And just a reminder, let's try to be kind to each other. I know it's a game, but words such as "scum" hit other players hard sometimes.
In honor of Ra's birthday yesterday, let's use "minion" or something less antagonistic. I know Ra never liked the word "scum" either .
I like "minion" much better than "scum" they're cute and misunderstood, it doesn't sound like an insult. You are amazing Lala! I'm enjoying the game so far
...*fades back into the shadows to continue to lurk*
While Aitkens was nuzzled up on his couch, too scared to venture outside for fear the mafia would get him, he whispered sweet nothings into his phone. Only one of his whispers reached the wrong ears!!!
DEAD: Aitkens, Vanilla Townie.
It is now day.
Check out my cooking Youtube channel: Living with Leigh
While Aitkens was nuzzled up on his couch, too scared to venture outside for fear the mafia would get him, he whispered sweet nothings into his phone. Only one of his whispers reached the wrong ears!!!
DEAD: Aitkens, Vanilla Townie.
It is now day.
Wow, Aitkens death speaks volumes to me.
Btw, Lala, I totally get that death message
I feel like since I was the only one to vote Aitkens, this was a frame job. I honestly thought either Hello or I would die tonight.
Something about Thethe isn't sitting right with me, these are odd deaths for our regular mafia games. I am more inclined to think one of the newer players are mafia since the deaths aren't really making sense.
Day starts are like "We live in a happy town, everything is fine but we'd rather lynch someone just in case!"
- Caro the Magnificent
Well.
That's an interesting choice of kill. He wasn't helping town by being absent; he's the only person in this game who hasn't posted once yet.
Certainly not what I expected.
Renee, I agree. These are weird kills. Some of the newer players as part of the mafia makes sense to me as well.
Here is what I am thinking.
1. Emily - Sounds normal, though I dunno how she sounds when bad. Have a slightly off gut feeling about her but don't really think she'd kill Joel.
2. Renee - Seemed suspicious at first. But really sounds genuine and wouldn't kill Joel. Town.
5. Skelda - First to bring up Loppie, who was maf. She was his main/only suspicion. Would he call out and lead a lynch on a mafia buddy no one else had pointed out as suspicious? Possible, but doesn't seem likely at this point. Strongly leaning town.
6. Shannen - Seems okay. Sounds like Shannen + newbie-townie.
7. Lissa - Town.
8. CM - Can never read her well, have a really off feeling about her this time though. Hard to say.
9. Hello - Seems townish with her elaborate theories.
10. Aitkens - Dead.
11. Mat - Newbie. She should say more.
12. TehTeh - Newbie. She should say more.
Likely town:
Skelda
Renee
Shannen
Hello
Nullish/suspicious:
CM
Mat
TehTeh
Em? (idk)
I am thinking Mat or/and TehTeh is/are mafia. I'm thinking both remaining mafia are in my nullish/suspicious list - to be more specific, I think they are in CM/Mat/TehTeh. And if both are not in there perhaps one is Em or I am wrong about one of my townreads.
1. Emilzydiva - I am pretty sure Emsy is town. She is less coherent as mafia.
2. Sheldonly - Town
3. SummerFalls - Dead :evil:
4. Loppie - Mafia - Lynched
5. Skelda - Town. Mafia Skelda is pretty obvious. This is the town Skelda that I know and love, or he has gotten better at being mafia.
6. Shannen - I can't tell, I don't know her well. I believe she is likely to be town, but I will watch her.
7. Marvelissa - I am more inclined to think she is town, but I am not 100% sure.
8. cmbaker - I am in the same boat with Lissa, I always find CM a bit Sketchy, even when she is town. She is Katie 2.0.
9. Hello - I am pretty sure she is town. If she were mafia I would have died or have been lynched.
10. Aitkens - Dead :evil:
11. MatMoate - Pretty quiet.
12. TehTeh - This is my most suspect at the moment. After last night and still coming after me for no apparent reason really threw me off. It's so obvious that I am town. Mafia Renée doesn't protest as much, as I hate being mafia and would rather die than lie. BUT TehTeh doesn't know me so it could just be that.
Not sure:
Shannen
Lissa
Mat
TehTeh
CM
The rest are town.
