They did address this in the patch notes/one of the articles (I forget). They said some of the things were harder to convert, but they went with the choice of giving people more options... Rather than leaving some things out because they weren't quite right.
I'd rather they leave them out and work on the issues than give us half a--ed items lol. Like some items look pretty bad that if they left them out to fix, I wouldn't have missed them. They said this took them a year to figure out and yet things cc creators have been doing (converting male to female and vice versa), they could have at least smoothed out the bad bugs. Then fixed up the minor issues afterwards (a few weeks)?
but maybe that's just my opinion?
I think how each mesh looks depends somewhat on the sim's proportions. So if they checked them all quickly on one sim, they might have missed issues that only effect skinnier/plumper/buffer sims.
Like someone else says, they probably converted using a script of some kind, and did a manual once-over for anything obvious out of place. Imagine how long it would take to check every mesh, on every possible body type?
E.G. Some of the long hairs stick out weirdly to the sides on men with wide shoulders, but I've seen them on more slender males and they look fine.
They did address this in the patch notes/one of the articles (I forget). They said some of the things were harder to convert, but they went with the choice of giving people more options... Rather than leaving some things out because they weren't quite right.
I'd rather they leave them out and work on the issues than give us half a--ed items lol. Like some items look pretty bad that if they left them out to fix, I wouldn't have missed them. They said this took them a year to figure out and yet things cc creators have been doing (converting male to female and vice versa), they could have at least smoothed out the bad bugs. Then fixed up the minor issues afterwards (a few weeks)?
but maybe that's just my opinion?
I think how each mesh looks depends somewhat on the sim's proportions. So if they checked them all quickly on one sim, they might have missed issues that only effect skinnier/plumper/buffer sims.
Like someone else says, they probably converted using a script of some kind, and did a manual once-over for anything obvious out of place. Imagine how long it would take to check every mesh, on every possible body type?
Actually we did have people checking things manually over and over again (I would chat with one of them everyday, all of the tagging for assets was done by hand) but it's not possible for us to notice everything which is why we depend on the community to alert us to any issues that might arise.
So I can probly never play the game again because a truly CRAP update wont work ?
This is BULL, EA , I pay for your games and this happens.
Not good enough.
So I can probly never play the game again because a truly CRAP update wont work ?
This is BULL, EA , I pay for your games and this happens.
Not good enough.
Modders are already fixing the mesh issue, how is it that modders can fix it in under 24 hours when they are just ONE person with no budget, yet it took EA ONE YEAR to do....here is the very popular PickyPikachu explaining it.....
pickypikachu:
"Heres the problem, “female” meshes have more vertices in the breast area, that’s just the reality of how they set up the body templates. So when they converted male clothing they simply pushed out the vertices to somewhat match the female form, but there aren’t enough points to make it smooth and they didn’t bother to update the mesh. I don’t get how this took one year. The morph data is all over the place for the crotch area. Yes yes, good on them for being progressive and calling attention to this but I feel like deep down this was a publicity stunt and there was zero quality assurance. And then brushing it off by saying “we wanted to get this out there so it’s not perfect”. I’m mostly disappointed with this update. All that aside I am glad that a lot of you are loving it and finally making simselves that closely match yourselves and finally getting your characters into the clothing the belong in. But me, as a creator, cannot get over the sloppiness. Ugh"
They did address this in the patch notes/one of the articles (I forget). They said some of the things were harder to convert, but they went with the choice of giving people more options... Rather than leaving some things out because they weren't quite right.
I'd rather they leave them out and work on the issues than give us half a--ed items lol. Like some items look pretty bad that if they left them out to fix, I wouldn't have missed them. They said this took them a year to figure out and yet things cc creators have been doing (converting male to female and vice versa), they could have at least smoothed out the bad bugs. Then fixed up the minor issues afterwards (a few weeks)?
but maybe that's just my opinion?
I think how each mesh looks depends somewhat on the sim's proportions. So if they checked them all quickly on one sim, they might have missed issues that only effect skinnier/plumper/buffer sims.
