Forum Announcement, Click Here to Read More From EA_Cade.

Expansion Packs Ranking

«1
AlanSimsAlanSims Posts: 720 Member
Now that we have 15 expansion packs, are you able to rank them from Favorite to Least Favorite ? It's a bit hard so this is probably my list right now:

1. Seasons
2. Cats & Dogs
3. City Living
4. Growing Together
5. Cottage Living
6. Eco Lifestyle
7. Get To Work
8. Get Famous
9. Get Together (The world is 90% reason)
10. Discover University
11. For Rent
12. Snowy Escape
13. Island Living
14. Horse Ranch
15. Highschool Years

I've played with Horse Ranch and For Rent just a bit though. I'm sure that with more time these will probably go higher.

Comments

  • Options
    EllupelluelluEllupelluellu Posts: 7,284 Member
    1. Cottage Living
    2. Horse Ranch
    3. Island Living
    4. City Living
    5. Eco Lifestyle
    6. Get Famous
    7. Cats & Dogs
    8. Get Together
    9. Snowy Escape
    10. Discover University
    11. Seasons
    12. Growing Together
    13. Highschool Years
    14. Get To Work

    Not having For Rent yet.
    My love, my love, my fearless love, I will not say goodbye..
    Sea may rise, sky may fall, My love will never die..
    My heart, my heart, My drowning heart, Oh all the tears I've cried
    Oh I may weep forevermore, My love will never die..
    My Story:Villa Catarina
  • Options
    Frn0731Frn0731 Posts: 7,180 Member
    edited January 17
    1. Seasons
    2. Get Together (not only because it's the most beautiful World)
    3. City Living
    4. Cottage Living
    5. Discover University
    6. Island living
    7. Cats and Dogs (Mainly for the world)
    8. Snowy escape
    9. Get to work
    10. Eco Lifestyle
    11. Highschool years
    12. Get Famous
    13. Growing Together
    I don't have For Rent and Horse Ranch. I probably will by 'For Rent' soon and am not interested in Horse Ranch. Maybe I will get it for the buy build stuff.

    I just bought For Rent. I would rate it last place.
    Post edited by Frn0731 on
    Laugh out loud. Often
  • Options
    GordyGordy Posts: 3,063 Member
    1. Cottage Living
    2. Growing Together
    3. Seasons
    4. Get Famous
    5. Cats & Dogs
    6. Snowy Escape
    7. Island Living
    8. Get Together
    9. City Living
    10. For Rent
    11. Horse Ranch
    12. Highschool Years
    13. Eco Lifestyle
    14. Get To Work
    15. Discover University
    🐲🐲🐲🐲
    The Sims 4 hasn't introduced a new musical instrument since 2017
    🐲🐲🐲🐲
  • Options
    alanmichael1alanmichael1 Posts: 5,459 Member
    1. Get Famous
    2. Snowy Escape
    3. Cottage Living
    4. Highschool Years
    5. Get To Work
    6. Eco Lifestyle
    7. Cats & Dogs
    8. Horse Ranch
    9. Seasons
    10. City Living
    11. For Rent
    12. Get Together
    13. Discover University
    14. Growing Together
    15. Island Living
  • Options
    Lenny_OggLenny_Ogg Posts: 3,696 Member

    1. Highschool Years because without this pack 'The Boys' would have never happened 😱
    2. Horse Ranch changed our lives because we can't live without 🐐 and 🐎 anymore
    3. For Rent because it gave us our first home and it's stunningly beautiful 🌺
    4b475c7656d1f799246eac2d50cd4d2771f3248b.jpg
    4. Snowy Escape because it's perfect and beautiful 🎏
    5. Cottage Living because the world is beautiful and 🐓 and 🐇
    6. Island Living also perfect and beautiful 🏝
    7. City Living because San Myshuno 🏙
    8. Cats & Dogs, even though I didn't like the animals as much as I thought
    9. University Living. We only discovered recently wow beautiful Britechester is ^^'
    10. Get Together. Windenburg is stunning and the Club system is so mighty and underrated
    11. Get to Work. Great careers. And aliens! And a faboulous build/buy(debug)
    12. Get Famous
    My most hated packs are:
    13. Seasons. Totally ruined gardening for me. And I loved gardening a lot 🍃
    14. Eco Lifestyle. NAPs omg
    15. Growing Together. Totally useless for me. It's one of the very few packs I regret buying (this and Menswear Fashion ^^')

