I'll be fine with either 2 or 3, though I'll admit I like the clutter ideas in #1 (Not the furniture style - and we already have that in Cats and Dogs, and I don't use those much either.)
In the thread about Simarchy's recreations on twitch/Twitter, it looks (to me) like we already have more furniture like #1 than the other two - as there's more "placeholder" stuff in the other two - especially #2's craft room stuff (like the wheeled cart and the large project table.)
1. has all the decorations I really really really love and want
but I don't want this to become full on grandmas only pack
and the furnitures are kinda meh like we got lots of this in other packs already
3. has warm earthy colors which I really like
and I see myself using these furnitures a lot
(especially the chair)
+ it also has some cute decors
+ is gender and age neutral which I like
but the ''industrial'' annoys me yet again ._. I just want cozy
2. I only really want that big table other than that I hate this one
mostly because 1. we have this stuff already in other packs there is loads of it
and 2. the colors are not warm at all and 3. it looks like barbies house which is not my aesthetic at all
โญ๏ธ AHQ Champion ๐ฆ Vlad Advocate ๐ Team Dragons
๐ก Gallery ๐ Stories ๐ World Project ๐ฅ MOD/CC Free
so I voted for the wrong one I thought 3 was the one I love and it's actually 2, I didn't see the labeled photo so that's my bad.
I don't like 1 because we already have similar furniture, in fact I remember making a room similar to it with furniture we already have was just missing the yarn items.
I like 3 but we have stuff that's already similar to it as well and that door is a version of a door that came with pets and i don't care for that door.
I love 2 because I love bright colors and the door has decor on it which is something i don't think we've seen before. I also love the big desk on wheels and the 2 tables with all the slots I just hope they don't come with the items already on them like some tables we've had in the past. I also really love the decor especially the boxes of yarn cause that is how I stash projects i'm working on.
but i'll be happy with 2 or 3. 1 just has too many items that look like things we already have and i don't want the pack to become the granny stereotype people think it'll be.
i like all of them, i think they all have some nice pieces and design elements.
but i am going with #2.
i think #3 doesn't really have a cohesive theme, i'm not sure what it's going for other than adding a more masculine option. the style doesn't remind me of knitting.
and #1 doesn't exactly capture the granny style i wanted. i wanted something classier/antique not cartoonish and exaggerated.
Granny chic is my favorite. It's got that crafty and homey vibe that I'm hoping to get from this pack. DIY is my second fav. I love the colors and it's super cute. Cozy Workshop is my least favorite. It doesn't give me any cozy vibes and looks so dull. I much prefer the vibrant appeal that the other rooms have.
If it is a ranked vote I would vote cozy then DIY then at a very distant third Granny Chic. If it isn't I'll vote for the one most likely to beat Granny Chic. It not that I don't want more stuff for our elders just the opposite in fact but our sim elders deserve better that outdated stereotypes and tired cliches from the mid twentieth century.
Gallery ID: Truet318, check out my latest builds on the gallery.
The Road goes ever on and on And I must follow, if I can,
Until it joins some larger way,
Where many paths and errands meet.
The fact that we can't even properly categorize the other 2 styles says a lot.
Exactly the other 2 packs look like any other pack with a shelf with yarn while Granny has so many objects that use knitting as decoration and not just a knitting room people asking which room is cozy says it all so generic.
Sims 4 went from "You Rule" to "One of the stories we want you to tell"
I'm not crazy about any of them. Too much clutter, and nothing matches. I don't want more green and blue furniture and doors. I want simple wood items that match.
Not too excited by any of them, but I think cozyโs probably the first one Iโd pick. Fully expecting Granny to win, but idk I just think the Cozy colours are cheerful and nicely suited to an arts and crafts-themed pack like this.
I'm actually split between #1 and #3. I like some elements of both. I like that #3 is more gender neutral though I'd like it better if it were clearly "cozier" such as with a fireplace and more blankets. I like some of the items in the granny design and I'm open to have some items for elders though I'm apprehensive about an entire pack based on "granny chic".
I honestly don't care for #2. The colors are way too bright for me. I kind of like the "yarn lights" but other than that, it's really not my style. It's the kind of stuff that I edit out of the game when I play. I'd really like this better if pottery were also included.
While I'm less than thrilled about this SP's theme, I decided to vote for DIY Delight because it matches my style of building/decorating and seems the most verstile. I also like how the some of the items would pair with items from the Parenthood GP.
Comments
In the thread about Simarchy's recreations on twitch/Twitter, it looks (to me) like we already have more furniture like #1 than the other two - as there's more "placeholder" stuff in the other two - especially #2's craft room stuff (like the wheeled cart and the large project table.)
I just like the furniture more in that one.
1. has all the decorations I really really really love and want
but I don't want this to become full on grandmas only pack
and the furnitures are kinda meh like we got lots of this in other packs already
3. has warm earthy colors which I really like
and I see myself using these furnitures a lot
(especially the chair)
+ it also has some cute decors
+ is gender and age neutral which I like
but the ''industrial'' annoys me yet again ._. I just want cozy
2. I only really want that big table other than that I hate this one
mostly because 1. we have this stuff already in other packs there is loads of it
and 2. the colors are not warm at all and 3. it looks like barbies house which is not my aesthetic at all
๐ก Gallery ๐ Stories ๐ World Project ๐ฅ MOD/CC Free
1 = Granny, 2 = DIY, 3 = Cozy
I don't like 1 because we already have similar furniture, in fact I remember making a room similar to it with furniture we already have was just missing the yarn items.
I like 3 but we have stuff that's already similar to it as well and that door is a version of a door that came with pets and i don't care for that door.
I love 2 because I love bright colors and the door has decor on it which is something i don't think we've seen before. I also love the big desk on wheels and the 2 tables with all the slots I just hope they don't come with the items already on them like some tables we've had in the past. I also really love the decor especially the boxes of yarn cause that is how I stash projects i'm working on.
but i'll be happy with 2 or 3. 1 just has too many items that look like things we already have and i don't want the pack to become the granny stereotype people think it'll be.
but i am going with #2.
i think #3 doesn't really have a cohesive theme, i'm not sure what it's going for other than adding a more masculine option. the style doesn't remind me of knitting.
and #1 doesn't exactly capture the granny style i wanted. i wanted something classier/antique not cartoonish and exaggerated.
but i want the rooster in the bottom pic.
The Road goes ever on and on And I must follow, if I can,
Until it joins some larger way,
Where many paths and errands meet.
I honestly don't care for #2. The colors are way too bright for me. I kind of like the "yarn lights" but other than that, it's really not my style. It's the kind of stuff that I edit out of the game when I play. I'd really like this better if pottery were also included.