a bit excitable, or was at the start of the game. Is it a scum tell? Luna? was saying it's more of a towny tell but then DeKay was town the last game she played and wasn't like this... Maybe not specifically scum as in mafia, but maybe an SK? I can see DeKay being excited to be a solo killer.
I could see DeKay being excited to be a town vig. If I remember correctly, she usually does pretty well with her shots.
I'll do horribly with mine.
Same. I can't be trusted with vig shots
Did you also just...?
I also don't think I'll do very well with my vig shots
This post makes me think Em is SK.
Since both vigs are dead.
Em's post didn't sit right with me from the start. If she's a doctor, why would she jump on Luna's claim and claim for herself? It's unfortunate for her that both Vigs died night, because if she was claiming, it's blown now.
I didn't actually claim vig lol. Do you think I'm stupid? I was trying to "cover up" Luna's claim
I was hoping she wouldn't comment on her slip-up but then she did. I feel bad for Luna that she did that slip-up but i'm a bit bothered by the fact she actually went and cemented her claim and not letting it get lost under posts. i was trying to help her claim get lost under posts.
Idk if I believe that. She already outed herself before you posted that. Like it was pretty much clear.
well
idk what else to say. that's what was what. even if i was actually a vig, i wouldn't claim in such a scenario. so on that same page of logic, why would i then fake claim as scum if i wouldn't claim as vig? Sophia jokingly claimed, and i jokingly claimed too. it was half a joke and half trying to bury the claim, if i could do anything to help at all.
but then obviously as keyen said, he voted luna and i also questioned luna out in the open which perhaps really didn't help. and me not even protecting luna at all didn't help either xD
Em figured out the whole game. We can go home now.
yes i claim nicki minaj
But is Nicki Minaj town tho...🤔🤔🤔
I think she's SK
It's also weird how you're set on me being SK since early D1. I don't know where you're getting this accusation but it sounds like you're trying to frame me as bad. This doesn't also sound very random.
I found that a bit sketch too., Why is she focused on sk? is sk a threat to her? or is SHE sk and is trying to distance herself from being the serial killer?
I brought up SK on D1 because I thought DeKay could be it. I don't think I've been too focused on it though? Maybe I didn't notice lol
But the only way to kill the SK is with our vote. The same applies to mafia now too though since the vigs are dead.
Why did nobody else protected Luna though? After her claim she was an obvious target imo.
I protected Broncos because I thought other people would be on Luna
okokok
i think it's better to, if you're actually a doctor, to protect someone anyway, even if you think other people will protect her.
we can only protect against ONE kill per night, so in the case like luna's where it's very possible that both mafia and sk could have targeted her, it's important to have as many docs as possible on luna. that was my line of thinking anyway.
in the end, in reality, it didn't even matter because someone must have gotten blocked and everyone else protected the wrong people. but yeah, general rule of thumb i think it's better to be safe than sorry. and now we're sorry.
Comments
I protected Broncos because I thought other people would be on Luna
ok anyway where was i
Luna- I can see anyone killing luna because of that claim. But what I don't understand is why didn't more people protect luna? I'm gonna come right up right now and say i'm really sorry, i thought i did protect luna. i sent rose and nush a list way earlier of just people i was thinking might be good and luna was at the top. when luna claimed, i remembered that list but forgot i sent another list and went to bed without double checking my protection
Song- I think this was a vig shot. DeKay voted song and then unvoted song and was suspecting song a lot. they had a lot of interaction day 1.
Nerd- seems like a vig shot too
Dekay- seems like a scum kill because of what i said earlier about dekay kills being more due to feeling intimidated as opposed to... not. (i did not post this earlier. i wrote it below but i wrote it earlier than i wrote this lol) plus song and nerd just seem like "let's see if they're scum" kills because we had such trouble reading them last time
unless rose is following a kill reveal order like mafia>sk>vigs in which case maf killed luna, sk killed song and the vigs killed nerd and dekay.
true but also like what i said in a past game, dekay kills are usually done out of intimidation rather than strategical and i think in this case, it was still an intimidation kill. probably by someone who's played a fair few games with her but still feel someone intimidated. idk that points me towards... keyen? maybe bella? but i don't see bella being bad this game idk. oh yeah i need to go read back her posts once i catch up. maybe sophia. maybe city. not broncos or caro. although maybe caro. lol.
Sims 4 Bachelorette Series
My YooToob Channul
My First Mafia Game (stuff)
well let's heckin hope not
Sims 4 Bachelorette Series
My YooToob Channul
My First Mafia Game (stuff)
I think in general, yeah, off topic chatter/a hyper focus on mechanics can be a scumtell because it's nervousness and avoiding the topic that they have to lie about
i don't remember many on-topic bella posts.
here are bella's on-topic posts
That's it.
