Lucky that is not how you host. You do not change a player's role just because you want mafia to win.
I was the shadows,
Town win.
I know I was joking? I was waiting for your reaction
Nonetheless, Sub is right - that is not how you host. You don't 'joke around' when you host, especially with roles and lynchings. Stuff like that isn't easy to discern over the internet. Plus, it can easily confuse players and change the course of a game. That is not how you host; even if it was a joke, that is not how you host.
Just give the players the information that you're supposed to supply without any toppings or embellishing - it's easiest to do it that way for everybody's sake.
You made a 'joke' about Zinnia earlier on in the game (I believe it was about whether she was mafia, and I also believe it may have been sarcastic) and a lot of players spent a lot of time speculating whether it was indeed a joke or serious.
I'm honestly just glad the game is over, to be honest. Multiple things frustrated me about this game, but it was kinda fun, I guess?
Anyway, almost convinced me you were town, Sub. Almost. I was left wondering what would happen if you did turn out to be town after all - that would be embarrasing! I'm happy I was correct, though: we did it, town! I was also at the point of slightly suspecting Broncos, for some strange reason. But I'm glad I didn't act on that feeling; very glad! Everyone played well, to be fair.
MAFIA STATS
Played: 18 | Won: 9 | Lost: 9
Town Wins: 4 | Mafia Wins: 5 | Third Wins: 0
Played as Town: 10 | Played as Mafia: 9 | Played as Third: 1
Lucky that is not how you host. You do not change a player's role just because you want mafia to win.
I was the shadows,
Town win.
I know I was joking? I was waiting for your reaction
Nonetheless, Sub is right - that is not how you host. You don't 'joke around' when you host, especially with roles and lynchings. Stuff like that isn't easy to discern over the internet. Plus, it can easily confuse players and change the course of a game. That is not how you host; even if it was a joke, that is not how you host.
Just give the players the information that you're supposed to supply without any toppings or embellishing - it's easiest to do it that way for everybody's sake.
You made a 'joke' about Zinnia earlier on in the game (I believe it was about whether she was mafia, and I also believe it may have been sarcastic) and a lot of players spent a lot of time speculating whether it was indeed a joke or serious.
I'm honestly just glad the game is over, to be honest. Multiple things frustrated me about this game, but it was kinda fun, I guess?
Anyway, almost convinced me you were town, Sub. Almost. I was left wondering what would happen if you did turn out to be town after all - that would be embarrasing! I'm happy I was correct, though: we did it, town! I was also at the point of slightly suspecting Broncos, for some strange reason. But I'm glad I didn't act on that feeling; very glad! Everyone played well, to be fair.
Lucky that is not how you host. You do not change a player's role just because you want mafia to win.
I was the shadows,
Town win.
I know I was joking? I was waiting for your reaction
Nonetheless, Sub is right - that is not how you host. You don't 'joke around' when you host, especially with roles and lynchings. Stuff like that isn't easy to discern over the internet. Plus, it can easily confuse players and change the course of a game. That is not how you host; even if it was a joke, that is not how you host.
Just give the players the information that you're supposed to supply without any toppings or embellishing - it's easiest to do it that way for everybody's sake.
You made a 'joke' about Zinnia earlier on in the game (I believe it was about whether she was mafia, and I also believe it may have been sarcastic) and a lot of players spent a lot of time speculating whether it was indeed a joke or serious.
I'm honestly just glad the game is over, to be honest. Multiple things frustrated me about this game, but it was kinda fun, I guess?
Anyway, almost convinced me you were town, Sub. Almost. I was left wondering what would happen if you did turn out to be town after all - that would be embarrasing! I'm happy I was correct, though: we did it, town! I was also at the point of slightly suspecting Broncos, for some strange reason. But I'm glad I didn't act on that feeling; very glad! Everyone played well, to be fair.
I'm really glad I made it that far as the shadows.