Day starts are like "We live in a happy town, everything is fine but we'd rather lynch someone just in case!"
- Caro the Magnificent
Here is what I am thinking.
1. Emily - Sounds normal, though I dunno how she sounds when bad. Have a slightly off gut feeling about her but don't really think she'd kill Joel.
2. Renee - Seemed suspicious at first. But really sounds genuine and wouldn't kill Joel. Town.
5. Skelda - First to bring up Loppie, who was maf. She was his main/only suspicion. Would he call out and lead a lynch on a mafia buddy no one else had pointed out as suspicious? Possible, but doesn't seem likely at this point. Strongly leaning town.
6. Shannen - Seems okay. Sounds like Shannen + newbie-townie.
7. Lissa - Town.
8. CM - Can never read her well, have a really off feeling about her this time though. Hard to say.
9. Hello - Seems townish with her elaborate theories.
10. Aitkens - Dead.
11. Mat - Newbie. She should say more.
12. TehTeh - Newbie. She should say more.
Likely town:
Skelda
Renee
Shannen
Hello
Nullish/suspicious:
CM
Mat
TehTeh
Em? (idk)
I am thinking Mat or/and TehTeh is/are mafia. I'm thinking both remaining mafia are in my nullish/suspicious list - to be more specific, I think they are in CM/Mat/TehTeh. And if both are not in there perhaps one is Em or I am wrong about one of my townreads.
I'm also leaning towards Mat/CM/TehTeh. I would be okay with a lynch on any of them.
Day starts are like "We live in a happy town, everything is fine but we'd rather lynch someone just in case!"
- Caro the Magnificent
Yeah, I am almost sure the remaining mafia are two of those three. And I'd be okay with a lynch on any of them, as well. If the one we lynch is town, whoops, but then we've probably found our two mafia.
Yeah, I am almost sure the remaining mafia are two of those three. And I'd be okay with a lynch on any of them, as well. If the one we lynch is town, whoops, but then we've probably found our two mafia.
Well, we haven't ML yet so if we ML we are not in a horrible position, but we need to give people a time to claim.
Vote: TehTeh
Day starts are like "We live in a happy town, everything is fine but we'd rather lynch someone just in case!"
- Caro the Magnificent
Yeah, I agree about giving people time to claim.
I just meant that if we do end up MLing, we'll probably still be in a decent position. But not MLing would be even better.
Geeeeeeeezzzz It took a while to get finally logged in.
Right, well, down to business.
I agree, the kills are slightly weird. Joel not so much as it's a night one, nobody has posted yet for game chat and it's basically pure randomness. I mean, it surely wasn't anyone who knew Joel hosted last game and wanted to play because that would be mean to know he was looking forward to playing and not give him a chance to play and we aren't mean in that way are we? I would hope not. So that narrowed down suspects.
Although aitkens, he's not posted once. Wouldn't mafia want to keep him around for this reason? If i was mafia i would have kept him around as long as possible because if he continued to be quiet on the thread he would be an easy lynch later on to get me one step closer to winning. So this makes me think it's someone new too, or two newer players who aren't experienced with mafia games.
So with that being said i'm knocking Hello and Lissa off my suspect list and moving Shannen, Teh and Mat there.
Most likely good:
Renee
Maybe good:
Cm – Assuming her claim is true... Just to get somewhere.
Lissa
No idea:
Skelda
Hello
Unsure about:
Shannon
Teh
Mat
Maybe bad:
Most likely bad:
Dead:
Joel: Vanilla Townie – Night Killed N1
Loppie: Mafia – Lynched D1
Aitkens: Vanilla Townie – Night Killed N2
I've not got them as "maybe bad/most likely bad" because i rarely ever have anyone there ever.
If i'm honest i got to say my thoughts have changed on Hello and Lissa, i don't know why but i was reading back and i think they are town. I would think they would put more thought into the kill and kill someone else, not aitkens. Aitkens aint helping town so he can help mafia. So it certainly narrows down
If not, then we are completely wrong on our thoughts.