Like someone else says, they probably converted using a script of some kind, and did a manual once-over for anything obvious out of place. Imagine how long it would take to check every mesh, on every possible body type?
Actually we did have people checking things manually over and over again (I would chat with one of them everyday, all of the tagging for assets was done by hand) but it's not possible for us to notice everything which is why we depend on the community to alert us to any issues that might arise.
Ahh, I was so worried that we were given something half hearted and was upset for a moment. I needed that clarification, I wouldn't have known otherwise!!
And yes, thank you for noticing our concerns!! I'm very happy with this update and how progressive Sims are becoming its just those things can really take me out of my immersion. Hope this topic was helpful for the Gurus to see the problems they didn't catch!
Modders are already fixing the mesh issue, how is it that modders can fix it in under 24 hours when they are just ONE person with no budget, yet it took EA ONE YEAR to do....here is the very popular PickyPikachu explaining it.....
pickypikachu:
"Heres the problem, “female” meshes have more vertices in the breast area, that’s just the reality of how they set up the body templates. So when they converted male clothing they simply pushed out the vertices to somewhat match the female form, but there aren’t enough points to make it smooth and they didn’t bother to update the mesh. I don’t get how this took one year. The morph data is all over the place for the crotch area. Yes yes, good on them for being progressive and calling attention to this but I feel like deep down this was a publicity stunt and there was zero quality assurance. And then brushing it off by saying “we wanted to get this out there so it’s not perfect”. I’m mostly disappointed with this update. All that aside I am glad that a lot of you are loving it and finally making simselves that closely match yourselves and finally getting your characters into the clothing the belong in. But me, as a creator, cannot get over the sloppiness. Ugh"
That one person also has infinite time at their disposal and we do not. There were multiple people who were working on this. Those same people are always working on lots of other things at the same time. So comparing them to a single individual who has the free time available is unrealistic.
The issues I'm having with some clothing...The waistline is moved. The one on the right is where it should be, put if I add a converted top, it drops it down.
Also, their stance is different. Left is original female tshirt, and right is with a converted tshirt. Basically the same shirt, but different stance.
Don't know what it looks like in game, as I haven't gotten a chance to play yet, just messed with CAS.
Modders are already fixing the mesh issue, how is it that modders can fix it in under 24 hours when they are just ONE person with no budget, yet it took EA ONE YEAR to do....here is the very popular PickyPikachu explaining it.....
pickypikachu:
"Heres the problem, “female” meshes have more vertices in the breast area, that’s just the reality of how they set up the body templates. So when they converted male clothing they simply pushed out the vertices to somewhat match the female form, but there aren’t enough points to make it smooth and they didn’t bother to update the mesh. I don’t get how this took one year. The morph data is all over the place for the crotch area. Yes yes, good on them for being progressive and calling attention to this but I feel like deep down this was a publicity stunt and there was zero quality assurance. And then brushing it off by saying “we wanted to get this out there so it’s not perfect”. I’m mostly disappointed with this update. All that aside I am glad that a lot of you are loving it and finally making simselves that closely match yourselves and finally getting your characters into the clothing the belong in. But me, as a creator, cannot get over the sloppiness. Ugh"
Modders aren't doing every single piece of clothing- like 700 items. They chose a single jacket in one color and convert it and it often takes hours to do that one thing AND if it's not perfect the average simmer just shrugs and accepts it because it's a modder doing it. They way I look at it the stuff that works is still a nice addition that we didn't have before. If every single item is not perfect, so what? It was free and the stuff that's there to use is a welcome addition.
They did address this in the patch notes/one of the articles (I forget). They said some of the things were harder to convert, but they went with the choice of giving people more options... Rather than leaving some things out because they weren't quite right.
I also have a feeling that they may have an automated process for doing a lot of the work of manipulating meshes to fit the other sex's body. Which is easier and quicker, at the expense of things really not being perfect.
I don't really blame them, knowing the volume of clothes they did. I'd go mad hand-tweaking meshes for hundreds of items too.
