Forum Announcement, Click Here to Read More From EA_Cade.

Tarot Major Arcana Mafia Game - Reversed Cards (Mafia) Win!

Comments

  • Options
    Meepy!!Meepy!! Posts: 260 Member
    I'd say that I'm a newbie, I've only played in two games.
  • Options
    FloppyFishFloppyFish Posts: 3,881 Member
    I guess I am a newbie too... this is my second game xDDD
    Mafia Stats
    Games Played: 14 | Games Won: 8 | Games Lost: 6
    Times Town: 9 | Times Mafia: 2 | Times 3rd: 2
    Town Wins: 6 | Mafia Wins: 1 | 3rd Wins: 1
    Deaths: 8

  • Options
    MissSassyMissSassy Posts: 9,731 Member
    Good question... Let me check the ones I know are more experienced: (just guesses)

    Sonschi --> 3rd game
    Broncos4life --> experienced (not too sure)
    bellagorilla --> maybe her 6th game
    DeKay --> 5th game
    FloppyFish--> 2n (your siggi)
    Zinniavanilla --> several games already, probably experienced
    emilzydiva --> no clue, sry
    lovesstorms --> not sure as well
    Kandy --> I've only read Sub's game and there she was very active and a lot of input, so probably experienced
    SilentWolf101 --> I tend to say experienced
    TRibbo24 --> experienced?
    Meepy!! --> 3rd game
    Lyoufln --> same here
    HappyFuzzyKitty --> no clue again :D
    TheRoseHorse, Discarded Night 1 --> dead :(


    I don't know if this is helpful at all :joy:

    Let's say, the mafia consists of mainly "newbies"/less experienced ones, those would be (imo):

    Sonschi
    Floppy
    Meepy
    Lyoufln

    Of course I exclude myself ( :D ) because I know I'm town and I would have killed someone more active. That would leave Floppy, Meepy and Lyoufln.

    BUT ít could also just be that the mafia wants to confuse us to think this way. And now my "theory" sounds scummy :D

    I'm not voting yet because there are still 23.5 hours left. I wouldn't know who to vote anyway. But maybe this little theory could've helped someone get another idea.
  • Options
    Broncos4lifeBroncos4life Posts: 11,798 Member
    For those who have played with me before know all about my experienced player goes down night one with an experienced mafia. My guess is either it was a random kill, or we have an inexperienced mafia, maybe with a veteran not around.
    Do you like solving a mystery? Come join a mafia game!
    Link: here!

    71t7p4hX88L._AC_SL1500_.jpg
  • Options
    FloppyFishFloppyFish Posts: 3,881 Member
    That makes sense.
    Mafia Stats
    Games Played: 14 | Games Won: 8 | Games Lost: 6
    Times Town: 9 | Times Mafia: 2 | Times 3rd: 2
    Town Wins: 6 | Mafia Wins: 1 | 3rd Wins: 1
    Deaths: 8

  • Options
    LyouflnLyoufln Posts: 10,861 Member
    @Sonschi this is my 2nd game. Also, I'm trying to be more active because it's fun to chat here! YAY!
  • Options
    FloppyFishFloppyFish Posts: 3,881 Member
    Lyloufln and meepy have you ever had a power role or been mafia before in your games?
    Mafia Stats
    Games Played: 14 | Games Won: 8 | Games Lost: 6
    Times Town: 9 | Times Mafia: 2 | Times 3rd: 2
    Town Wins: 6 | Mafia Wins: 1 | 3rd Wins: 1
    Deaths: 8

  • Options
    MissSassyMissSassy Posts: 9,731 Member
    I just checked Broncos' game (the last game before this one?) and it says that Meepy and Lyoufln have been town. I couldn't find Floppy on the player's list but the siggi says town as well. So all three have only been town so far and might not know the "unwritten rule" ( :D sounds weird) that mafia tends to kill more active players first.

    I actually hoped that at least one of you was already mafia to exclude those from the "scummy list". Still considering, the mafia has no (active) veteran....
  • Options
    TheRoseHorseTheRoseHorse Posts: 7,300 Member
    Noooo. Avenge meeeeee. Go townies! Find the Mafia!
    Even the Most Beautiful Rose has been through the Dirt
  • Options
    TheRoseHorseTheRoseHorse Posts: 7,300 Member
    Sonschi wrote: »
    I just checked Broncos' game (the last game before this one?) and it says that Meepy and Lyoufln have been town. I couldn't find Floppy on the player's list but the siggi says town as well. So all three have only been town so far and might not know the "unwritten rule" ( :D sounds weird) that mafia tends to kill more active players first.

    I actually hoped that at least one of you was already mafia to exclude those from the "scummy list". Still considering, the mafia has no (active) veteran....
    The one before this one was mine, not broncos
    Even the Most Beautiful Rose has been through the Dirt
  • Options
    LyouflnLyoufln Posts: 10,861 Member
    @Sonschi I've never heard of any unwritten rule, thought I may have picked up on it during Broncos' mafia game.