    (I don't care a lot about gameplay ;))
    d70aead6bd57d9113e587b03ecffce84b09267d0.jpgThe Boys 2 - Therapy Game 🛺 A Dramedy 🚶🏼🚶🏻🚶🏽🚶🏽 The Boys 🥇 Their first year - A Dramedy 🚀 Lost In Space - A Space Opera 🐎 The Stables - A Horse Drama
    🎁 Best of Buydebug ☃️ Short trips to the Oggiverse - Short Clips 🎬 My Builds: Houses 🏘 Rooms 🛋 SciFi 👾 creatively edited Screenshots 🎨
  • Options
    EternalSunshineEternalSunshine Posts: 340 Member
    Of the EPs that I own, at the moment, I would rank them:

    1. Cottage Living
    2. Get Together
    3. Seasons
    4. Eco Lifestyle
    5. Get To Work
    6. Cats & Dogs
    7. Horse Ranch
    8. Discover University
    9. City Living
    10. Get Famous
    11. Growing Together
    12. Snowy Escape
    13. Island Living

    I don't own Highschool Years or For Rent.
  • Options
    RememberJoyRememberJoy Posts: 1,143 Member
    It's hard for me to rank the expansions because I like stuff from all of them, so I'll just put them into categories:

    Must Have:
    Seasons
    Island Living
    Cottage Living
    City Living
    Get Together

    Like To Have:
    For Rent
    Eco Lifestyle
    Horse Ranch
    Snowy Escape
    Cats & Dogs
    Get Famous
    Discover University
    Get to Work

    Could Play Without:
    Growing Together
    Highschool Years

    The last two could move up after I play with them some more, but right now I could remove them and not miss them too much.
  • Options
    BluegayleBluegayle Posts: 4,239 Member
    1.Horse Ranch
    2. Seasons
    3. Cottage Living
    4. Cats & Dogs
    5. Growing Together
    6. Island Living
    7. Get Together
    8. Get To Work
    9. Eco Lifestyle
    10. City Living
    11. For Rent ( havent had time to play much so not sure on rating)
    12. Snowy Escape
    13. Discover University
    14. Highschool Years
    15. Get Famous
    "Every child matters. If we fail our children, we are bound to fail our present, our future, faith, cultures, and civilizations as well."
    ZO6GpFg.jpg
  • Options
    LeucosiaXLeucosiaX Posts: 1,853 Member
    edited January 10
    #1 Seasons
    #2 Cottage Living
    #3 Cats & Dogs
    #4 City Living
    #5 Get Together
    #6 Get To Work
    #7 Get Famous
    #8 Island Living
    #9 Discover University
    #10 Horse Ranch
    #11 Snowy Escape
    #12 High School Years
    #13 Growing Together
    #14 For Rent
    #15 Eco Lifestyle
  • Options
    mrs_starkeymrs_starkey Posts: 187 Member
    1. Seasons
    2. Cottage Living
    3. Cats & Dogs
    4. Horse Ranch
    5. Growing Together
    6. Eco Lifestyle
    7. City Living
    8. Get Together
    9. Island Living
    10. Discover University
    11. For Rent
    12. Snowy Escape
    13. Highschool Years
    14. Get To Work
    15. Get Famous
  • Options
    simgirl1010simgirl1010 Posts: 36,360 Member
    1. Cats & Dogs
    2. Horse Ranch
    3. Cottage Living
    4. Growing Together
    5. Discover University
    6. High School Years
    7. Seasons
    8. Get To Work
    9. Get Famous
    10. Eco Lifestyle
    11. City Living
    12. Snowy Escape
    13. Get Together
    14. Island Living
    15. For Rent
  • Options
    SERVERFRASERVERFRA Posts: 7,199 Member
    1. Seasons ties with Snow Escape B)<3:p;)
    2. Get Together ties with Cottage Living ties with Horse Ranch <3B)
    3. Island Living <3<3
    4. Discover University ties with High School ties with Get Famous B)
    5. Cats & Dogs ties with Growing Together :p;)
    6. Get to Work ties with Eco Living :p
    7. For Rent :'(
  • Options
    PandoraTOPandoraTO Posts: 485 Member
    1. Seasons
    2. City Living
    3. Get Together
    4. Cottage Living
    5. Cats & Dogs
    6. Get To Work
    7. Eco Lifestyle
    8. Island Living
    9. Snowy Escape
    10. High School Years
    11. Get Famous
    12. Discover University

    I don’t have For Rent (too buggy), Horse Ranch (not interested) or Growing Together (maybe when it’s 50% off).
  • Options
    mightyspritemightysprite Posts: 6,098 Member
    Dang! I like all the ones I have. hmm

    Okay this is in order of "how angry would I be if this got taken out of my game" ...

