Forum Announcement, Click Here to Read More From EA_Cade.

Best World for Medieval save

Hi everyone! What neighborhood would be the best for playing Historical themes such as Medieval and Tudor. Im very grateful if you can also explain why do you think your choise would be the best fit for Medieval save.

Best World for Medieval save 60 votes

Willow Creek
1%
skip 1 vote
Winderburg
45%
JaiSeaKita5399Simburiangreydonnhellohannah2Serendipity38blueyblueskyannaliese39DoloresGreyLenny_OggMDianaSimsmusteniRedShoe7filipomelHopeyStarrthatsnotswegOceancatmrs_starkeyInuMiroLoverSERVERFRA 27 votes
Henford on Bagley
40%
CK213ScrapdashStrangerthanelanorbretonmaggiemae8135simgirl1010luthienrisingloubyloulouSimplyJenkiwi84BlueSeaWaveslovemy4sMeTime85LiELFBlueR0seSAEldarinAtreya33EllupelluelluMarteziaKingPerti23 24 votes
Brindleton Bay
1%
Umbreon12 1 vote
Newcrest
0%
Other
11%
crocobauraFishyNamoralanmichael1DaraviCAPTAIN_NXR7JackOnYourBackAmapola76 7 votes

Comments

  • Options
    SimplyJenSimplyJen Posts: 14,828 Member
    Henford on Bagley
    There's a section of Windenburg that's more on the modern side even if you replace the surrounding lots. Henford on Bagley has rolling hillsides and overall is more fitting for medieval in my opinion... but I don't play historical saves.
    i7-13700K β€’ 16GB β€’ RTX 4070
    S3 simblr: http://simplysimming.tumblr.com/
    S4 simblr: http://simlogic.tumblr.com/
  • Options
    LeucosiaXLeucosiaX Posts: 1,635 Member
    Henford on Bagley
    Before Cottage Living I think those who played historical games loved Windenburg, but now Hendford I think is really the best. I have yet to play the decades challenge, but I have some historically dressed and living sims in both and well as my elves. Glimmerbrook is also possible.
  • Options
    Lenny_OggLenny_Ogg Posts: 3,696 Member
    Winderburg

    I have almost all my historic builds in Windenburg because of the Old Town and the countryside
    (the rest of them in Henford-on-Bagley which is also awesome with the village/countryside).
    I would choose Windenburg for Tudor and Henford-on-Bagley for Medieval.
    Imo both have the perfect mix for a Medieval/Tudor save.
    (Minus the cars ^^')
    But otherwise there are no disturbing modern landmarks. (Except a few in New-old-Henford.)

    cc719d7c2ed02a89d296887bfeee8ea365d621e7.jpg
    3dcf547c9046dfa5a42c7bbc9e88507f8ecf35d8.jpg
    ae92d13f8018a851e8f5e17fecf8e69285654620.jpg

    Countryside
    4f7768ffb2c37e574c9e10180c5c23a50a768cac.jpg
    3 more pics below the spoiler
    ffbf85eecd1b21653ac6d7e70925db4b17a6d3c6.jpg
    337d47d61b8523667313bf0560175546babdde3e.jpg
    d418c37d9a843a1b3abfc1587c19a1f0619a3ef8.jpg