    Also, I was a townie last time!
  • Options
    MissSassyMissSassy Posts: 9,731 Member
    Sonschi wrote: »
    I just checked Broncos' game (the last game before this one?) and it says that Meepy and Lyoufln have been town. I couldn't find Floppy on the player's list but the siggi says town as well. So all three have only been town so far and might not know the "unwritten rule" ( :D sounds weird) that mafia tends to kill more active players first.

    I actually hoped that at least one of you was already mafia to exclude those from the "scummy list". Still considering, the mafia has no (active) veteran....
    The one before this one was mine, not broncos

    Thank you! :) I just checked and the things I wrote above still apply.

    Btw, I saw you floating around looking for ghost popcorn: (~',')~ \_/ :p
  • Options
    MissSassyMissSassy Posts: 9,731 Member
    Lyoufln wrote: »
    @Sonschi I've never heard of any unwritten rule, thought I may have picked up on it during Broncos' mafia game.

    Also, I was a townie last time!

    There's no actual "unwritten rule" :sweat_smile: Didn't know how to express it otherwise. I just meant the common strategy from mafia players to get rid of active players first :)

    SORRY FOR DOUBLE POSTING.
  • Options
    TheRoseHorseTheRoseHorse Posts: 7,300 Member
    edited August 2017
    I loooove ghooooost popcooooorn.
    Even the Most Beautiful Rose has been through the Dirt
  • Options
    LyouflnLyoufln Posts: 10,861 Member
    @FloppyFish this is my second game, and I was a townie the first time. I've never been mafia/had a power role, though that would be fun!
  • Options
    MissSassyMissSassy Posts: 9,731 Member
    Has anyone suspicions about anyone yet? I have the bad feeling my theory is nonsense... or at least not very helpful.
  • Options
    EmzyDalsvidaEmzyDalsvida Posts: 15,617 Member
    DeKay wrote: »
    I like the "what doesn't kill you makes you stronger" quote.

    I meant to reply to this conversation but seemed to have forgotten. It's a quote from a song from Eurovision, 2016. Germany's entry.

    "Our life won’t wait for us to live"

    But, that's just one of many many quotes I love.
  • Options
    EmzyDalsvidaEmzyDalsvida Posts: 15,617 Member
    icmnfrsh wrote: »
    The fortune teller enters her tent back when the sun is up. A peculiar sight beholds her.

    "Why, it seems that the fates had something else in mind. I believe they're telling me that now is not the time for introspection and listening to your inner voice. Decisive action must be taken in order to take charge of your fate."

    TheRoseHorse, the Hermit, has been discarded.

    It is now Day 2
    With 14 players alive, it takes 8 to hammer.

    rip Horse The Rose

  • Options
    EmzyDalsvidaEmzyDalsvida Posts: 15,617 Member
    I'm gonna guess that unless one of you are particularly friendly with the deceased Rose The Horse, then this was a random kill. As FishyFlop said. Sometimes friends like to murder friends because they know it's safe and no hard feelings will be felt. xD

    And as sonschi suggested, it would indeed be more strategic for mafia to kill off a more active member. So it doesn't make sense if they were trying to be strategic for them to turn around and kill off someone who made it a point to say they won't be as active as usual.

    So basically the death of TehHorseyRosey points us in no direction as to who the abominable murderer is. Yay!
  • Options
    EmzyDalsvidaEmzyDalsvida Posts: 15,617 Member
    Addressing your list of trying to figure out the newbs, Sonschi, myself and lovesstorms are definately not. xD

    Also I saw FishFlopper has stats and I like stats. Maybe I'll add them in my signature because... stats.
  • Options
    MissSassyMissSassy Posts: 9,731 Member
    @emilzydiva I love how you change @FloppyFish 's name every time you use it :D
  • Options
    FloppyFishFloppyFish Posts: 3,881 Member
    xD she did that to rose.
    Mafia Stats
    Games Played: 14 | Games Won: 8 | Games Lost: 6
    Times Town: 9 | Times Mafia: 2 | Times 3rd: 2
    Town Wins: 6 | Mafia Wins: 1 | 3rd Wins: 1
    Deaths: 8

  • Options
    FloppyFishFloppyFish Posts: 3,881 Member
    FloppyFish wrote: »
    xD she did that to rose also xD.

    Mafia Stats
    Games Played: 14 | Games Won: 8 | Games Lost: 6
    Times Town: 9 | Times Mafia: 2 | Times 3rd: 2
    Town Wins: 6 | Mafia Wins: 1 | 3rd Wins: 1
    Deaths: 8

  • Options
    EmzyDalsvidaEmzyDalsvida Posts: 15,617 Member
  • Options
    FloppyFishFloppyFish Posts: 3,881 Member
    haha.

    you know what they say...

    mafias tend to burn their pizza
    Mafia Stats
    Games Played: 14 | Games Won: 8 | Games Lost: 6
    Times Town: 9 | Times Mafia: 2 | Times 3rd: 2
    Town Wins: 6 | Mafia Wins: 1 | 3rd Wins: 1
    Deaths: 8

Sign In or Register to comment.
Return to top