The thing is though, CC and mod creators have spoken out about how it is fixable and do-able. Yes, its hard, of course it is. I don't doubt that But its not impossible. EA is a big corporation and if a group of players who are doing this for free can do it, then I assume the creators who do this for a living can too. Especially with all the resources they have available to them.
"Heres the problem, “female” meshes have more vertices in the breast area, that’s just the reality of how they set up the body templates. So when they converted male clothing they simply pushed out the vertices to somewhat match the female form, but there aren’t enough points to make it smooth and they didn’t bother to update the mesh."
If some clothing are more difficult and they didn't want to exclude it then they should have just took time to fix that and make it more passable. No one was expecting this update, no one was waiting for it, so honestly why the rush? That's just how I feel about it.
And I wanted to address these problems in the open so hopefully the creators can see this and see how upset people are about it and fix it.
They did address this in the patch notes/one of the articles (I forget). They said some of the things were harder to convert, but they went with the choice of giving people more options... Rather than leaving some things out because they weren't quite right.
I also have a feeling that they may have an automated process for doing a lot of the work of manipulating meshes to fit the other sex's body. Which is easier and quicker, at the expense of things really not being perfect.
I don't really blame them, knowing the volume of clothes they did. I'd go mad hand-tweaking meshes for hundreds of items too.
They are not going to get things just right no matter what they try. Unless they have a machine doing all the work, which is not likely.
Considering modders were able to do it, there is no excuse for a team of Engineers to do it. Also, as I said, several modders have CONVERTED clothes to the opposite sex (converted in the key word here because thats different than making something specifically for the other sex) and they succeeded just fine with no weird textural issues.......and they don't have the budget EA has and do it for free.......
Although honestly as long as I don't have a bunch of bugs added with the patch I don't mind.
I think this comes down to time afforded to the developers. Someone who is creating CC as a hobby has all of the time in the world to ensure their creations are exactly how they want to be but a cog in a corporate machine just isn't going to be afforded that same luxury so in that sense I can understand why some of the meshes aren't looking right because, to me, it just isn't a realistic expectation to put on the team.
I don't think it's fair at all to compare CC developers who answer to no one but themselves to a game development team who have to answer to deadlines and stick to budgets.
They did address this in the patch notes/one of the articles (I forget). They said some of the things were harder to convert, but they went with the choice of giving people more options... Rather than leaving some things out because they weren't quite right.
I'd rather they leave them out and work on the issues than give us half a--ed items lol. Like some items look pretty bad that if they left them out to fix, I wouldn't have missed them. They said this took them a year to figure out and yet things cc creators have been doing (converting male to female and vice versa), they could have at least smoothed out the bad bugs. Then fixed up the minor issues afterwards (a few weeks)?
but maybe that's just my opinion?
I think how each mesh looks depends somewhat on the sim's proportions. So if they checked them all quickly on one sim, they might have missed issues that only effect skinnier/plumper/buffer sims.
Like someone else says, they probably converted using a script of some kind, and did a manual once-over for anything obvious out of place. Imagine how long it would take to check every mesh, on every possible body type?
Actually we did have people checking things manually over and over again (I would chat with one of them everyday, all of the tagging for assets was done by hand) but it's not possible for us to notice everything which is why we depend on the community to alert us to any issues that might arise.
Just wanted to say, thank you so much for letting us know, @SimGuruDrake !
I would like to thank the devs for trying, too.
As long as things get fixed eventually as simmers point them out (like the bust on that dress mesh issue in Luxury Party that got fixed), then that would make me so very happy.
They did address this in the patch notes/one of the articles (I forget). They said some of the things were harder to convert, but they went with the choice of giving people more options... Rather than leaving some things out because they weren't quite right.
I also have a feeling that they may have an automated process for doing a lot of the work of manipulating meshes to fit the other sex's body. Which is easier and quicker, at the expense of things really not being perfect.
I don't really blame them, knowing the volume of clothes they did. I'd go mad hand-tweaking meshes for hundreds of items too.
They are not going to get things just right no matter what they try. Unless they have a machine doing all the work, which is not likely.
You really think EA, in 2016, does everything by hand still?
If it's not done by hand, why on earth did it take them a year to do?
