...And why the actual heck are there three deaths?! How is that even possible??
Lala probably wanted to kill Mouse and Nerd hid behind Lala and mafia killed Lala.
Okay, fine. And that makes sense. Last night, I was sent an anonymous message by someone telling me “Lala was visited by Mouse last night”. Now, this could be one of two things:
A. A townie with the messenger ability trying to help
B. A mafia with the messenger ability trying to throw us off
I wonder how they know that though, if they have the messenger ability? Unless they have 2 abilities, which I don’t know is possible.
I think that might be a mafia trying to throw us off. How would they know that on N1? I don't see it being possible. Plus, Mouse died, so it wouldnt matter anyways.
Even the Most Beautiful Rose has been through the Dirt
No i feel like it's a little too obvious and no mafia would do this, but I kind of feel like the 'coincidence' of both city & sophia getting on around the same time and both of their claims just fitting together was kind of ... eh.
But just,, guys,, it was just a split-second thought, i'm not accusing anyone
Actually, now that you mention it... That could be a mafia trick to try and win over town.
see that's what came to my head, because they both just come on and just happen to have claims that align so perfectly. it's kinda like a butter-up.
or i'm just reading this completely wrong, it worked out in the last game with claims that made sense together, but that wasn't a closed setup so hmm
Hmm you're right, that does seem pretty coincidental. Almost too coincidental. But doesn't that seem too obvious? I guess we all slip up sometimes, though, so idk.
No i feel like it's a little too obvious and no mafia would do this, but I kind of feel like the 'coincidence' of both city & sophia getting on around the same time and both of their claims just fitting together was kind of ... eh.
But just,, guys,, it was just a split-second thought, i'm not accusing anyone
Actually, now that you mention it... That could be a mafia trick to try and win over town.
see that's what came to my head, because they both just come on and just happen to have claims that align so perfectly. it's kinda like a butter-up.
or i'm just reading this completely wrong, it worked out in the last game with claims that made sense together, but that wasn't a closed setup so hmm
Hmm you're right, that does seem pretty coincidental. Almost too coincidental. But doesn't that seem too obvious? I guess we all slip up sometimes, though, so idk.
yeah it does seem really obvious, but at the same time it sounds... rehearsed? could be wrong lol i need more opinions
I mean, if Mouse visited Lala, it could mean that she went to talk to Lala. But then it wouldn't make sense for Lala to kill Mouse for this... So maybe Lala killed Nerd if she actually used her vigilante ability?
Wait, but then Mouse wouldn't have died in this case. Maaaan.
Are you sure it said Lala was visited by Mouse and not Mouse was visited by Lala? XD
Yep.
Then that message is probably fake... unless some other person who has a vig/killing role wants to own up. LOL.
I’m still wondering how the heck they saw that Lala was visited by Mouse if they have the messenger ability. How can they have 2 abilities at once?
Did it actually say that "You got an anonymous message..." or did you just get that "Lala was visited by Mouse"?
Cuz if you didn't get the anonymous message part, then maybe it's not an anonymous message but rather like you're getting a result from someone else's role. Someone might have redirected it to you?
It said, and I quote, “You hear a voice whisper to you “Lala was visited by Mouse””.
I didn't really want to claim yet but I'm a town whisperer. Every night I get to a whisper a secret to someone but I don't get to know what the secret is. I targeted you last night since I trusted that you would be town (since you were pushing for a claim and I doubted that mafia would do that even in a closed setup like this) and now I feel more confident that you're town since you shared the secret with everyone and didn't keep it to yourself (I also doubt mafia would do that)
Oh ok. Ignore what I said earlier. That's a pretty cool role.
Even the Most Beautiful Rose has been through the Dirt
Either that or Lala still decided to kill Mouse. We can't know cuz she's dead. 🤷♀️
But whatever it is, let's just find the mafia the old school way and not dwell so much on the deaths.
I mean, this could have been a lot easier if you all wanna role claim but y'all don't want to... so.
Even if Lala knew about the neighborhood before night was over (which I highly doubt, but let's just cover all bases here), she wouldn't've learned Mouse's alignment because that's not how the 'hood works.
Anyways, the reason why we're dwelling on the deaths so much is to figure out a. why we have 3 deaths on our hands (which I think we've figured out a very plausible explanation), and b. to try and decided who might've wanted them dead.
And I think that question still remains... Whom of the living would want to kill Lala?
Bella's right. Kills are the only tracks the baddies leave, after all. With that in mind, a proper investigation means we can't forget the crime scene itself. I was thinking, you know how Lala was super confident in how Luna was town the other day? Maybe the killer made the mistake of thinking she was some type of investigator or something. Did anyone mention that earlier?
Well, Lala was a jack of all trades so she did have a 1-shot cop ability.
I could also see someone being intimidated by her. Was it... Nush? who yesterday was a bit unnerved by her confidence. I've seen the tactic many times where mafia kills the strong town players because they are intimidated by them.