I would vote for Teh and bandwagon but i'll wait around and see what he has to say. If he is a he and not a she
I agree, the kills are slightly weird. Joel not so much as it's a night one, nobody has posted yet for game chat and it's basically pure randomness. I mean, it surely wasn't anyone who knew Joel hosted last game and wanted to play because that would be mean to know he was looking forward to playing and not give him a chance to play and we aren't mean in that way are we? I would hope not. So that narrowed down suspects.
Although aitkens, he's not posted once. Wouldn't mafia want to keep him around for this reason? If i was mafia i would have kept him around as long as possible because if he continued to be quiet on the thread he would be an easy lynch later on to get me one step closer to winning. So this makes me think it's someone new too, or two newer players who aren't experienced with mafia games.
That's pretty much what I was thinking about Joel's N1 death. Saying it was probably newbies was partly hope because I really hoped someone who knew how much he was looking forward to playing wouldn't do that; as you said and I've said that'd be mean.
And Aitkens, yeah I thought that was strategically a really odd kill. He'd be such an easy lynch, and he's hardly around to help town in the meantime; he's no threat to the mafia. And newbies wouldn't know that.
And I've been assuming she for TehTeh based on her avatar.
TehTeh, tell us if we're wrong, sorry XD
see...seee...see! even when I say I'm good ya'll still think I'm bad
Aitkens is an odd kill...so I agree that there's at least 2 newbies with the mafia or perhaps all the newbs are a mafia team cause I don't think an experienced player would kill off aitkens as alot of you have said he would have been helpful to mafia if he stuck around.
since Loppie was lynched my guess is that the last 2 remaining mafia are newbs, so Shannen, mat or Tehteh, 2 of the three might be mafia.
see...seee...see! even when I say I'm good ya'll still think I'm bad
Aitkens is an odd kill...so I agree that there's at least 2 newbies with the mafia or perhaps all the newbs are a mafia team cause I don't think an experienced player would kill off aitkens as alot of you have said he would have been helpful to mafia if he stuck around.
since Loppie was lynched my guess is that the last 2 remaining mafia are newbs, so Shannen, mat or Tehteh, 2 of the three might be mafia.
Well, just saying you're good doesn't always mean you're good. Everyone is going to say they're good whether they are or not.
I am not really suspicious of Shannen at the moment. But if we don't find all the mafia in you/TehTeh/Mat, it seems like she'd be a good choice to look at.
Ok, lets try and think logically. What do mafia have to achieve by killing an inactive?
Part of me feels like its a newbie move but then again, could it be possible that the newbies are easy targets? Lets be honest, nobody trusts the newbies because they don't know the way they act in the game and the advance players are going to be more trusting to those they feel they can read like a book.
I'm not sure if lists are required but I feel like, it will help with my mind.
cm- I am really unsure about you. I was certain that you was mafia but I honestly don't know how to read you in this game because you are always the same in every game, I've lurked in.
Emily- I feel is town. From what I've seen in the past, you are giving me a different vibe.
Renee - I feel is town - At first I wondered but something doesn't fit right with you being Mafia.
Hello- I really did have strong vibes that you was mafia, although Skelda kinda squashed that. I kinda still think you are mafia though.
Skelda- Your jumping to one person to the next had me worried and you did try to rally up people to votes and I've only seen actual mafia members try and pull a stunt like that. However what makes me now believe you are town..is that your chosen vote helped get rid of a mafia member.
Lissa- You are leaning more town.
Teh- Newbie - Need to say more
Mat- Newbie - Need to say more
As to who to vote for..I have no idea at the moment.
Shannen, a fair part of the reason I'm looking at the newbies is because I have town reads on most of the regulars, partly for other reasons. The odd kills just add to it. Sure, they could be attempts to frame the newbies, but the evidence I see points to no.
Though you could be right about the newbies being easy targets.
Really, it's not just that I'm suspicious of the newbies but also partly that I'm not suspicious of the others. To some extent it's process of elimination. And right now I guess I'm more suspicious of those I can't read well - which is Mat, TehTeh and CM.
If the two mafia aren't among them, one is probably you or Em.
I'm not really suspicious of you. But I know I'm town, and I strongly believe Skelda, Renee and Hello are town. So if one of them is maf, I'm screwed, and nicely done to them
And lists are not required, but usually quite useful both for their maker and others.
