You kidding? Supernatural bypasses all other EPs. I would suggest getting Pets and World Adventures. You'll get unicorns and mummies, plus so much to do in World Adventures
I don't understand why there is even a question of whether or not to get this. As far as I can see, it's an absolute must have, if you're going to continue to play sims.
If you enjoy playing other life states, then this expansion is a must have.
Other than this, I would suggest Pets or Ambitions; maybe World Adventures depending on how much you want to spend. In my opinion Showtime is a waste of money and really didn't add anything worthwhile apart from Genies.
You didn't say what you like, but if you like animals, then Pets is a great expansion. I also loved World Adventures. Since you're on the Supernatural forum you must be interested in that, so definitely get Supernatural. I think Supernatural is going to be very, very fun.
Comments
Other than this, I would suggest Pets or Ambitions; maybe World Adventures depending on how much you want to spend. In my opinion Showtime is a waste of money and really didn't add anything worthwhile apart from Genies.
but other then that.. threads like this belong in general discussion (or seasons apparently)