If Rosey was playing, I'd suspect she killed Mouse or Nerd because they had been fairly quiet yesterday--that's something she does as mafia, and even with other killing roles--she goes after the quiet, inactive ones.
So I guess what I'm asking is, do you see a pattern to this kill?
We suspect that Lala shot Mouse because she suspected her during day, and Nerd hid behind one of them and died along with her target.... But someone had to submit the Lala kill, and who could it be?
I feel like anyone could have submitted that kill, since she's so good at this. But I do see your point about targetting more quiet players. It woulda been a little more wise to hit on the lay low 😂
No i feel like it's a little too obvious and no mafia would do this, but I kind of feel like the 'coincidence' of both city & sophia getting on around the same time and both of their claims just fitting together was kind of ... eh.
But just,, guys,, it was just a split-second thought, i'm not accusing anyone
Actually, now that you mention it... That could be a mafia trick to try and win over town.
see that's what came to my head, because they both just come on and just happen to have claims that align so perfectly. it's kinda like a butter-up.
or i'm just reading this completely wrong, it worked out in the last game with claims that made sense together, but that wasn't a closed setup so hmm
Omg.. I promise on my mother’s grave that I’m town. I swear!!
Do you like games that involve strategy? Do you like solving a mystery?
No i feel like it's a little too obvious and no mafia would do this, but I kind of feel like the 'coincidence' of both city & sophia getting on around the same time and both of their claims just fitting together was kind of ... eh.
But just,, guys,, it was just a split-second thought, i'm not accusing anyone
Actually, now that you mention it... That could be a mafia trick to try and win over town.
see that's what came to my head, because they both just come on and just happen to have claims that align so perfectly. it's kinda like a butter-up.
or i'm just reading this completely wrong, it worked out in the last game with claims that made sense together, but that wasn't a closed setup so hmm
Omg.. I promise on my mother’s grave that I’m town. I swear!!
And I don’t think City is mafia because of how specific her role explanation was.
Do you like games that involve strategy? Do you like solving a mystery?
No i feel like it's a little too obvious and no mafia would do this, but I kind of feel like the 'coincidence' of both city & sophia getting on around the same time and both of their claims just fitting together was kind of ... eh.
But just,, guys,, it was just a split-second thought, i'm not accusing anyone
Actually, now that you mention it... That could be a mafia trick to try and win over town.
see that's what came to my head, because they both just come on and just happen to have claims that align so perfectly. it's kinda like a butter-up.
or i'm just reading this completely wrong, it worked out in the last game with claims that made sense together, but that wasn't a closed setup so hmm
Omg.. I promise on my mother’s grave that I’m town. I swear!!
hhh yeah i believe you, you're like one of the more townish people to me, but i was a little hesitant about it for a sec bc of the perfectly aligning claims
No i feel like it's a little too obvious and no mafia would do this, but I kind of feel like the 'coincidence' of both city & sophia getting on around the same time and both of their claims just fitting together was kind of ... eh.
But just,, guys,, it was just a split-second thought, i'm not accusing anyone
Actually, now that you mention it... That could be a mafia trick to try and win over town.
see that's what came to my head, because they both just come on and just happen to have claims that align so perfectly. it's kinda like a butter-up.
or i'm just reading this completely wrong, it worked out in the last game with claims that made sense together, but that wasn't a closed setup so hmm
Omg.. I promise on my mother’s grave that I’m town. I swear!!
And I don’t think City is mafia because of how specific her role explanation was.
that's true, but she also commented after you right? so she could've seen your comment & had time to come up with an idea. but then again, it does sound pretty believable ahh
No i feel like it's a little too obvious and no mafia would do this, but I kind of feel like the 'coincidence' of both city & sophia getting on around the same time and both of their claims just fitting together was kind of ... eh.
But just,, guys,, it was just a split-second thought, i'm not accusing anyone
Actually, now that you mention it... That could be a mafia trick to try and win over town.
see that's what came to my head, because they both just come on and just happen to have claims that align so perfectly. it's kinda like a butter-up.
or i'm just reading this completely wrong, it worked out in the last game with claims that made sense together, but that wasn't a closed setup so hmm
Omg.. I promise on my mother’s grave that I’m town. I swear!!
Yeah I think you're townish too 😉 Luna was just doing her job to help the investigation, don't worry.
ok so i made a full circle back to nush and rose bc they sus sus to me
Ooh why? (I'm lost rn haha)
lol idk that part is just a gut feeling, a lot of people are suspicious of rose just because of the little bit she said, but also just.. what she says sounds like she's laying low. nush, idk, he's acting different-
ok so i made a full circle back to nush and rose bc they sus sus to me
Nush seems like a third party. Not sure about Rose though.
nush could be a third party yeah i always forget those exist LOL
Nush was a third party last time too, right?
And I kind of feel what you're saying; let's let Rose and Nush come on and explain themselves, too. We have plenty of time.
ok so i made a full circle back to nush and rose bc they sus sus to me
Nush seems like a third party. Not sure about Rose though.
nush could be a third party yeah i always forget those exist LOL
Nush was a third party last time too, right?