And as for you being sick, I hope you feel better!
Comments
I like "minion" much better than "scum"
...*fades back into the shadows to continue to lurk*
Games Played: 59 | Wins: 31 | Losses: 27 | Draws: 1
Scum: 14 | Town: 40 | Third: 5
Scum Wins: 5 | Town Wins: 25 | Third Party Wins: 1
Alive: 18 | Nightkilled: 16 | Lynched: 18 | Endgamed: 3 | Other: 5
- Caro the Magnificent
An Introduction to Mafia
Mafia Stats
Games Played: 51 ||Games Won: 31
Mafia: 4 ||Third: 7 ||Town: 39 ||Alien: 1
NK: 19 ||Lynched: 7 ||Alive: 25
Games Played: 59 | Wins: 31 | Losses: 27 | Draws: 1
Scum: 14 | Town: 40 | Third: 5
Scum Wins: 5 | Town Wins: 25 | Third Party Wins: 1
Alive: 18 | Nightkilled: 16 | Lynched: 18 | Endgamed: 3 | Other: 5
Sims 4 Bachelorette Series
My YooToob Channul
My First Mafia Game (stuff)
DEAD: Aitkens, Vanilla Townie.
It is now day.
Wow, Aitkens death speaks volumes to me.
Btw, Lala, I totally get that death message
I feel like since I was the only one to vote Aitkens, this was a frame job. I honestly thought either Hello or I would die tonight.
Something about Thethe isn't sitting right with me, these are odd deaths for our regular mafia games. I am more inclined to think one of the newer players are mafia since the deaths aren't really making sense.
- Caro the Magnificent
An Introduction to Mafia
Mafia Stats
Games Played: 51 ||Games Won: 31
Mafia: 4 ||Third: 7 ||Town: 39 ||Alien: 1
NK: 19 ||Lynched: 7 ||Alive: 25
That's an interesting choice of kill. He wasn't helping town by being absent; he's the only person in this game who hasn't posted once yet.
Certainly not what I expected.
Renee, I agree. These are weird kills. Some of the newer players as part of the mafia makes sense to me as well.
Games Played: 59 | Wins: 31 | Losses: 27 | Draws: 1
Scum: 14 | Town: 40 | Third: 5
Scum Wins: 5 | Town Wins: 25 | Third Party Wins: 1
Alive: 18 | Nightkilled: 16 | Lynched: 18 | Endgamed: 3 | Other: 5
1. Emily - Sounds normal, though I dunno how she sounds when bad. Have a slightly off gut feeling about her but don't really think she'd kill Joel.
2. Renee - Seemed suspicious at first. But really sounds genuine and wouldn't kill Joel. Town.
5. Skelda - First to bring up Loppie, who was maf. She was his main/only suspicion. Would he call out and lead a lynch on a mafia buddy no one else had pointed out as suspicious? Possible, but doesn't seem likely at this point. Strongly leaning town.
6. Shannen - Seems okay. Sounds like Shannen + newbie-townie.
7. Lissa - Town.
8. CM - Can never read her well, have a really off feeling about her this time though. Hard to say.
9. Hello - Seems townish with her elaborate theories.
10. Aitkens - Dead.
11. Mat - Newbie. She should say more.
12. TehTeh - Newbie. She should say more.
Likely town:
Skelda
Renee
Shannen
Hello
Nullish/suspicious:
CM
Mat
TehTeh
Em? (idk)
I am thinking Mat or/and TehTeh is/are mafia. I'm thinking both remaining mafia are in my nullish/suspicious list - to be more specific, I think they are in CM/Mat/TehTeh. And if both are not in there perhaps one is Em or I am wrong about one of my townreads.
Games Played: 59 | Wins: 31 | Losses: 27 | Draws: 1
Scum: 14 | Town: 40 | Third: 5
Scum Wins: 5 | Town Wins: 25 | Third Party Wins: 1
Alive: 18 | Nightkilled: 16 | Lynched: 18 | Endgamed: 3 | Other: 5
1. Emilzydiva - I am pretty sure Emsy is town. She is less coherent as mafia.
2. Sheldonly - Town
3. SummerFalls - Dead :evil:
4. Loppie - Mafia - Lynched
5. Skelda - Town. Mafia Skelda is pretty obvious. This is the town Skelda that I know and love, or he has gotten better at being mafia.
