I find little to no continuity across all 4 versions, so by titie:
TS1 - Bella Goth
TS2 - Cassandra Goth & Lilith Pleasant (the latter after SIMPE repairs to the hosing EA gave her)
TS3 - didn't get into it
TS4 - Summer Holiday & Cassandra Goth (the latter after YA-ing & de-gloomifying)
I have more than a few favorites from every game except the first. Its been way too long since I played it and I didn't have it long enough to ever get the hang of it because it was a rental.
Gunther Goth(TS3)
Bella Goth(TS2)
Conelia Goth(TS3)
Mortimer Goth(TS2&3)
Alexander Goth(TS2&4)
Cassandra Goth(Ts2&4)
Lolita Goth(TS3)
Thornton Wolff(TS3)
Morgana Wolff(TS3)
Liberty Lee(TS4)
Morgyn Ember(TS4)
Caleb Vatore(TS4)
Max Vilareal(TS4)
Malcolm Landgraab(TS2,3,& 4)
Have a super fantastic awesome splendid amazing day! -TheQxxn
Cassandra Goth is the only one I've played with in 1, 2 and 4 (I never played 3). In every save in Sims4, if I don't play her I have one of my spares marry her.
Also a lot of people have given her some very beautiful makeovers and posted them to this board. She is one sim I love in any version I see of her.
I also really love Nina Caliente. I haven't played her much in Sims 4 yet, but she was definitely a favorite in Sims 2.
@Daephene I get the feeling that Nina isn’t really a player like most people think. She seems more innocent than Dina and is simply misguided and trying to be like her sister. Do you feel that way? Cassandra is a favorite of mine as well!
@Simtown15 I don't know if I'd call her innocent, but I definitely think of her as nicer than Dina. In my Sims2 game Dina was the gold digger and Don was just a fling on her way to someone wealthier. Nina was into enjoying life with like-minded people rather than using them. She ended up raising Don's baby as a single mother, while running a hair salon out of her house and looking for love (Don went ahead with his marriage in that game).
I don't like the way the two of them look so different in Sims 4 so I haven't played them at all yet.
None? I never played with any of the townies lol. I’ve only played with my sims in every iteration of the game. If I had to pick though, I would go with the Goths. Just based on the history of the family and all.
If any of you have played The Sims: Bustin' Out, you'll probably remember Mimi as she was who I usually chose to live with after moving out from Mom's. Bella Goth is another and Malcolm Landgraab.
Comments
I absolutelly love her and she's the one i remember so well since 1!
But I can respect Bella Goth because she's iconic.
S3 : Bill Caspian, Monica Malau, Joseph Doe
S4 : Makoa Kealoha, Cassandra Goth
TS1 - Bella Goth
TS2 - Cassandra Goth & Lilith Pleasant (the latter after SIMPE repairs to the hosing EA gave her)
TS3 - didn't get into it
TS4 - Summer Holiday & Cassandra Goth (the latter after YA-ing & de-gloomifying)
TS3 - The Landgraabs, Pin Yin, Aubrey Oviedo
TS4 - Morgan Fyres, the vampires, Morgyn Ember
I like to build stuff
Gunther Goth(TS3)
Bella Goth(TS2)
Conelia Goth(TS3)
Mortimer Goth(TS2&3)
Alexander Goth(TS2&4)
Cassandra Goth(Ts2&4)
Lolita Goth(TS3)
Thornton Wolff(TS3)
Morgana Wolff(TS3)
Liberty Lee(TS4)
Morgyn Ember(TS4)
Caleb Vatore(TS4)
Max Vilareal(TS4)
Malcolm Landgraab(TS2,3,& 4)
TS4: Caleb Vatore, Vlad Straud, Paolo Rocca (once I take him out of Partihaus) , Diego Lobo, Most of the Sims in Sulani, the 3 Sages
Mara the Faerie Queen
Bonehilda
Vicki Vampiress
🐸🐸🐸🐸 Fortuneteller
Also a lot of people have given her some very beautiful makeovers and posted them to this board. She is one sim I love in any version I see of her.
I also really love Nina Caliente. I haven't played her much in Sims 4 yet, but she was definitely a favorite in Sims 2.
Vlad and Agnes Crumplebottom if I had to pick a top.
I don't like the way the two of them look so different in Sims 4 so I haven't played them at all yet.
https://youtu.be/X2eiCUQDNvQ
Looking for some custom animations? Check out my youtube channel: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCKrWaxowK2vCzwkz6bEZRbg
Deviantart profile: https://gamingtweety.deviantart.com/
Eddy Mullis
Zumi and the Winchester Brothers
The Watcher's Caretaker - A Limited ISBI
and I created her for a challenge, Ann is her for the first outfit as she dressed as her for Halloween she got a Maxis fave! as the original Crumplebottom loved knitting (carried in her bag) I hope to use her with the new pack when it comes out
Gallery Link: https://www.ea.com/games/the-sims/the-sims-4/pc/gallery/88C2EDA6F3FD11E987B47A1175479295?category=all&searchtype=ea_origin_id&sortby=newest&time=all&searchquery=luckyheather&max=50&maxis=false
As Mrs Crumplebottom
Screenshots of all outfits in Forum Post here https://forums.thesims.com/en_US/discussion/comment/17284249/#Comment_17284249
My Gallery https://www.ea.com/en-gb/games/the-sims/the-sims-4/pc/gallery/browse?category=all&searchtype=ea_origin_id&sortby=newest&time=all&searchquery=luckyheather&max=50&maxis=true