I told y'all I lied about being Lookout. I hope you like my will
Yeah, lookout is a very common claim for mafia due to how easy it is to fake wills for it.
But what's the point of faking your will if they're are gonna flip mafia anyways?
I had wondered that too. I'm not clear on how wills work in this game as opposed to TOS. Like, can anyone ask to see someone else's will before their death, in this game? If so, there would be reason to have a fake one, but if not, it makes little sense.
Racism is EVERYONE's fight #BLM #StopAsianHate
Let's make Liberty and Justice For All a reality.
I told y'all I lied about being Lookout. I hope you like my will
Yeah, lookout is a very common claim for mafia due to how easy it is to fake wills for it.
But what's the point of faking your will if they're are gonna flip mafia anyways?
I had wondered that too. I'm not clear on how wills work in this game as opposed to TOS. Like, can anyone ask to see someone else's will before their death, in this game? If so, there would be reason to have a fake one, but if not, it makes little sense.
Some mafia have multiple fake wills they will choose to use depending on what people claim as.
So when you die, all your fake wills will be posted but when you're alive you'll work on both until you have to claim, but keep the strongest one as your aliby.
Lenny | Sims 3 | Uni Student | Timezone: EDT (UTC -4) |My blood type is A- | 50% Anxiety 25% Angst 25% Awesome | I bleed for cute sims
Nerd, that was a cute will. I keep wanting to type Nerdy because once I played mafia with someone whose name was Nerdy ... so if I type that by accident one day, please forgive me.
Check out my cooking Youtube channel: Living with Leigh
Gone for two hours and had 320 posts. And yay I was right about Nerd being mafioso or SK! I thought it was more likely to be SK but at least my second guess was right.
Mass claims were the best part of it though.. but oh well, I guess it's hard for evil roles. Instead of SK, will there be a plaguebearer or arsonist? @TheRoseHorse
Do you like games that involve strategy? Do you like solving a mystery?
Mass claims were the best part of it though.. but oh well, I guess it's hard for evil roles. Instead of SK, will there be a plaguebearer or arsonist? @TheRoseHorse
Mass claims were the best part of it though.. but oh well, I guess it's hard for evil roles. Instead of SK, will there be a plaguebearer or arsonist? @TheRoseHorse
Mass claims were the best part of it though.. but oh well, I guess it's hard for evil roles. Instead of SK, will there be a plaguebearer or arsonist? @TheRoseHorse
Ngl I knew this was going to be really hard for the evils because of the fact that there's no claim space. This is the same role set up used in TOS classic, where if everyone knows how to play the game, the town always wins.
I suggest editing the role list to include more Random towns, or use the role list from Ranked instead which has 3 RT towns and add a few edits.
Ranked Role List (but there's one more extra slot)
Jailor
Town Investigative
Town Investigative
Town Protective
Town Killing
Town Support
Random Town
Random Town
Godfather
Mafioso
Random Mafia
Random Mafia
Neutral Killing
Neutral Evil
Neutral Benign
Only issue is that now we have a lot more roles and investigator results. Personally, I'd tweak the list to be something like this. (NOTE I HAVEN'T BALANCED CHECKED THIS IT'S JUST A SUGGESTION)
Town (9)
Jailor, Lookout, Town investigative (sheriff/invest), Town support, Town killing, Town protective, Random Townx3,
Mafia (3/4?)
Godfather
Mafiaoso
Random Mafia x 2? (framer, disguiser, consigiler, consort, )
Neutrals (4)
Neutral killing (I would put werewolf instead of SK)
Neutral evil (jester/executioner)
Amnesiac x 2
I really don't know if this is balanced lol. Amnesiac is a role that can "remember" their past identity (which occurs when the person looks at a dead person) and assume the role an allegiance of the dead person. They can remember any role, even veteran or werewolf or a mafia.
I just thought this would be fun and mafia has more claim space (neutrals, RTs and amnesiacs)
Lenny | Sims 3 | Uni Student | Timezone: EDT (UTC -4) |My blood type is A- | 50% Anxiety 25% Angst 25% Awesome | I bleed for cute sims
If I host this again, I'm gonna allow whispers. I feel like that will help the whole mass claim situation.