6. Shannen - I can't tell, I don't know her well. I believe she is likely to be town, but I will watch her.
7. Marvelissa - I am more inclined to think she is town, but I am not 100% sure.
8. cmbaker - I am in the same boat with Lissa, I always find CM a bit Sketchy, even when she is town. She is Katie 2.0.
9. Hello - I am pretty sure she is town. If she were mafia I would have died or have been lynched.
10. Aitkens - Dead :evil:
11. MatMoate - Pretty quiet.
12. TehTeh - This is my most suspect at the moment. After last night and still coming after me for no apparent reason really threw me off. It's so obvious that I am town. Mafia Renée doesn't protest as much, as I hate being mafia and would rather die than lie. BUT TehTeh doesn't know me so it could just be that.
Not sure:
Shannen
Lissa
Mat
TehTeh
CM
The rest are town.
- Caro the Magnificent
An Introduction to Mafia
Mafia Stats
Games Played: 51 ||Games Won: 31
Mafia: 4 ||Third: 7 ||Town: 39 ||Alien: 1
NK: 19 ||Lynched: 7 ||Alive: 25
I'm also leaning towards Mat/CM/TehTeh. I would be okay with a lynch on any of them.
- Caro the Magnificent
An Introduction to Mafia
Mafia Stats
Games Played: 51 ||Games Won: 31
Mafia: 4 ||Third: 7 ||Town: 39 ||Alien: 1
NK: 19 ||Lynched: 7 ||Alive: 25
Games Played: 59 | Wins: 31 | Losses: 27 | Draws: 1
Scum: 14 | Town: 40 | Third: 5
Scum Wins: 5 | Town Wins: 25 | Third Party Wins: 1
Alive: 18 | Nightkilled: 16 | Lynched: 18 | Endgamed: 3 | Other: 5
Well, we haven't ML yet so if we ML we are not in a horrible position, but we need to give people a time to claim.
Vote: TehTeh
- Caro the Magnificent
An Introduction to Mafia
Mafia Stats
Games Played: 51 ||Games Won: 31
Mafia: 4 ||Third: 7 ||Town: 39 ||Alien: 1
NK: 19 ||Lynched: 7 ||Alive: 25
I just meant that if we do end up MLing, we'll probably still be in a decent position. But not MLing would be even better.
Vote: TehTeh
Games Played: 59 | Wins: 31 | Losses: 27 | Draws: 1
Scum: 14 | Town: 40 | Third: 5
Scum Wins: 5 | Town Wins: 25 | Third Party Wins: 1
Alive: 18 | Nightkilled: 16 | Lynched: 18 | Endgamed: 3 | Other: 5
Right, well, down to business.
I agree, the kills are slightly weird. Joel not so much as it's a night one, nobody has posted yet for game chat and it's basically pure randomness. I mean, it surely wasn't anyone who knew Joel hosted last game and wanted to play because that would be mean to know he was looking forward to playing and not give him a chance to play and we aren't mean in that way are we? I would hope not. So that narrowed down suspects.
Although aitkens, he's not posted once. Wouldn't mafia want to keep him around for this reason? If i was mafia i would have kept him around as long as possible because if he continued to be quiet on the thread he would be an easy lynch later on to get me one step closer to winning. So this makes me think it's someone new too, or two newer players who aren't experienced with mafia games.
So with that being said i'm knocking Hello and Lissa off my suspect list and moving Shannen, Teh and Mat there.
Most likely good:
Renee
Maybe good:
Cm – Assuming her claim is true... Just to get somewhere.
Lissa
No idea:
Skelda
Hello
Unsure about:
Shannon
Teh
Mat
Maybe bad:
Most likely bad:
Dead:
Joel: Vanilla Townie – Night Killed N1
Loppie: Mafia – Lynched D1
Aitkens: Vanilla Townie – Night Killed N2
I've not got them as "maybe bad/most likely bad" because i rarely ever have anyone there ever.