    Old Town
    fce0b12b1699a5e564901878925e835dace46d5f.jpg
    3 more pics below the spoiler
    f9886633763bbecbcdabe88420dd7265dfbf422a.jpg
    26011a8e7ade915103ff72ca36d5c7a232f1a20c.jpg
    adc6bc7b67f9c57a90b36039f87e3801488e7661.jpg
    d70aead6bd57d9113e587b03ecffce84b09267d0.jpgThe Boys 2 - Therapy Game πŸ›Ί A Dramedy 🚢🏼🚢🏻🚢🏽🚢🏽 The Boys πŸ₯‡ Their first year - A Dramedy πŸš€ Lost In Space - A Space Opera 🐎 The Stables - A Horse Drama
    🎁 Best of Buydebug β˜ƒοΈ Short trips to the Oggiverse - Short Clips 🎬 My Builds: Houses 🏘 Rooms πŸ›‹ SciFi πŸ‘Ύ creatively edited Screenshots 🎨
  • Options
    alanmichael1alanmichael1 Posts: 5,405 Member
    Other
    The Werwolf world.
  • Options
    LiELFLiELF Posts: 6,462 Member
    Henford on Bagley
    I agree with the Henford Vote. Much as I love Windenburg, it does have the modern area that kind of takes the timeless immersion away. Henford's town is more believable in that way. And it would probably be generally easier to use for that gameplay theme.

    But you could still use Windenburg, I think. In my game I've replaced the lots on the modern side for older looking buildings and mostly try to play in the older areas anyway. Windenburg is the largest Sim world, it has the most lots (and the ruins too!) so eliminating the modern section from gameplay still leaves a normal sized world to play with if you really wanted to use it.

    I'd also say Forgotten Hollow and Glimmerbrook, but they are quite small so there wouldn't be much to work with unless you used them as extension villages to visit. Tartosa maybe would work as well, though I don't have that world, so I'm not quite sure.
    #Team Occult
  • Options
    Atreya33Atreya33 Posts: 4,436 Member
    Henford on Bagley
    I think Henford on Bagley is the best. There are a few deco cars in the world but for the rest it is very good for historical saves.
    Windenburg is another good option. 3 of the 4 neighbourhoods (island, old town and country side) have surroundings that feel fitting for medieval saves. Especially the island is useful because it has no decorative buildings or modern elements.
    Another good option is Glimmerbrook. It is remote without any decorative buildings to determine the era.
  • Options
    Amapola76Amapola76 Posts: 1,908 Member
    Other
    If you are asking because you need to limit it to only one world (because you can only buy one EP, or are doing a challenge with world limitations, etc.), then I would probably go with Henford.

    Otherwise, if you have no real reason to limit it to just one world, I would suggest putting your primary household in either Henford, or the rural or island sections of Windenburg, but then designate some combination of Henford, Windenburg, Forgotten Hollow, and/or Tartosa as areas where you can have "neighboring villages" with non-residential lots (shops, churches, parks, etc.) that you can utilize and other households to befriend or romance.
  • Options
    JALJAL Posts: 1,044 Member
    I haven't played a medieval save myself yet, but I would also go with Henford or Windenburg. I have a hard time actually deciding between them. I think it depends more on what kind of medieval play you want (countryside or town). Brindleton, Newcrest and Willow Creek are far too modern in my book. I do also think Glimmerbrook, but then that's also a very small world. You could of course combine the three, set your family in for example Henford but have them travel into Windenburg for things like market days and church.
    Moreover, I advise that the cart button must be destroyed!
  • Options
    BoomeyBoomey Posts: 43 Member
    Winderburg
    I like Windenburg because of the club aspect. The Knights of the Hedges give me medieval vibes so that’s how I would incorporate those together.
  • Options
    CAPTAIN_NXR7CAPTAIN_NXR7 Posts: 4,467 Member
    Other
    For medieval play, my vote goes to Windenburg, Henford, Forgotten Hollow AND the uninhabited Island on Sulani!

