also can we talk about how table in cozy stuff has
EMPTY SHELVES YOU COULD PUT THINGS ON YES CUSTOMIZATION
(please do that with shelves no matter what style wins)
Honestly, I’m not too thrilled with any of them, but 2 or 3 are probably closer to what I’d pick. I like the industrial-style feel of 2, but 3 feels like it has more like an arts and crafts theme. Can’t wait for the next poll to open next week!
can't we just do this instead? and add swatches for different aesthetics?
like some grandmaish shades some earthy shades and some ikeaish shades
(sorry the paint quality and messes tho im too noob for this)
can't we just do this instead? and add swatches for different aesthetics?
like some grandmaish shades some earthy shades and some ikeaish shades
(sorry the paint quality and messes tho im too noob for this)
You for president. Although sadly I don't think the Gurus will do that Remember though, this vote is to pick which STYLE the pack is going to focus on, not the objects included.
Granny Chic is my top pick for a couple of reasons. It feels like it has the most character, and I would probably get the most use out of build/buy items in that style.
I like some elements of the cozy one, but it's almost too plain; I don't feel strongly about it either way. Some items in the DIY one are okay, but I'm not interested in the bright/pastel/cutesy vibe it's going for.
The cuckoo clock is by far my favourite object of all of them. I actually remember my grandma’s cuckoo clock with the pine cone weights and my grandma knitting.
But the room I like the best is the brown one
Yes!!! If they end up doing a knitting focused pack and don't include a rocking chair i think people are going to go off!
can't we just do this instead? and add swatches for different aesthetics?
like some grandmaish shades some earthy shades and some ikeaish shades
(sorry the paint quality and messes tho im too noob for this)
i like how you shoved the rooster into there, he's gotta make it through no matter what artstyle wins.
can't we just do this instead? and add swatches for different aesthetics?
like some grandmaish shades some earthy shades and some ikeaish shades
(sorry the paint quality and messes tho im too noob for this)
i like how you shoved the rooster into there, he's gotta make it through no matter what artstyle wins.
yes. #roostersquad
and also it was perfect object to show i want to put whatever I want there
not just some presets that limit usage of objects
(well, unless its rooster I can forgive cause like that doesn't go too into direction of craftroom
or laundry or kitchen or whatever and I'd still get lots of use out of that wholesome object)
+ I know they are asking about style not objects but still I feel like it's a petty question when we could just do mix and match and be happy
I never really saw knitting as a studio craft, it's more something to do in a warm cozy room & comfy chair.
I think this is the reason why I'm liking Granny Chic and DIY Delight more than Cozy Craft Workshop. They both look like they're rooms in someone's home. Both give me that cozy and homey aesthetic which is what I really want for this pack. The homemade decor, spread around both rooms really add to that feeling.
Cozy Craft Workshop, despite having cozy in the name, doesn't feel cozy at all to me. It feels like just a workshop, which is the opposite of the vibes I was looking for in a pack like this. The room just feels kind of dull, unlike the cute and quirky appeal of the other two.
While I instinctively was drawn to the industrial, unisex room first, I also like the Granny Chic for its antiquey look. Really don't like the pink one, it's very modern and young and doesn't look as much like a knitting craft room to me. I also think that, since this pack is going to revolve around knitting and not sewing, (which I feel would be better represented with the third style because that big center table looks like a sewing table for laying large pieces of cloth down), I'd like to see it go in the direction of catering more towards Elders. I've been wanting an Elders Stuff Pack for a while and this could fill in some of the gaps for that neglected life stage.
Plus, I love the cuckoo clock and the tea set and the hanging plants.
So:
#1 Looks like the best representation of knitting to me, also good for Elders, could lead to expanding some more objects and CAS for Elders as well. I'll probably vote for this one.
#2 While I like it, looks more like a workshop for rugged crafts or pottery or glass. Doesn't say "knitting" to me.
#3 Looks a lot like a sewing room. There's a big difference between sewing and knitting, and while I'd have liked to have sewing as a choice, it wasn't listed as a craft. But maybe if this is chosen, they'll add sewing as well.
My daughter and I were discussing this today ( my sims 4 is on PC and hers is on the console, can’t wait till we can share lots on the gallery) We admit we like different aspects of each pack, but decided that the granny pack is our favorite. We just hope they include some natural wood tables bookshelves etc. AND I hope they have swatches with doilies And swatches without doilies.... there are just a few too many in that granny room at one time.... even my grandmother didn't Have that many on the furniture.... lol. Some of the reason we picked granny room over the upper right room were because of the objects. We loved the little foot stool with the teapot, the cuckoo clock, the knitting basket with the knitting needles up on the shelf ( we are hoping that’s a clutter item), the umbrella stand ( hoping it is functional like the one we have now.), the embroidery and Afghan on the wall, the hanging planter on the right, the cute table lamp, knitting stand, basket of knitted things and the shelf with the squirrel and knitted bunny, and the rug with that clutter yarn on it, the cozy chair, and the the talk craft shelf ( hope it comes with swatches with the drawer closed as well, and in a natural wood color.). And the cute chair with a pillow. It will be hard to choose the objects.
