This site has entered read-only mode as of July 18th. The new Forums.EA.com are now live.

Which Goths Do You Prefer?

SimmingalSimmingal Posts: 9,333 Member
Since now we have different version of Goths in the game there was poll on twitter about which you prefer so I figured we need forum version soo yes which The Sims 4 version of The Goth Family do you prefer?
⭐️ AHQ Champion 🦇 Vlad Advocate 🐉 Team Dragons
🏡 Gallery 📖 Stories 🌍 World Project 🥔 MOD/CC Free

Which Goths Do You Prefer? 234 votes

Old Version (2014-2022)
58%
SimCrazyCK213KamioIcewolfSamadamsPlayerOmri147WrenryColorist40AprilDawnPlayerSinger2010imhappydanacnbrettMontrase102rhaliusDOLLDRMS1shellbemeSnuffyBucketmaggiemae8135Anmirla5031first 137 votes
New Version (2022 - ?)
20%
BluegayleEvvieSimmerJueJuexoJessiScrapdashncisGibbs02CynnaCharell88BeardedgeekBoergeAarg61simgirl1010DevSims91NRoweKennziKaigeLizzychicagogreydonnphantasmkisslanlynFraTacTrashmagic 48 votes
Justine Keaton but Goth
5%
CamkatTheSpotted_CmcruddStrangerthanBabykittyjadebixtersMDianaSimsColton147147Pamtastic72happyopisuperkyle221Mondayfiggy 13 votes
No you don't get Other option.
15%
auroraael14Cabelle1863rudolphafriendlysimmersMindofyYautjagirlmitchiebanjoladybreidSimplyJenMilutinMujovicCarmineMissmagoo2viola-illyriacynciejoleacoEnkiSchmidtImSandsModerateOspreyDoodlyDoofusHorrorgirl6 36 votes

Comments

  • Options
    MilutinMujovicMilutinMujovic Posts: 1,188 Member
    edited May 2022
    No you don't get Other option.
    I prefer my own Goths. At least I did them more justice than Maxis in both attempts in TS4.
    Images:
    aDQTRfb.png
    ezT7hy8.png
    wfokehR.png
    ytVfMcV.png
    UZNbIoq.png
  • Options
    DoloresGreyDoloresGrey Posts: 3,493 Member
    Old Version (2014-2022)
    Poor Alexander didn't get any justice. He looks even worse now.
    -probably just playing Phasmophobia :p
  • Options
    GordyGordy Posts: 3,105 Member
    Old Version (2014-2022)
    Neither were great, but at least Bella and Alexander resembled their TS2 selves. Mortimer just looks uglier now. Cassandra Goth, while pretty, doesn't feel like Cassandra Goth with either look.
    🐲🐲🐲🐲
    The Sims 4 hasn't introduced a new musical instrument since 2017
    🐲🐲🐲🐲
  • Options
    UniqueKhaosUniqueKhaos Posts: 470 Member
    No you don't get Other option.
    My own. New Goths are horrible, old Goths are less horrible.
  • Options
    SimmingalSimmingal Posts: 9,333 Member
    edited May 2022
    Old Version (2014-2022)
    I prefer my own Goths.

    Of course but I told you theres no other option on this poll so now your Goths got eaten by mother plant poor pals :blush:

    //Jkjk I mean I prefer my own too but they are edited from old version so its still vote towards old version

    edit: okay I see the pictures now your Goths are cute I will save them from the mother
    ⭐️ AHQ Champion 🦇 Vlad Advocate 🐉 Team Dragons
    🏡 Gallery 📖 Stories 🌍 World Project 🥔 MOD/CC Free
  • Options
    BoergeAarg61BoergeAarg61 Posts: 985 Member
    edited May 2022
    New Version (2022 - ?)
    No idea but probably picked the wrong one.
    I actually play parts of the old version which is now the new version in my game. The only exceptions are the ones who died from old age.

    Some pictures might be added later when the new kits are released and bought. So far, my Goths are divided into three different households.

    Edit: Here are the latest pictures of the four Goths in my game.