I also wish I had saved my shadows night kill to kill you, TRibbo, but all of the ghosts told me it would be a good idea to kill to confuse people, I knew you would be an obstacle! xD
Now, I don't mean to continue the criticism rudely, but:
As for the things I have highlighted, it can completely change the course of the game, I was completely confused myself, as maf, who was even mafia anymore. In the mafia chat, Lucky kept on siding with me, trying to 'help' me, and further placing this into the came. As a host, you cannot be bias towards either town or mafia, you have to be consistently fair and you can't try and push the other team past the finishing line. You need to equally share out the 'help cake' or however you may imagine it. Each player gets one slice, or none at all.
I'm also glad the game is over, half of the time I was stuck in the mud and unsure of what to do or how to tackle the obstacles that were town xD. Once Ghetto was killed, I was stumped, and I honestly wished it was me, not her, that was lynched. (For the sake of our win, of course.) After the first slip up in this game, everything kind of went downhill from there, and this is by far the longest, most confusing game of mafia I have ever played.
None of the above was to hurt or offend anyone, just to make it clear. Reading through it I realise it could seem harsh or mean, but it isn't intended in that way and now as I'm writing this sentence I also realise how formal my writing is for no reason, help me. Anyway, well played, everyone, it was fun while it lasted, minus the confusion and slips and everything else that was added to this odd game.
Thank you @LuckyKittenCat for hosting, seeing as you had only played a few games prior to hosting, I understand why you may have messed up a couple times, and I didn't mean to attack you if I did.
I won Game of the Year in the 2nd annual Scummies Awards!
Lucky that is not how you host. You do not change a player's role just because you want mafia to win.
I was the shadows,
Town win.
I know I was joking? I was waiting for your reaction
Nonetheless, Sub is right - that is not how you host. You don't 'joke around' when you host, especially with roles and lynchings. Stuff like that isn't easy to discern over the internet. Plus, it can easily confuse players and change the course of a game. That is not how you host; even if it was a joke, that is not how you host.
Just give the players the information that you're supposed to supply without any toppings or embellishing - it's easiest to do it that way for everybody's sake.
You made a 'joke' about Zinnia earlier on in the game (I believe it was about whether she was mafia, and I also believe it may have been sarcastic) and a lot of players spent a lot of time speculating whether it was indeed a joke or serious.
I'm honestly just glad the game is over, to be honest. Multiple things frustrated me about this game, but it was kinda fun, I guess?
Anyway, almost convinced me you were town, Sub. Almost. I was left wondering what would happen if you did turn out to be town after all - that would be embarrasing! I'm happy I was correct, though: we did it, town! I was also at the point of slightly suspecting Broncos, for some strange reason. But I'm glad I didn't act on that feeling; very glad! Everyone played well, to be fair.
I'm really glad I made it that far as the shadows.
I also wish I had saved my shadows night kill to kill you, TRibbo, but all of the ghosts told me it would be a good idea to kill to confuse people, I knew you would be an obstacle! xD
I think it was because you were inactive for quite a while at the beginning - with good reasons, of course - that you advanced so far in the game. At first, I thought you were town, but as the numbers dropped, I started suspecting you. It came out of nowhere, like the Ghettox gut feeling (that was so long ago I forget it happened in this game) that I had.
You played well though, Sub. I can't deny that.
MAFIA STATS
Played: 18 | Won: 9 | Lost: 9
Town Wins: 4 | Mafia Wins: 5 | Third Wins: 0
Played as Town: 10 | Played as Mafia: 9 | Played as Third: 1
Lucky that is not how you host. You do not change a player's role just because you want mafia to win.
I was the shadows,
Town win.
I know I was joking? I was waiting for your reaction
Nonetheless, Sub is right - that is not how you host. You don't 'joke around' when you host, especially with roles and lynchings. Stuff like that isn't easy to discern over the internet. Plus, it can easily confuse players and change the course of a game. That is not how you host; even if it was a joke, that is not how you host.