    1. City Living
    2. Seasons
    3. Discover University
    4. Get Together
    5. Get to Work
    6. Eco Lifestyle
    7. Growing Together
    8. High School Years
    9. Cottage Living
    10. Cats & Dogs
    11. Snowy Escape
    12. Get Famous

    I don't have: Island Living (might get someday), For Rent (will get when they fix the bugs), Horse Ranch (might get someday).
  • Options
    ChadSims2ChadSims2 Posts: 5,094 Member
    1. Get Together
    2. Highschool Years
    3. Snowy Escape
    4. Growing Together
    5. Island Living
    6. Seasons
    7. Get Famous
    8. City Living
    9. Cottage Living

    After 9 packs become pretty useless at this point I'm rating useable objects like dumpsters and hopscotch not game play because the packs are just that bad.

    10. Eco Lifestyle
    11. Get to Work
    12. For Rent
    13. Discover University
    14. Horse Ranch
    15. Cats & Dogs
    Sims 4 went from "You Rule" to "One of the stories we want you to tell"
  • Options
    auroraael14auroraael14 Posts: 988 Member
    edited January 12
    1. Seasons 10/10 - I love the changing of seasons and the holidays. This is by far my favorite pack and I love that there is something for every age group to do.
    2. Growing Together 9\10 - I am a family player and this was the pack I had been waiting for since the release of toddlers. It makes the game feel more like a life simulation. I love the world this pack comes with, the build/buy, and the CAS. Again, another must-have pack when I play the Sims.
    3. High School Years 9\10 - I play rotationally and find it fun to spend a day with my teens while they're at school. I love the social bunny app, prom, and that my teens can graduate and I can have the family attend. Another great pack for my type of gameplay.
    4. For Rent 8\10 - I have seen people report that this pack is buggy but I have not had a single bug *knock on wood*. I have had a lot of fun building apartments, townhomes, and a trailer park where my Broke household lives in. The build/buy and CAS are pretty great too.
    5. Cottage Living 8\10 - I love the world that comes with this pack. It's one of my favorites. The CAS and build/buy are awesome. I'm just not a fan of the actual gameplay as I don't really play with animals.
    6. Get Together 8\10 - Another must-have almost for the world alone. I love the world so much. Don't forget the club feature.
    7. Snowy Escape 6\10 - I love sending my sims on vacation and this is usually where my sims go to get away from their day-to-day life.
    8. City Living 6\10 - I like the world and the apartments that came with City Living. It's just okay. I feel like something is lacking from this pack.
    9. Discover University 5\10 - It's okay. I don't send a lot of sims to college because it is so time-consuming.
    10. Cats & Dogs 5\10 - Most of my sims do not have any animals. I find them tedious to take care of. It feels like a chore.
    11. Island Living 4\10 - Another vacation spot for my sims otherwise I don't usually have sims live here and I don't use a lot of the items that come in this pack.
    12. Get to Work 4\10 - I use the careers sometimes but I don't usually want to go to work with my sims. Again it feels like a chore.
    13. Get Famous 2\10 - I don't use this pack that often. I sometimes will play in the world otherwise none of my sims are famous.
    14. Horse Ranch 1\10 - I have not played around with this pack. I think the world is beautiful but I don't think a whole expansion needed to be focused around horses. I don't like playing with animals so this pack didn't really appeal to me.
    15. Eco Lifestyle 0\10 - This is my least favorite pack. I wouldn't necessarily say it's useless but it's just not my cup of tea.
    Post edited by auroraael14 on
    Check out my gallery for house builds! Username: aejp24
  • Options
    SimDork23SimDork23 Posts: 524 Member
    1. Seasons
    2. Cats & Dogs
    3. Growing Together
    4. High School Years
    5. Snowy Escape
    6. Discover University
    7. Island Living
    8. Horse Ranch
    9. Eco Lifestyle
    10. For Rent
    11. City Living
    12. Get Famous
    13. Get Together
    14. Get To Work
    15. Cottage Living
  • Options
    Atreya33Atreya33 Posts: 4,532 Member
    edited January 10
    Sorting the EP's is difficult so I made 3 groups. The order within the group is a close call and may vary over time.