    26.05.2022_19.53.14.png

    26.05.2022_19.53.33.png

    26.05.2022_19.56.36.png

    26.05.2022_19.59.27.png
    Post edited by BoergeAarg61 on
  • Options
    VeeDubVeeDub Posts: 1,862 Member
    Old Version (2014-2022)
    I don't really care because if they survive pre-made purges in any of my saves I always make 'em over, anyway. But for general aesthetics, I found the earlier versions more appealing.
    FYI: Just because you can see my signature, don't assume that I can see yours.
    Because I can't; I keep all sigs turned off. ;)
  • Options
    simgirl1010simgirl1010 Posts: 36,556 Member
    New Version (2022 - ?)
    I never play them but if I remember correctly Bella is in my sim's reading club.
  • Options
    DaniRose2143DaniRose2143 Posts: 9,396 Member
    edited May 2022
    No you don't get Other option.
    If a pre-made sim or family of sims is going to be a major part of my saves they are getting makeovers. And when I get done with them it's usually hard to tell what they looked like before what with all the cc.

    - New Mortimer is vastly better than old Morty
    - I prefer new Bella, but new or old she gets the glam treatment head to toe and looks 100% better when I'm done with her.<two snaps up>
    - Stop me if you heard this before, I prefer new Cassandra.
    - Kill it! kill it! kill it before it kills us all!!! Oh....that was Alexander? It thought it was so some hideously sick, twisted, lab experiment that got loose. Would you look at that, we actually found a use for the 'We wear bags' NAP!
  • Options
    Omri147Omri147 Posts: 11,178 Member
    Old Version (2014-2022)
    I feel like they were stripped away from their iconic attributes.
    Mortimer's full mustache, Cassandra's round glasses (though I do prefer her 'new' skintone), Alexander's rich nerd chic, and most importantly, Bella's iconic dress. They just don't feel like themselves anymore.
  • Options
    SimmingalSimmingal Posts: 9,333 Member
    edited May 2022
    Old Version (2014-2022)
    New Rule:

    If you picked Other despite there not being Other option because you have your own version of Goths you now have to share them on this thread so we can admire their beauty

    Otherwise horrible curse will fall upon them
    ⭐️ AHQ Champion 🦇 Vlad Advocate 🐉 Team Dragons
    🏡 Gallery 📖 Stories 🌍 World Project 🥔 MOD/CC Free
  • Options
    DaniRose2143DaniRose2143 Posts: 9,396 Member
    No you don't get Other option.
    Simmingal wrote: »
    New Rule:

    If you picked Other despite there not being Other option because you have your own version of Goths you now have to share them on this thread so we can admire their beauty

    Otherwise horrible curse will fall upon them

    I will be back shortly. This calls for a special brand new Bella. Which the way I work in CAS means I'll see you this afternoon.

  • Options
    logionlogion Posts: 4,791 Member
    Old Version (2014-2022)
    Their old looks never bothered me but what kinda bothers me now is that the new Goths doesn't look like the same sims that have been around me for 8 years.

    What matters to me is what you remember them by and what you did with them when playing the game and it feels like that disappears when you change their looks so they don't look like how you remember them.
  • Options
    MilutinMujovicMilutinMujovic Posts: 1,188 Member
    No you don't get Other option.
    Simmingal wrote: »
    I prefer my own Goths.

    Of course but I told you theres no other option on this poll so now your Goths got eaten by mother plant poor pals :blush:

    //Jkjk I mean I prefer my own too but they are edited from old version so its still vote towards old version

    edit: okay I see the pictures now your Goths are cute I will save them from the mother

    Haha thank you.

    For anyone wondering, I tried to keep them as close as I could to the original TS2 versions. However, unlike Maxis, I used genetics to generate Cassandra, Alexander, and Mathilde.
    If anyone is interested I can show you how they look as adults.
  • Options
    ImSandsImSands Posts: 337 Member
    No you don't get Other option.
    I'm playing with the new Goth now and they are growing on me. Time will tell which I prefer in the end.
  • Options
    haisinhaisin Posts: 957 Member
    Old Version (2014-2022)
    I think it would have been better to let them be. The new Goths are as good as any other Goths I could download from the gallery. The old ones or the new ones don't completely match with the idea I have of the Goths, but I don't really expect that either. I will edit them if I want to play them.
  • Options
    SimmingalSimmingal Posts: 9,333 Member
    Old Version (2014-2022)