Also while scrolling i saw this-
Seemed a bit like too much of an exasperated reaction to be townish, but then maybe it's just a keyen reaction. but also i'm kinda thinking he's acting quite similarly as he did in the last game on UM, and he was scum there.
Sims 4 Bachelorette Series
My YooToob Channul
My First Mafia Game (stuff)
Did he see he saw the logic in it? sketch.
Sims 4 Bachelorette Series
My YooToob Channul
My First Mafia Game (stuff)
I found that a bit sketch too., Why is she focused on sk? is sk a threat to her? or is SHE sk and is trying to distance herself from being the serial killer?
Sims 4 Bachelorette Series
My YooToob Channul
My First Mafia Game (stuff)
The mafia doc can very well protect their partner.
Mouse (3)- Luna, Dekay, Broncos
Song (1)- Caro
Very townish wagon on mouse. Luna and dekay are obviously dead townies and broncos i'm townreading for now because she's acting very much the same as she did the past games and seems very chill and helpful as always.
I went back and checked, and it seems like Keyen and sophia were around at the end of the day and didn't vote. caro was around too, but not for when the wagon was formed. it was only really luna, dekay and broncos around for that wagon. i was hoping to get something out of this but not really. if anything, it helped me townread broncos a bit more. and that's never a bad thing.
Sims 4 Bachelorette Series
My YooToob Channul
My First Mafia Game (stuff)
VOTE: City? Maybe? I don’t think I’ve seen many posts from her.
Hm. Keyen's posts today are seeming more townish.
Sims 4 Bachelorette Series
My YooToob Channul
My First Mafia Game (stuff)
rude
Sims 4 Bachelorette Series
My YooToob Channul
My First Mafia Game (stuff)
Yeah. Like she was there when she had to be and was very town, but then when she didn't exactly have to be around she was away with the fairies.
Sims 4 Bachelorette Series
My YooToob Channul
My First Mafia Game (stuff)
I never was intimidated by DeKay lol. I've even pushed for her lynched Day 1 when I was scum.
He is fake crying in that gif. are you also fake crying?
Sims 4 Bachelorette Series
My YooToob Channul
My First Mafia Game (stuff)
And I am exasperated because as far as I know, I've never been pushy with anyone. If you think this a scum keyen, then you must agree I've been more accusatory than usual. If so, what posts of mine do you think I'm being accusatory?
That's what I'm trying to say.
As soon as I posted that I'm going to sleep, I went to discord, hanged with yall, then went to sleep and never check the forums. I wasn't around when day ended.
4 to hammer? I urge you to unvote right now, unless you're scum then i'll forgive. but you guys slipped in with votes so easily. it feels like there's still a fair few of us and a wagon can (evidently) form very quickly. we can't exactly afford a mislynch, as caro pointed out.
Sims 4 Bachelorette Series
My YooToob Channul
My First Mafia Game (stuff)
I'm honestly not surprised if Mouse/Soph/City are the scumteam and Caro is the SK.
yeah i did the same lol
Sims 4 Bachelorette Series
My YooToob Channul
My First Mafia Game (stuff)
My Sims 3 Page | My Studio | Check out my Sims 3 Let's Play
Play mafia with us: www.ultimatemafia.boards.net
well
idk what else to say. that's what was what. even if i was actually a vig, i wouldn't claim in such a scenario. so on that same page of logic, why would i then fake claim as scum if i wouldn't claim as vig? Sophia jokingly claimed, and i jokingly claimed too. it was half a joke and half trying to bury the claim, if i could do anything to help at all.
but then obviously as keyen said, he voted luna and i also questioned luna out in the open which perhaps really didn't help. and me not even protecting luna at all didn't help either xD
Sims 4 Bachelorette Series
My YooToob Channul
My First Mafia Game (stuff)
I brought up SK on D1 because I thought DeKay could be it. I don't think I've been too focused on it though? Maybe I didn't notice lol
But the only way to kill the SK is with our vote. The same applies to mafia now too though since the vigs are dead.
My Sims 3 Page | My Studio | Check out my Sims 3 Let's Play
Play mafia with us: www.ultimatemafia.boards.net
okokok
i think it's better to, if you're actually a doctor, to protect someone anyway, even if you think other people will protect her.
we can only protect against ONE kill per night, so in the case like luna's where it's very possible that both mafia and sk could have targeted her, it's important to have as many docs as possible on luna. that was my line of thinking anyway.
in the end, in reality, it didn't even matter because someone must have gotten blocked and everyone else protected the wrong people. but yeah, general rule of thumb i think it's better to be safe than sorry. and now we're sorry.
Sims 4 Bachelorette Series
My YooToob Channul
My First Mafia Game (stuff)