And I kind of feel what you're saying; let's let Rose and Nush come on and explain themselves, too. We have plenty of time.
yeah, let's give them a chance, i might be too hard on them rn lol
Ok, just to make sure I have this right.
We think that Lala was killex by mafia, Mouse was killed by Lala, and Nerd was killed because they hid behind one of them. Right?
Even the Most Beautiful Rose has been through the Dirt
Ok, just to make sure I have this right.
We think that Lala was killex by mafia, Mouse was killed by Lala, and Nerd was killed because they hid behind one of them. Right?
Yes.
Do you like games that involve strategy? Do you like solving a mystery?
ok so i made a full circle back to nush and rose bc they sus sus to me
Nush seems like a third party. Not sure about Rose though.
nush could be a third party yeah i always forget those exist LOL
Nush was a third party last time too, right?
And I kind of feel what you're saying; let's let Rose and Nush come on and explain themselves, too. We have plenty of time.
yeah, let's give them a chance, i might be too hard on them rn lol
No, you're not. We need to start being hard on somebody if we want to get somewhere, and much as I share your reluctance to do so 😉
ok so i made a full circle back to nush and rose bc they sus sus to me
Ooh why? (I'm lost rn haha)
lol idk that part is just a gut feeling, a lot of people are suspicious of rose just because of the little bit she said, but also just.. what she says sounds like she's laying low. nush, idk, he's acting different-
I honestly am laying low a bit. I dont want mafia to know my role because I feel its important. All I do want to say is Im town. Ill claim if I need to though.
Even the Most Beautiful Rose has been through the Dirt
ok so i made a full circle back to nush and rose bc they sus sus to me
Nush seems like a third party. Not sure about Rose though.
nush could be a third party yeah i always forget those exist LOL
Nush was a third party last time too, right?
And I kind of feel what you're saying; let's let Rose and Nush come on and explain themselves, too. We have plenty of time.
yeah, let's give them a chance, i might be too hard on them rn lol
No, you're not. We need to start being hard on somebody if we want to get somewhere, and much as I share your reluctance to do so 😉
we do need to start being hard on people i feel like giving everyone a free pass isn't gonna do us any good, but i do feel like letting them talk at least a little bit :')
ok so i made a full circle back to nush and rose bc they sus sus to me
Ooh why? (I'm lost rn haha)
lol idk that part is just a gut feeling, a lot of people are suspicious of rose just because of the little bit she said, but also just.. what she says sounds like she's laying low. nush, idk, he's acting different-
I honestly am laying low a bit. I dont want mafia to know my role because I feel its important. All I do want to say is Im town. Ill claim if I need to though.
okay, i mean it makes sense, i'm just curious as to why you discarded the oracle?
Comments
I think that might be a mafia trying to throw us off. How would they know that on N1? I don't see it being possible. Plus, Mouse died, so it wouldnt matter anyways.
Hmm you're right, that does seem pretty coincidental. Almost too coincidental. But doesn't that seem too obvious? I guess we all slip up sometimes, though, so idk.
yeah it does seem really obvious, but at the same time it sounds... rehearsed? could be wrong lol i need more opinions
♥
Oh ok. Ignore what I said earlier. That's a pretty cool role.
I feel like anyone could have submitted that kill, since she's so good at this. But I do see your point about targetting more quiet players. It woulda been a little more wise to hit on the lay low 😂
Omg.. I promise on my mother’s grave that I’m town. I swear!!
And I don’t think City is mafia because of how specific her role explanation was.
hhh yeah i believe you, you're like one of the more townish people to me, but i was a little hesitant about it for a sec bc of the perfectly aligning claims
♥
that's true, but she also commented after you right? so she could've seen your comment & had time to come up with an idea. but then again, it does sound pretty believable ahh
♥
♥
Yeah I think you're townish too 😉 Luna was just doing her job to help the investigation, don't worry.
♥
Ooh why? (I'm lost rn haha)
Nush seems like a third party. Not sure about Rose though.
lol idk that part is just a gut feeling, a lot of people are suspicious of rose just because of the little bit she said, but also just.. what she says sounds like she's laying low. nush, idk, he's acting different-
♥
nush could be a third party yeah
♥
Nush was a third party last time too, right?
And I kind of feel what you're saying; let's let Rose and Nush come on and explain themselves, too. We have plenty of time.
yeah, let's give them a chance, i might be too hard on them rn lol
♥
We think that Lala was killex by mafia, Mouse was killed by Lala, and Nerd was killed because they hid behind one of them. Right?
Yes.
No, you're not. We need to start being hard on somebody if we want to get somewhere, and much as I share your reluctance to do so 😉
I honestly am laying low a bit. I dont want mafia to know my role because I feel its important. All I do want to say is Im town. Ill claim if I need to though.
we do need to start being hard on people
♥
okay, i mean it makes sense, i'm just curious as to why you discarded the oracle?
♥