Just give the players the information that you're supposed to supply without any toppings or embellishing - it's easiest to do it that way for everybody's sake.
You made a 'joke' about Zinnia earlier on in the game (I believe it was about whether she was mafia, and I also believe it may have been sarcastic) and a lot of players spent a lot of time speculating whether it was indeed a joke or serious.
I'm honestly just glad the game is over, to be honest. Multiple things frustrated me about this game, but it was kinda fun, I guess?
Anyway, almost convinced me you were town, Sub. Almost. I was left wondering what would happen if you did turn out to be town after all - that would be embarrasing! I'm happy I was correct, though: we did it, town! I was also at the point of slightly suspecting Broncos, for some strange reason. But I'm glad I didn't act on that feeling; very glad! Everyone played well, to be fair.
I'm really glad I made it that far as the shadows.
I also wish I had saved my shadows night kill to kill you, TRibbo, but all of the ghosts told me it would be a good idea to kill to confuse people, I knew you would be an obstacle! xD
I think it was because you were inactive for quite a while at the beginning - with good reasons, of course - that you advanced so far in the game. At first, I thought you were town, but as the numbers dropped, I started suspecting you. It came out of nowhere, like the Ghettox gut feeling (that was so long ago I forget it happened in this game) that I had.
Lucky that is not how you host. You do not change a player's role just because you want mafia to win.
I was the shadows,
Town win.
I know I was joking? I was waiting for your reaction
Nonetheless, Sub is right - that is not how you host. You don't 'joke around' when you host, especially with roles and lynchings. Stuff like that isn't easy to discern over the internet. Plus, it can easily confuse players and change the course of a game. That is not how you host; even if it was a joke, that is not how you host.
Just give the players the information that you're supposed to supply without any toppings or embellishing - it's easiest to do it that way for everybody's sake.
You made a 'joke' about Zinnia earlier on in the game (I believe it was about whether she was mafia, and I also believe it may have been sarcastic) and a lot of players spent a lot of time speculating whether it was indeed a joke or serious.
I'm honestly just glad the game is over, to be honest. Multiple things frustrated me about this game, but it was kinda fun, I guess?
Anyway, almost convinced me you were town, Sub. Almost. I was left wondering what would happen if you did turn out to be town after all - that would be embarrasing! I'm happy I was correct, though: we did it, town! I was also at the point of slightly suspecting Broncos, for some strange reason. But I'm glad I didn't act on that feeling; very glad! Everyone played well, to be fair.
I'm really glad I made it that far as the shadows.
I also wish I had saved my shadows night kill to kill you, TRibbo, but all of the ghosts told me it would be a good idea to kill to confuse people, I knew you would be an obstacle! xD
I think it was because you were inactive for quite a while at the beginning - with good reasons, of course - that you advanced so far in the game. At first, I thought you were town, but as the numbers dropped, I started suspecting you. It came out of nowhere, like the Ghettox gut feeling (that was so long ago I forget it happened in this game) that I had.
You played well though, Sub. I can't deny that.
The guy behind the green-haired guy in your sig (the one who's face is hidden) looks a lot like Steve Holt Yeah?
Lucky that is not how you host. You do not change a player's role just because you want mafia to win.
I was the shadows,
Town win.
I know I was joking? I was waiting for your reaction
Nonetheless, Sub is right - that is not how you host. You don't 'joke around' when you host, especially with roles and lynchings. Stuff like that isn't easy to discern over the internet. Plus, it can easily confuse players and change the course of a game. That is not how you host; even if it was a joke, that is not how you host.
Just give the players the information that you're supposed to supply without any toppings or embellishing - it's easiest to do it that way for everybody's sake.
You made a 'joke' about Zinnia earlier on in the game (I believe it was about whether she was mafia, and I also believe it may have been sarcastic) and a lot of players spent a lot of time speculating whether it was indeed a joke or serious.
I'm honestly just glad the game is over, to be honest. Multiple things frustrated me about this game, but it was kinda fun, I guess?