Modders are already fixing the mesh issue, how is it that modders can fix it in under 24 hours when they are just ONE person with no budget, yet it took EA ONE YEAR to do....here is the very popular PickyPikachu explaining it.....
pickypikachu:
"Heres the problem, “female” meshes have more vertices in the breast area, that’s just the reality of how they set up the body templates. So when they converted male clothing they simply pushed out the vertices to somewhat match the female form, but there aren’t enough points to make it smooth and they didn’t bother to update the mesh. I don’t get how this took one year. The morph data is all over the place for the crotch area. Yes yes, good on them for being progressive and calling attention to this but I feel like deep down this was a publicity stunt and there was zero quality assurance. And then brushing it off by saying “we wanted to get this out there so it’s not perfect”. I’m mostly disappointed with this update. All that aside I am glad that a lot of you are loving it and finally making simselves that closely match yourselves and finally getting your characters into the clothing the belong in. But me, as a creator, cannot get over the sloppiness. Ugh"
That one person also has infinite time at their disposal and we do not. There were multiple people who were working on this. Those same people are always working on lots of other things at the same time. So comparing them to a single individual who has the free time available is unrealistic.
Unless she's unemployed and not actively looking for work, I imagine that modder has less time than Maxis staff.
You guys have a minimum 8 hours a day, 5 days a week. She has a couple of hours after work and/or school, and 2 full days each weekend, assuming no other commitments.
The issues I'm having with some clothing...The waistline is moved. The one on the right is where it should be, put if I add a converted top, it drops it down.
I'm not complaining at all -- I think it's amazing that they were able to do this. But I do agree that there's a problem in general with shirts that have ties on them when women try to wear them. As @Imkiture shows, the skirt drops down, possibly so that there's a gap between the bottom of the tie and the top of the waistband.
Definitely hoping that Maxis spends the next few patches fixing the glitches with the clothes! It's such a nice idea and some of them looked fine! But also some of them (like the hammer-pants) looked a little scary x). I prolly won't use the customization options but having the clothes unisex is SO much fun! Counting on you to fix the glitches, Maxis, pleaaaasse!
I think over all they did a good job and kudos to @SimGuruDrake for coming in to the thread. Is there some place we can report problems with meshes specifically? In the bug section or? I keep seeing pointy crotch problems mostly. For now I'm just avoiding things that look wrong to me, but really happy with the amount of stuff that looks great.
*edited for "plumming out" hmm what word do I use.. pointy between the legs mesh problems lol.
They did address this in the patch notes/one of the articles (I forget). They said some of the things were harder to convert, but they went with the choice of giving people more options... Rather than leaving some things out because they weren't quite right.
I'd rather they leave them out and work on the issues than give us half a--ed items lol. Like some items look pretty bad that if they left them out to fix, I wouldn't have missed them. They said this took them a year to figure out and yet things cc creators have been doing (converting male to female and vice versa), they could have at least smoothed out the bad bugs. Then fixed up the minor issues afterwards (a few weeks)?
but maybe that's just my opinion?
I think how each mesh looks depends somewhat on the sim's proportions. So if they checked them all quickly on one sim, they might have missed issues that only effect skinnier/plumper/buffer sims.
Like someone else says, they probably converted using a script of some kind, and did a manual once-over for anything obvious out of place. Imagine how long it would take to check every mesh, on every possible body type?
Actually we did have people checking things manually over and over again (I would chat with one of them everyday, all of the tagging for assets was done by hand) but it's not possible for us to notice everything which is why we depend on the community to alert us to any issues that might arise.
Comments
I think how each mesh looks depends somewhat on the sim's proportions. So if they checked them all quickly on one sim, they might have missed issues that only effect skinnier/plumper/buffer sims.
Like someone else says, they probably converted using a script of some kind, and did a manual once-over for anything obvious out of place. Imagine how long it would take to check every mesh, on every possible body type?
E.G. Some of the long hairs stick out weirdly to the sides on men with wide shoulders, but I've seen them on more slender males and they look fine.