I don't really know how whispers will work in our forum or how you are going to regulate it but maybe to avoid mass claim, you can tweak the setup and say that there could be multiple repeated roles or give a more longer role list with roles that aren't in the game, like a Greater Mafia? That way the bad guys can have some leeway.
If I host this again, I'm gonna allow whispers. I feel like that will help the whole mass claim situation.
I don't really know how whispers will work in our forum or how you are going to regulate it but maybe to avoid mass claim, you can tweak the setup and say that there could be multiple repeated roles or give a more longer role list with roles that aren't in the game, like a Greater Mafia? That way the bad guys can have some leeway.
Cuz mass claims are very hard to regulate. It doesn't make sense for only a selected few people to claim their roles... Once a person claims, people will tend to be more curious and ask others around and then it just spreads like that. 😂
So the only way to prevent it in a game where everyone has roles is to just give more options that could be repeated or that isn't in the game at all (semi closed).
If I host this again, I'm gonna allow whispers. I feel like that will help the whole mass claim situation.
I don't really know how whispers will work in our forum or how you are going to regulate it but maybe to avoid mass claim, you can tweak the setup and say that there could be multiple repeated roles or give a more longer role list with roles that aren't in the game, like a Greater Mafia? That way the bad guys can have some leeway.
But does Rose have to be in it as well? And how could whispers even stop mass claiming?
Comments
Your will is a 10/10.
Let's make Liberty and Justice For All a reality.
I had wondered that too. I'm not clear on how wills work in this game as opposed to TOS. Like, can anyone ask to see someone else's will before their death, in this game? If so, there would be reason to have a fake one, but if not, it makes little sense.
Let's make Liberty and Justice For All a reality.
Some mafia have multiple fake wills they will choose to use depending on what people claim as.
So when you die, all your fake wills will be posted but when you're alive you'll work on both until you have to claim, but keep the strongest one as your aliby.
Oof. forgot to post it. edited it in.
I'm with you, I'd just rather not be Mafia next time
Yes. No mass claims.
I might. idk
I feel like the trial system doesn't really work all that well for a forum like this.
Trials only work if everyone is on at the same time, unfortunately.
And the mass claim situation... I'd say something more about it, but that'd probably be too on-topic so I'll withhold my comment.
Most likely caught as scum and best theme-Google Translate, 4th annual Scummies win!
If you feel like it's too on topic, you can pm me.
I suggest editing the role list to include more Random towns, or use the role list from Ranked instead which has 3 RT towns and add a few edits.
Ranked Role List (but there's one more extra slot)
Jailor
Town Investigative
Town Investigative
Town Protective
Town Killing
Town Support
Random Town
Random Town
Godfather
Mafioso
Random Mafia
Random Mafia
Neutral Killing
Neutral Evil
Neutral Benign
Only issue is that now we have a lot more roles and investigator results. Personally, I'd tweak the list to be something like this. (NOTE I HAVEN'T BALANCED CHECKED THIS IT'S JUST A SUGGESTION)
Town (9)
Jailor, Lookout, Town investigative (sheriff/invest), Town support, Town killing, Town protective, Random Townx3,
Mafia (3/4?)
Godfather
Mafiaoso
Random Mafia x 2? (framer, disguiser, consigiler, consort, )
Neutrals (4)
Neutral killing (I would put werewolf instead of SK)
Neutral evil (jester/executioner)
Amnesiac x 2
I really don't know if this is balanced lol. Amnesiac is a role that can "remember" their past identity (which occurs when the person looks at a dead person) and assume the role an allegiance of the dead person. They can remember any role, even veteran or werewolf or a mafia.
I just thought this would be fun and mafia has more claim space (neutrals, RTs and amnesiacs)
As exciting as this is, and as much free time and boredom that ppl are dealing with, that might not be a problem.
Let's make Liberty and Justice For All a reality.
I don't really know how whispers will work in our forum or how you are going to regulate it but maybe to avoid mass claim, you can tweak the setup and say that there could be multiple repeated roles or give a more longer role list with roles that aren't in the game, like a Greater Mafia? That way the bad guys can have some leeway.
Whispers are pms 👍
So the only way to prevent it in a game where everyone has roles is to just give more options that could be repeated or that isn't in the game at all (semi closed).