Anyway, almost convinced me you were town, Sub. Almost. I was left wondering what would happen if you did turn out to be town after all - that would be embarrasing! I'm happy I was correct, though: we did it, town! I was also at the point of slightly suspecting Broncos, for some strange reason. But I'm glad I didn't act on that feeling; very glad! Everyone played well, to be fair.
I'm really glad I made it that far as the shadows.
I also wish I had saved my shadows night kill to kill you, TRibbo, but all of the ghosts told me it would be a good idea to kill to confuse people, I knew you would be an obstacle! xD
I think it was because you were inactive for quite a while at the beginning - with good reasons, of course - that you advanced so far in the game. At first, I thought you were town, but as the numbers dropped, I started suspecting you. It came out of nowhere, like the Ghettox gut feeling (that was so long ago I forget it happened in this game) that I had.
You played well though, Sub. I can't deny that.
The guy behind the green-haired guy in your sig (the one who's face is hidden) looks a lot like Steve Holt Yeah?
Hoseok? Not really
MAFIA STATS
Played: 18 | Won: 9 | Lost: 9
Town Wins: 4 | Mafia Wins: 5 | Third Wins: 0
Played as Town: 10 | Played as Mafia: 9 | Played as Third: 1
Lucky that is not how you host. You do not change a player's role just because you want mafia to win.
I was the shadows,
Town win.
I know I was joking? I was waiting for your reaction
Nonetheless, Sub is right - that is not how you host. You don't 'joke around' when you host, especially with roles and lynchings. Stuff like that isn't easy to discern over the internet. Plus, it can easily confuse players and change the course of a game. That is not how you host; even if it was a joke, that is not how you host.
Just give the players the information that you're supposed to supply without any toppings or embellishing - it's easiest to do it that way for everybody's sake.
You made a 'joke' about Zinnia earlier on in the game (I believe it was about whether she was mafia, and I also believe it may have been sarcastic) and a lot of players spent a lot of time speculating whether it was indeed a joke or serious.
I'm honestly just glad the game is over, to be honest. Multiple things frustrated me about this game, but it was kinda fun, I guess?
Anyway, almost convinced me you were town, Sub. Almost. I was left wondering what would happen if you did turn out to be town after all - that would be embarrasing! I'm happy I was correct, though: we did it, town! I was also at the point of slightly suspecting Broncos, for some strange reason. But I'm glad I didn't act on that feeling; very glad! Everyone played well, to be fair.
I'm really glad I made it that far as the shadows.
I also wish I had saved my shadows night kill to kill you, TRibbo, but all of the ghosts told me it would be a good idea to kill to confuse people, I knew you would be an obstacle! xD
I think it was because you were inactive for quite a while at the beginning - with good reasons, of course - that you advanced so far in the game. At first, I thought you were town, but as the numbers dropped, I started suspecting you. It came out of nowhere, like the Ghettox gut feeling (that was so long ago I forget it happened in this game) that I had.
You played well though, Sub. I can't deny that.
The guy behind the green-haired guy in your sig (the one who's face is hidden) looks a lot like Steve Holt Yeah?
Hoseok? Not really
No no. Look at the jacket. And the way that they are posing(?) if you can't see their faces then it looks similar.
Comments
Town Wins: 4 | Mafia Wins: 5 | Third Wins: 0
Played as Town: 10 | Played as Mafia: 9 | Played as Third: 1
and Lucky keeps messing around with us, I don't know what's what and who's alive now.
+1
Town Wins: 4 | Mafia Wins: 5 | Third Wins: 0
Played as Town: 10 | Played as Mafia: 9 | Played as Third: 1
But wasn't it 2,2?
Dey were mafia
I was the shadows,
Town win.
Nonetheless, Sub is right - that is not how you host. You don't 'joke around' when you host, especially with roles and lynchings. Stuff like that isn't easy to discern over the internet. Plus, it can easily confuse players and change the course of a game. That is not how you host; even if it was a joke, that is not how you host.