If i'm honest i got to say my thoughts have changed on Hello and Lissa, i don't know why but i was reading back and i think they are town. I would think they would put more thought into the kill and kill someone else, not aitkens. Aitkens aint helping town so he can help mafia. So it certainly narrows down
If not, then we are completely wrong on our thoughts.
I would vote for Teh and bandwagon but i'll wait around and see what he has to say. If he is a he and not a she
Sims 4 Bachelorette Series
My YooToob Channul
My First Mafia Game (stuff)
Sheldonly votes TehTeh
Lissa votes TehTeh
With 9 alive it takes 5 to lynch
TehTeh leads with 2 votes
And Aitkens, yeah I thought that was strategically a really odd kill. He'd be such an easy lynch, and he's hardly around to help town in the meantime; he's no threat to the mafia. And newbies wouldn't know that.
And I've been assuming she for TehTeh based on her avatar.
TehTeh, tell us if we're wrong, sorry XD
Games Played: 59 | Wins: 31 | Losses: 27 | Draws: 1
Scum: 14 | Town: 40 | Third: 5
Scum Wins: 5 | Town Wins: 25 | Third Party Wins: 1
Alive: 18 | Nightkilled: 16 | Lynched: 18 | Endgamed: 3 | Other: 5
Aitkens is an odd kill...so I agree that there's at least 2 newbies with the mafia or perhaps all the newbs are a mafia team cause I don't think an experienced player would kill off aitkens as alot of you have said he would have been helpful to mafia if he stuck around.
since Loppie was lynched my guess is that the last 2 remaining mafia are newbs, so Shannen, mat or Tehteh, 2 of the three might be mafia.
I am not really suspicious of Shannen at the moment. But if we don't find all the mafia in you/TehTeh/Mat, it seems like she'd be a good choice to look at.
Games Played: 59 | Wins: 31 | Losses: 27 | Draws: 1
Scum: 14 | Town: 40 | Third: 5
Scum Wins: 5 | Town Wins: 25 | Third Party Wins: 1
Alive: 18 | Nightkilled: 16 | Lynched: 18 | Endgamed: 3 | Other: 5
Part of me feels like its a newbie move but then again, could it be possible that the newbies are easy targets? Lets be honest, nobody trusts the newbies because they don't know the way they act in the game and the advance players are going to be more trusting to those they feel they can read like a book.
I'm not sure if lists are required but I feel like, it will help with my mind.
cm- I am really unsure about you. I was certain that you was mafia but I honestly don't know how to read you in this game because you are always the same in every game, I've lurked in.
Emily- I feel is town. From what I've seen in the past, you are giving me a different vibe.
Renee - I feel is town - At first I wondered but something doesn't fit right with you being Mafia.
Hello- I really did have strong vibes that you was mafia, although Skelda kinda squashed that. I kinda still think you are mafia though.
Skelda- Your jumping to one person to the next had me worried and you did try to rally up people to votes and I've only seen actual mafia members try and pull a stunt like that. However what makes me now believe you are town..is that your chosen vote helped get rid of a mafia member.
Lissa- You are leaning more town.
Teh- Newbie - Need to say more
Mat- Newbie - Need to say more
As to who to vote for..I have no idea at the moment.
<Sorry for any typo's, I'm sick at the moment. >
Though you could be right about the newbies being easy targets.
Really, it's not just that I'm suspicious of the newbies but also partly that I'm not suspicious of the others. To some extent it's process of elimination. And right now I guess I'm more suspicious of those I can't read well - which is Mat, TehTeh and CM.
If the two mafia aren't among them, one is probably you or Em.
I'm not really suspicious of you. But I know I'm town, and I strongly believe Skelda, Renee and Hello are town. So if one of them is maf, I'm screwed, and nicely done to them
And lists are not required, but usually quite useful both for their maker and others.
And as for you being sick, I hope you feel better!
Games Played: 59 | Wins: 31 | Losses: 27 | Draws: 1
Scum: 14 | Town: 40 | Third: 5
Scum Wins: 5 | Town Wins: 25 | Third Party Wins: 1
Alive: 18 | Nightkilled: 16 | Lynched: 18 | Endgamed: 3 | Other: 5