    Must haves
    1. Cottage living
    2. Get together
    3. Seasons
    Enjoyed them a lot
    4. Discover university
    5. Snowy escape
    6. Horse ranch
    7. Island living
    8. Get to work
    9. Growing together
    Not essential for my game
    10. City living
    11. Eco lifestyle
    12. Cats & Dogs
    13. Get Famous

    For Rent: don't own it yet so can't tell
    High school years : no intention to buy it so at the very bottom of the list.
  • Options
    haisinhaisin Posts: 954 Member
    It's so hard to rank them.
    1. Island Living (I like the world and beach activities)
    2. Get Together (the club system is useful and I love the world)
    3. Seasons (sometimes the weather is annoying, but it would be so different to play without it)
    4. Get Famous (I don't play famous sims all the time, but I like playing them)
    5. Cottage Living (I love the rabbits and chickens, but I don't like the quests that much)
    6. Discover University (It's actually surprising that I like uni a lot, I thought it would be boring, but I have had good uni years with my sims)
    7. Snowy Escape (I really like rock climbing and some other stuff, but the festivals not that much and I think the world could be better)
    8. Horse Ranch (I bought it yesterday so haven't really played much yet, but I'm excited about nectar making and well the horses too)
    9. Cats & Dogs (cats and dogs make good familiars)
    10. City Living (I love karaoke and some of the cas and bb, but I don't usually play much in San Myshuno and I have kind of seen the festivals already)
    11. Eco Lifestyle (I use some of the cas and bb and dumpster diving is fun, but that's that maybe)

    I only listed the ones I own, so Get to Work, For Rent, Growing Together and High School Years didn't make it to the list. I might be interested in For Rent or Growing Together.
  • Options
    mustenimusteni Posts: 5,417 Member
    edited January 10
    I enjoy all the packs, but some more...
    1. Seasons 10/10
    2. Growing Together 9/10
    3. Horse Ranch 9/10
    4. Get Together 9/10
    5. City Living 8/10
    6. Cottage Living 8/10
    7. Get Famous 8/10
    8. Island Living 7/10
    9. Snowy Escape 7/10
    10. For Rent 6/10
    11. Highschool Years 6/10
    12. Get To Work 6/10
    13. Cats & Dogs 5/10
    14. Eco Lifestyle 4/10
    15. Discover University 4/10
  • Options
    RandomTokenCodeRandomTokenCode Posts: 189 Member
    edited January 10
    I have all new packs, but it doesn't mean I love them. I just for the time-limited incentive.

    1. City Living
    2. Growing Together
    3. High School Years
    4. Eco Lifestyle
    5. Seasons
    6. Get Together
    7. Island Living
    8. For Rent
    9. Cottage Living
    10. Get to Work
    11. Cats and Dogs
    12. Get Famous
    13. Snowy Escape
    14. Discover University
    15. Horse Ranch
  • Options
    Erja888Erja888 Posts: 4,846 Member
    My ranking is currently:

    1. Cottage Living
    2. Seasons
    3. Get Together
    4. Get Famous
    5. City Living
    6. Horse Ranch
    7. High School Years
    8. Snowy Escape
    9. Eco Lifestyle
    10. Growing Together
    11. Cats and Dogs
    12. For Rent
    13. Island Living
    14. Get to work
    15. Discover University
    I'd love to see a singing career in game, EA! You can't let the singing skill go to waste! My TS4 EPs: GTW, GT, CL, C&D, S, GF, IL, DU, EL, SE, CoL, HSY, GrT, HR, FR GPs: OR, SD, DO, V, P, JA, SV, RoM, DHD, MWS
  • Options
    mikamakimonmikamakimon Posts: 470 Member
    This might be different on another day, but for today, here is my ranking:

    1 - Cottage Living
    2 - Snowy Escape
    3 - City Living
    4 - Cats and Dogs
    5 - Get to Work
    6 - Island Living
    7 - Horse Ranch - new pack for me and I haven't fully explored this yet
    8 - Seasons
    9 - Get Together
    10 - Discover University
    11 - Eco Lifestyle
    12 - Get Famous

    I don't have For Rent, High School Years, or Growing Together yet, so no ranking for these.
  • Options
    AlanSimsAlanSims Posts: 720 Member
    Very interesting to see everyone's list. Seasons and Cottage Living seem to be the most liked and the rest are very random. I also see Growing Together, Cats & Dogs at either Top or Bottom.
  • Options
    lucombrelucombre Posts: 45 Member
    Absolutely essential:
    Growing Together (really transforms the game)
    Get Together (club system and world)
    City Living (I’m a city person irl)
    Eco Lifestyle (dumpsters, hobbies)
    For rent (allows so many more options for housing and communities)
    Cottage Living (simple living feature and world)
    Discover University (gives sims a proper young adulthood)

    Wouldn’t want to play without:
    Cats and Dogs
    Island Living
    Get Famous

    Nice to have:
    Snowy Escape
    Get to Work

    Don’t have:
    Seasons (I like my eternally sunny worlds 😆)
    Horse Ranch (will get eventually)
    High School Years (probably don’t want due to all the annoying events)
Sign In or Register to comment.
Return to top