Just give the players the information that you're supposed to supply without any toppings or embellishing - it's easiest to do it that way for everybody's sake.
You made a 'joke' about Zinnia earlier on in the game (I believe it was about whether she was mafia, and I also believe it may have been sarcastic) and a lot of players spent a lot of time speculating whether it was indeed a joke or serious.
I'm honestly just glad the game is over, to be honest. Multiple things frustrated me about this game, but it was kinda fun, I guess?
Anyway, almost convinced me you were town, Sub. Almost. I was left wondering what would happen if you did turn out to be town after all - that would be embarrasing! I'm happy I was correct, though: we did it, town! I was also at the point of slightly suspecting Broncos, for some strange reason. But I'm glad I didn't act on that feeling; very glad! Everyone played well, to be fair.
Town Wins: 4 | Mafia Wins: 5 | Third Wins: 0
Played as Town: 10 | Played as Mafia: 9 | Played as Third: 1
You can edit your post, now.......
'-'
??
Ava didn't vote, also I was +1-ing Sub's comment, which is why I quoted it.
Town Wins: 4 | Mafia Wins: 5 | Third Wins: 0
Played as Town: 10 | Played as Mafia: 9 | Played as Third: 1
+1
Town Wins: 4 | Mafia Wins: 5 | Third Wins: 0
Played as Town: 10 | Played as Mafia: 9 | Played as Third: 1
+2
Link: here!
+3
+4
I'm really glad I made it that far as the shadows.
I also wish I had saved my shadows night kill to kill you, TRibbo, but all of the ghosts told me it would be a good idea to kill to confuse people, I knew you would be an obstacle! xD
Now, I don't mean to continue the criticism rudely, but:
As for the things I have highlighted, it can completely change the course of the game, I was completely confused myself, as maf, who was even mafia anymore. In the mafia chat, Lucky kept on siding with me, trying to 'help' me, and further placing this into the came. As a host, you cannot be bias towards either town or mafia, you have to be consistently fair and you can't try and push the other team past the finishing line. You need to equally share out the 'help cake' or however you may imagine it. Each player gets one slice, or none at all.
I'm also glad the game is over, half of the time I was stuck in the mud and unsure of what to do or how to tackle the obstacles that were town xD. Once Ghetto was killed, I was stumped, and I honestly wished it was me, not her, that was lynched. (For the sake of our win, of course.) After the first slip up in this game, everything kind of went downhill from there, and this is by far the longest, most confusing game of mafia I have ever played.
None of the above was to hurt or offend anyone, just to make it clear. Reading through it I realise it could seem harsh or mean, but it isn't intended in that way and now as I'm writing this sentence I also realise how formal my writing is for no reason, help me.
Thank you @LuckyKittenCat for hosting, seeing as you had only played a few games prior to hosting, I understand why you may have messed up a couple times, and I didn't mean to attack you if I did.
I think it was because you were inactive for quite a while at the beginning - with good reasons, of course - that you advanced so far in the game. At first, I thought you were town, but as the numbers dropped, I started suspecting you. It came out of nowhere, like the Ghettox gut feeling (that was so long ago I forget it happened in this game) that I had.
You played well though, Sub. I can't deny that.
Town Wins: 4 | Mafia Wins: 5 | Third Wins: 0
Played as Town: 10 | Played as Mafia: 9 | Played as Third: 1
Yeah, good game. @DatSubmarineYourLookingFor @GhettoxRainbows
although to be fair, Lucky messed up one of my night roles which altered my suspicions.
The guy behind the green-haired guy in your sig (the one who's face is hidden) looks a lot like Steve Holt
Hoseok? Not really
Town Wins: 4 | Mafia Wins: 5 | Third Wins: 0
Played as Town: 10 | Played as Mafia: 9 | Played as Third: 1
No no. Look at the jacket. And the way that they are posing(?) if you can't see their faces then it looks similar.