Actually we did have people checking things manually over and over again (I would chat with one of them everyday, all of the tagging for assets was done by hand) but it's not possible for us to notice everything which is why we depend on the community to alert us to any issues that might arise.
Additionally I'm looping in @SimGuruArvin @SimGuruNick @SimQARobo so that they can keep an eye on your reports here
This is BULL, EA , I pay for your games and this happens.
Not good enough.
What issue are you having?
pickypikachu:
"Heres the problem, “female” meshes have more vertices in the breast area, that’s just the reality of how they set up the body templates. So when they converted male clothing they simply pushed out the vertices to somewhat match the female form, but there aren’t enough points to make it smooth and they didn’t bother to update the mesh. I don’t get how this took one year. The morph data is all over the place for the crotch area. Yes yes, good on them for being progressive and calling attention to this but I feel like deep down this was a publicity stunt and there was zero quality assurance. And then brushing it off by saying “we wanted to get this out there so it’s not perfect”. I’m mostly disappointed with this update. All that aside I am glad that a lot of you are loving it and finally making simselves that closely match yourselves and finally getting your characters into the clothing the belong in. But me, as a creator, cannot get over the sloppiness. Ugh"
Ahh, I was so worried that we were given something half hearted and was upset for a moment. I needed that clarification, I wouldn't have known otherwise!!
And yes, thank you for noticing our concerns!! I'm very happy with this update and how progressive Sims are becoming its just those things can really take me out of my immersion. Hope this topic was helpful for the Gurus to see the problems they didn't catch!
Disclaimer: He or Him! Not a girl!
-- Origin ID: Audio5urf --
Feel free to add me, and check out my gallery shenanigans.
That one person also has infinite time at their disposal and we do not. There were multiple people who were working on this. Those same people are always working on lots of other things at the same time. So comparing them to a single individual who has the free time available is unrealistic.
Also, their stance is different. Left is original female tshirt, and right is with a converted tshirt. Basically the same shirt, but different stance.
Don't know what it looks like in game, as I haven't gotten a chance to play yet, just messed with CAS.
The Tudor Legacy
Modders aren't doing every single piece of clothing- like 700 items. They chose a single jacket in one color and convert it and it often takes hours to do that one thing AND if it's not perfect the average simmer just shrugs and accepts it because it's a modder doing it. They way I look at it the stuff that works is still a nice addition that we didn't have before. If every single item is not perfect, so what? It was free and the stuff that's there to use is a welcome addition.
I think this comes down to time afforded to the developers. Someone who is creating CC as a hobby has all of the time in the world to ensure their creations are exactly how they want to be but a cog in a corporate machine just isn't going to be afforded that same luxury so in that sense I can understand why some of the meshes aren't looking right because, to me, it just isn't a realistic expectation to put on the team.
I don't think it's fair at all to compare CC developers who answer to no one but themselves to a game development team who have to answer to deadlines and stick to budgets.
Edit: Crud, missed SimGuruDrake's comment.
Just wanted to say, thank you so much for letting us know, @SimGuruDrake !
I would like to thank the devs for trying, too.
As long as things get fixed eventually as simmers point them out (like the bust on that dress mesh issue in Luxury Party that got fixed), then that would make me so very happy.
(She/her)
If it's not done by hand, why on earth did it take them a year to do?
Unless she's unemployed and not actively looking for work, I imagine that modder has less time than Maxis staff.
You guys have a minimum 8 hours a day, 5 days a week. She has a couple of hours after work and/or school, and 2 full days each weekend, assuming no other commitments.
Apples and oranges.
still waiting for bg hair to be re-textured....
complete forum tutorial
Thank you @MDianaSanders for halloween-fying Golluma
I'm not complaining at all -- I think it's amazing that they were able to do this. But I do agree that there's a problem in general with shirts that have ties on them when women try to wear them. As @Imkiture shows, the skirt drops down, possibly so that there's a gap between the bottom of the tie and the top of the waistband.
*edited for "plumming out" hmm what word do I use.. pointy between the legs mesh problems lol.
So far I'm loving the lighting in the game.. Wow.
OMG thank you!