    The Crumbling Isle and the northern district in Windenburg work great for huge castles and taverns. I avoid the modern district altogether. Most of my Lords and Ladies live in Windenburg, whereas in Henford is where all me lovely commoners and some bog witches reside. I have pirates and medieval merfolk in (googles) Mua Pel'am in Sulani and then there's Forgotten Hollow where the Hunters live. Hunters as in, pale looking Sims with fangs and also those that are extremely hairy with claws.
  • Options
    crocobauracrocobaura Posts: 7,392 Member
    Other
    Seeing cars and jetskis drive by and Nancy Landgraab and the Bjorgensens in modern clothes would definitely break the immersion for me. There are a few secluded lots here and there, maybe if you don't mind having your medieval lots spread in several different neighbourhoods, it could work. That being said, Old town in Windenburg has beautiful bell chimes sound effects, I think that would be a nice setting and it needs few adjustments if you want to play a medieval city. Henford is a good choice too, especially in the countryside area.
  • Options
    Amapola76Amapola76 Posts: 1,908 Member
    Other
    Also, wanted to add that my answer was based on my interpretation that you are looking for realistic/historical medieval settings. If you are looking for a quasi-medieval world in a fantasy save, the answer would be slightly different.

    E.g., one of these days, if I can tear myself away from my main save, I think it would be fun to do an Elder Scrolls save, in which case I would do something similar to what I described above, but add parts of Oasis Spring (Alik'r) and Sulani (Stros M'kai), etc.
  • Options
    JALJAL Posts: 1,044 Member
    Another option that you might consider is using different worlds for different generations. Many people moved during medieval times. A different religion than your leader might be something to push you out, a famine, being the third/fourth or fifth child might be a good reason to move and settle elsewhere, soldiers often travelled far and wide and women were often married off to people living far away (at least if they were rich). That way you're not locked into one world, but could use multiple ones.
    Moreover, I advise that the cart button must be destroyed!
  • Options
    CK213CK213 Posts: 20,533 Member
    Henford on Bagley
    I would build in Henford-on-Bagley using Get Together build mode content.
    Windenburg has great content, but for the world, it's too modern.
    The%20Goths.png?width=1920&height=1080&fit=bounds
  • Options
    BlueR0seBlueR0se Posts: 1,595 Member
    Henford on Bagley
    Windenburg or Henford on Bagley. I use HoB for my historical saves.
  • Options
    ScrapdashScrapdash Posts: 1,236 Member
    Henford on Bagley
    Henford or a few parts of Windenburg, the area near the gym and nightclub wouldn't be possible.
    Honestly I just want a world like sims3 Dragon Valley. With all the painted in fake houses it's just not possible anymore to make a truly historical save and it's getting worse with each world they bring out.
  • Options
    SERVERFRASERVERFRA Posts: 7,130 Member
    Winderburg
    To me, Windenburg will always tie with Henford. <3<3
  • Options
    MarteziaKingMarteziaKing Posts: 277 Member
    Henford on Bagley
    Definitely Henford-on-Bagley, but I guess certain parts of Windenburg could work too. I hope you're planning on buying the Medieval build kit once it releases because I think it'll make your save more, well, medieval. ✨🏰✨
    6bkvqyxctsjq.jpg
    β™₯ If you can't be the light in the shadows, be the gem that refracts the light all around β™₯
  • Options
    Lenny_OggLenny_Ogg Posts: 3,696 Member
    Winderburg

    Henford-on-Bagley
    Old New Henford

    9b3c96d0b76dd5b00f7f49ed43cd6d5301f89abc.jpg

    4 more pics below the spoiler
    8e2aa8ec91006d1294f3cc246fad7063c003bfff.jpg
    fd4fb924324317461f534faf179bc5c77dbd79e0.jpg
    d8a4991d11837f10bd7279f4c091e7cc9697cc2f.jpg
    2d14ea8ceff06d5196ba4d8fb4de5ab721da32de.jpg

    Countryside
    6eea8095a305be8fba74802f74d6a2649532d5ee.jpg
    2 more pics below the spoiler
    9db1ec1d6cff8701a056284bd1b6ca750d698f73.jpg
    7f6fbf50296f23a26ecb1a970956e78160df0d69.jpg

    One of my few historic builds in Henford
    976e0240a17fe2b802db831f023ddae3d0e181ec.jpg

    What keeps me from placing more historic lots in Henford are the modern objects placed almost everywhere.
    Like the string lights in Bramblewood or the phone booths in Old New Henford.
    That's too much of a hassle for my liking to pay attention to not have a modern object in my historic screenshots.
    This is better in Windenburg.

