But still, how would he know that Broncos is a townie unless he has meta knowledge, meaning that he's a mafia? Broncos didn't really claim to be a townie in that post.
Uhm. Just a thought but what if DJ is mafia and therefore knows that broncos is a townie. What if he thought that he was lynched already. Why else would he say that his gut feeling was wrong without having conformation that broncos was lynched and a townie?
That's ok. And I must've missed the post you mentioned because I'm pretty sure I'm the first one who proposed that idea. Not sure about the concept that they'd both have to agree on killing someone because when my partner wasn't there in the last mafia game I just picked someone and told Broncos to wait and change it to…
Nobody got killed, that's really interesting. There's no doctor in this game so really the only way this could happen is for the mafia not to choose anyone. I knew that it's possible for the mafia to not kill but it doesn't really make sense because they wasted an opportunity to get rid of a townie. Hm. Are we sure it is a…
Maria Reynolds was my first pick and I'm definitely not a Hamilton fan so I wouldn't be too sure about Hamilton fans not picking her. That's why I think it might be best to just throw character theories completely overboard because so far none of them really add up all too much.
Thank you, I appreciate it. I'm actually feeling a bit better already, I think I might be allergic to cut grass or hay or something like that. I left my window open and when I woke up I felt all clogged up and it was really hard to breathe. A friend told me to take an ibuprofen and I'm feeling better now. @Kandy To be fair…
I have similar feelings about that but I also have doubts about it. I believe that one of the people who voted for him might be mafia trying to lynch someone apart from Ava, which would put you and Broncos in the spotlight. Me too of course, but obviously I know I'm town. So either you or Broncos or I'm completely off,…
Thanks, good catch! I completely missed that and wasn't exactly sure why everyone voted for her. Well, this is definitely an interesting development. We have to take a closer look at everyone who either no voted or voted for hussein, though to be honest I'm still not sure about him. I feel like I might just be completely…
I think I'm missing something when it comes to Ava. I feel like I have more reason to vote for husseinandali so that's what I'm going to do. Vote: husseinandali
You're not lynched (yet) but people think you're suspicious because you haven't been talking. Nobody was lynched on day 1 and Keyen was killed at night.
Sorry Kandy, I didn't see your post before posting mine or I would've simply agreed with you. As for your theory on newcomers picking obvious characters, I think it's accurate but has a flaw, which is that the obvious roles would be taken already if you joined later on. I think the earlier people signed up the likelier it…
Good job, Keyen! I'm sad to see that we don't get to play longer with you though. Keyen was attacked because he went against Lucky? No, I'm pretty sure Keyen was attacked because he was a confirmed town, a good player and someone we could've looked up to and oriented ourselves after - someone dangerous for the mafia that…
I said it's something akin to bullying if you penalize one person but not on others who have done the same (or an even worse) thing... Not exactly bullying. I just can't come up with the proper english word. But what I said was directed at Submarine and not an attack on you so I didn't expect an explanation from you and…
Personally I think if we force Lucky to contribute we also have to do the same with everyone else who hasn't posted that much. Otherwise it's unfair treatment and something akin to bullying. We can't exclude someone because they don't talk that much and not exclude anyone else because they don't talk that much. That's just…
@Keyenpeydee The role is accurate, the person isn't. In fact I had to look him up. I literally only know two people on the list, the one I chose and the one I wanted to choose but couldn't because they were taken already. And I don't even know those all that well, I read like, a 2 sentence synopsys of who they are and…
I know that you didn't advocate for her lynch but I still think it's suspicious that the first thought would be that she's mafia because she's silent. You said it yourself, the last two times she was townie and her original strategies didn't work out, so if she was townie again wouldn't it make sense for her to also change…
To be honest, and this is seriously the third time I'm defending Lucky at the beginning of a game, I think she's just sick of being lynched or killed early. I don't think that's suspicious but instead a natural reaction to talking a lot and dying because of it. I feel like the people who are making a big deal out of her…
It's icredible how this mafia seems to have a completely different atmosphere than the two other ones, to be honest. Maybe it's because Lucky isn't here but I feel like this is starting off a little more serious than the others.
Vote: Crafty There's basically no other basis for this other than I have a bad feeling about her. And in this early stage, that means almost nothing. But I feel like to vote someone will tell us more than if we don't vote, no matter the outcome of that lynch. And to be honest, I don't want to vote Keyen simply because he…
A story about camping, a discussion about sports, a bunch of sentences that don't make sense to me (probably because they're references) and I'm completely lost... And the first day isn't even over. Good job people. Good job. :lol:
I like that you're actually trying to help newcomers, like myself (kinda). Personally I don't feel you're scummy because you voted for Crafty because I've seen players do that and it meaning nothing. In my very first game Lucky was RVS'd to test the reaction but I find that a bit silly, there's no real way someone could…
Alright, I finally also have arrived... I usually forget about these games untill they actually start... I'm so sorry! I don't understand why everyone is voting for Keyen right now though because he hasn't really done anything? Or am I missing something?