    If you think the original from the Maxis remake was bad, the first time I aged him up to adult this is what the game generated..
    z3nlgOL.png

    its so bad its almost fashionable :lol:
    ⭐️ AHQ Champion 🦇 Vlad Advocate 🐉 Team Dragons
    🏡 Gallery 📖 Stories 🌍 World Project 🥔 MOD/CC Free
  • Options
    DaniRose2143DaniRose2143 Posts: 9,396 Member
    No you don't get Other option.
    Simmingal wrote: »

    If you think the original from the Maxis remake was bad, the first time I aged him up to adult this is what the game generated..
    z3nlgOL.png

    its so bad its almost fashionable :lol:

    When his adult form popped up I was reminded of the old adage that it can always be worse....yep. Proof of that under the spoiler. And seeing new Bella in CAS not live mode, I'm a bit surprised at how different she looks. I'm working on her but the new one doesn't respond to my cc like the old Bella. I have to rethink my take. Back to work.
  • Options
    DoodlyDoofusDoodlyDoofus Posts: 1,188 Member
    No you don't get Other option.
    I like the new Mortimer especially his new speedos because forget you guys, that's fun and silly, Bella's new skintone, the fact that Cassandra's new face doesn't make weird faced children (Only ever time I've married Cassandra in my game I always got these flat faced children that just looked....bad). That's about it. I don't like everything else....But I despise Alexander. Holy hell, you'd think they'd learn that just because you work hard to make a decent face for a kid doesn't mean they'll grow up well...you know, like Arlo Bunch and 2014 Alexander. I guess Alexander will just die tragically when a fire starts in a room where his doors disappeared so he can't pass on those unfortunate genetics.
  • Options
    DaniRose2143DaniRose2143 Posts: 9,396 Member
    No you don't get Other option.
    I am now reinstalling my alpha cc because new Bella does not take to Maxis match. In live mode and screenshots I didn't appreciate just how different she really is in this new version. The changes are more than I realized. I am now officially off the new Bella bandwagon.

    Being a woman of my word, I will have a new version of her, but I'm not as confident of the outcome as I was a while ago.🤣
  • Options
    OnverserOnverser Posts: 3,364 Member
    Old Version (2014-2022)
    I don't mind the darker skin tones, and I like the new Mortimer and Cassandra, but this new Bella isn't Bella. She's supposed to be this semi-unrealistic Jessica Rabbit type character, apart from the skin tone being wrong they'd nailed that look with the old Bella.

    I get they wanted to make her look older since she has kids, but realistically Cassandra only looks about 15 so Bella could easily be mid 30s, it would totally fit for her to have a teenage daughter and still look young. No idea what happened to Alexander, seems like they didn't even look for reference pictures before changing him
  • Options
    ModerateOspreyModerateOsprey Posts: 4,875 Member
    No you don't get Other option.
    deleted long, long ago
    Awake.
    Shake dreams from your hair
    My pretty child, my sweet one.
    Choose the day and choose the sign of your day
    The day's divinity....
    The Ghost Song - Jim Morrison
  • Options
    FraTacFraTac Posts: 854 Member
    New Version (2022 - ?)
    I have the new ones but did some tweaks with things that I prefer from the old ones. I gave Cassandra her original haircut and gave Alexander a massive makeover so he doesn't look that ugly when he ages up.

    OMkAa6h.png

    fmCDY4Z.png
    xWGF2yb.png
    Simmin' since 2000
  • Options
    IsharellIsharell Posts: 1,158 Member
    Old Version (2014-2022)
    I prefer the old version, although I admit new Mortimer is ok - at least now he looks less boring. They made Bella look way too old - I love how old Bella looks too young to have a kid as old as Cassandra. This way I could always sneer at Morty as a cradle-robbing pig (or pretend Bella is Cassie's stepmom). New Bella has lost her spark of specialness.

    If that is how Alexander grows up he needs to be killed before he can procreate. I don't even want any risk at all, that sim has to go.

    I particularly dislike the new Cassandra - she doesn't look like herself at all.
Sign In or Register to comment.
Return to top