    Modern Objects photobombing

    ~ 10 more pics below the spoiler ΓΆ.Γ–'
    String lights
    90457bcb503ff8490134b595883e8c46e4361b03.jpg

    f937918f3a2d4bd32f335a37d37f4718e8b70d19.jpg

    hahaha omg!
    84a3dd29b8f000b9535c915c0121d09dbdad10ea.jpg
    df004a6dd943eed8838ac0e73e206ddff96b2e6f.jpg
    61a24bddc082d59eebae9a6c1363616c6ae668ce.jpg
    9dd2f1d1ff684de55f2cdf21b25d9498aa810c69.jpg

    Phone booths
    5a79152465248d07b6a360b35e8308d5efb80b8a.jpg
    534681b56293d3ac968bd36248f9141257635f10.jpg
    aac8bde851c0a536befb9967026c2e9b6bcd72cf.jpg

    The modern shops
    e3e4bcd0abd4b7f1a3dd4b4f58b5059a8ed718e5.jpg

    And all the rest
    39f8c967f9728785c51bcb51bc09434d00ad99cf.jpg
    d70aead6bd57d9113e587b03ecffce84b09267d0.jpgThe Boys 2 - Therapy Game πŸ›Ί A Dramedy 🚢🏼🚢🏻🚢🏽🚢🏽 The Boys πŸ₯‡ Their first year - A Dramedy πŸš€ Lost In Space - A Space Opera 🐎 The Stables - A Horse Drama
    🎁 Best of Buydebug β˜ƒοΈ Short trips to the Oggiverse - Short Clips 🎬 My Builds: Houses 🏘 Rooms πŸ›‹ SciFi πŸ‘Ύ creatively edited Screenshots 🎨
  • Options
    DaraviDaravi Posts: 1,145 Member
    Other
    Personally I think the Island of windenburg is good a choice and I think Glimmerbrook is good for a small medival world too, because both lack of modern things, which disturb the immersion. HoB isn't a good choice because of the environmental cars everywhere. And the town itself looks like a Disney theme park. If you could rebuild the center, than it would be okay, but that's not possible.
  • Options
    JackOnYourBackJackOnYourBack Posts: 1,261 Member
    Other
    I'd say the world that came with spellcasters, no set dressing πŸ˜„
    Gallery ID: JackOnYourBack
  • Options
    JadeleineJadeleine Posts: 2,142 Member
    edited November 2023
    Thank you everyone for the answers! So many great ideas. Im gonna go with Windenburg Henford combo, both of them shall have a theme. Im thinking of quasi-fantasy type of save. Maybe I will come up with some kind of challenge around this.

    @LeucosiaX Yes, I was thinking about Glimmerbrook too, but that is too small for my intentions of having rotational save. ItΒ΄s still definitely part of the theme tough, can serve as side story place.

    @Lenny_Ogg thanks for the inspiring photos, they are beatiful! Both of those worlds looks so nice in the winter, magical.

    @LiELF I agree and the small neighborhoods like Glimmerbrook and werewolf world can work as exellent extensions to this save.

    @Amapola76 thoses are good ideas too, having shops and other community lots in other worlds will work very well with this. I was thinking of placing apotechary/potion shop in glimmerbrook etc.

    @Boomey yes, the Knights definitely work with this theme, thanks for reminding me that they are there!

    @Scrapdash I miss Dragon Valley too, it was so beautiful.

    @CAPTAIN_NXR7 I love the idea of having Pirates in Sulani, I will definitely adopt that and make some in this save!

    I started a challenge based on this, you can find it here if you like the theme:

    https://forums.thesims.com/en_US/discussion/1011759/new-medieval-fantasy-challenge/p1?new=1

    Post edited by Jadeleine on
Sign In or Register to comment.
Return to top