In the pink room to the right we love the square craft desk with chair, wooden basket of yarn, and the wooden skeins of yarn, along with some of the wall posters.
Please remember that you will be voting for the overall SYLE of the pack next. The object vote will be held at another date and may include objects that are or not in these concept art rooms. Don't choose a room based on the objects, choose it based off of the style of furniture and clothing, that you like the most
It's a tough call, but the more I look at them the more I am drawn to the one in the middle on the bottom row that looks more like a workshop. I like the mature, somber, utilitarian, and more gender-neutral feel of it. It looks more like the type of space I would prefer for myself when working on creative projects, and it fits better with a lot of my existing sims, who are mostly male.
I think it's very hard to mentally separate "style" from "items". That's why I had to look at them for a while. I really like some of the individual items in the other styles (such as the hanging plants and the shelves with diagonal spaces in the "Granny" style). I also think we need some less-modern styles just in general for less-modern houses and families, so I was initially drawn to the "Granny" style just for that reason.
But the workshop concept just speaks to me, as the feel of a place both I and most of my favorite sims would want to spend time in, and I think that's the one I'd choose.
Granny Chic for me probably. I like the Cozy Craft one well enough, but it looks like stuff we've already seen in other packs. I would be disappointed to see DYI Delight win, it's too dark and dreary for me. Plus I hate the industrial design style.
Comments
To answer OP's question, I dislike all these styles.
EMPTY SHELVES YOU COULD PUT THINGS ON YES CUSTOMIZATION
(please do that with shelves no matter what style wins)
There will most likely be plain swatches versions as well in Granny Chic
can't we just do this instead? and add swatches for different aesthetics?
like some grandmaish shades some earthy shades and some ikeaish shades
(sorry the paint quality and messes tho im too noob for this)
You for president. Although sadly I don't think the Gurus will do that
I like some elements of the cozy one, but it's almost too plain; I don't feel strongly about it either way. Some items in the DIY one are okay, but I'm not interested in the bright/pastel/cutesy vibe it's going for.
Yes!!! If they end up doing a knitting focused pack and don't include a rocking chair i think people are going to go off!
i like how you shoved the rooster into there, he's gotta make it through no matter what artstyle wins.
yes. #roostersquad
and also it was perfect object to show i want to put whatever I want there
not just some presets that limit usage of objects
(well, unless its rooster I can forgive cause like that doesn't go too into direction of craftroom
or laundry or kitchen or whatever and I'd still get lots of use out of that wholesome object)
+ I know they are asking about style not objects but still I feel like it's a petty question when we could just do mix and match and be happy
I think this is the reason why I'm liking Granny Chic and DIY Delight more than Cozy Craft Workshop. They both look like they're rooms in someone's home. Both give me that cozy and homey aesthetic which is what I really want for this pack. The homemade decor, spread around both rooms really add to that feeling.
Cozy Craft Workshop, despite having cozy in the name, doesn't feel cozy at all to me. It feels like just a workshop, which is the opposite of the vibes I was looking for in a pack like this. The room just feels kind of dull, unlike the cute and quirky appeal of the other two.
Plus, I love the cuckoo clock and the tea set and the hanging plants.
So:
#1 Looks like the best representation of knitting to me, also good for Elders, could lead to expanding some more objects and CAS for Elders as well. I'll probably vote for this one.
#2 While I like it, looks more like a workshop for rugged crafts or pottery or glass. Doesn't say "knitting" to me.
#3 Looks a lot like a sewing room. There's a big difference between sewing and knitting, and while I'd have liked to have sewing as a choice, it wasn't listed as a craft. But maybe if this is chosen, they'll add sewing as well.
In the pink room to the right we love the square craft desk with chair, wooden basket of yarn, and the wooden skeins of yarn, along with some of the wall posters.
For example:
this is just voting on general artstyle.
they're doing this the way they typically run their pack-making process, we're just being included in the final decision.
Please remember that you will be voting for the overall SYLE of the pack next. The object vote will be held at another date and may include objects that are or not in these concept art rooms. Don't choose a room based on the objects, choose it based off of the style of furniture and clothing, that you like the most
I think it's very hard to mentally separate "style" from "items". That's why I had to look at them for a while. I really like some of the individual items in the other styles (such as the hanging plants and the shelves with diagonal spaces in the "Granny" style). I also think we need some less-modern styles just in general for less-modern houses and families, so I was initially drawn to the "Granny" style just for that reason.
But the workshop concept just speaks to me, as the feel of a place both I and most of my favorite sims would want to spend time in, and I think that's the one I'd choose.
Origin ID: mintycupcake