May 22 - Let's walk around the forums together, this week's Friday Highlight is here!
May 21, 11AM PT - Save the time for Eco Lifestyle livestream! Details here.
May 21 - Take a look at SimGuruConor's latest deep dive into Nifty Knitting: learn more about Plopsy!

Something I didn't like

They had a special post a few days ago about how they design objects. They used the craft hutch desk as an example. I voted for it because I loved the way it looked and thought that was what we were getting since it won. During the post though, I found out they changed it. One change they made that upset me was taking away the round bin containing sewing needles and replacing it with another yarn spool. There comes a point where some changes can be what would've caused you to vote for a different design. If it's a pack voted on, then they shouldn't put anything in the vote that they aren't willing to make just as it's pictured. As far as I am concerned, the desk doesn't look as good without the needle bin, which is part of it's appeal in the first place.

Comments

  • LiELFLiELF Posts: 3,704 Member
    davina1221 wrote: »
    They had a special post a few days ago about how they design objects. They used the craft hutch desk as an example. I voted for it because I loved the way it looked and thought that was what we were getting since it won. During the post though, I found out they changed it. One change they made that upset me was taking away the round bin containing sewing needles and replacing it with another yarn spool. There comes a point where some changes can be what would've caused you to vote for a different design. If it's a pack voted on, then they shouldn't put anything in the vote that they aren't willing to make just as it's pictured. As far as I am concerned, the desk doesn't look as good without the needle bin, which is part of it's appeal in the first place.

    This probably won't make you feel better, but I believe that they did tell us that what we voted on was only concept art. The final product is always subject to change in actual development. The concept art was to give us a general idea of what those items would look like, not a definitive design.
  • davina1221davina1221 Posts: 3,247 Member
    I understand that to some extent. I don't care about small changes like reducing 5 balls to 4 ect., but taking the only needles there off seemed to change the look for me. I voted for it because of the craft look which was caused by the needle bin and all the other craft looking things. They talked about saving the resources, but I thought I read that they might add another hobby at one time or had room to add more, so if that is true, why not leave many of the items as close to what people voted for as possible. I'm hoping they add more stuff we didn't get like
    1. granny smock
    2. cloud outfit for toddler
    3. kitty plush

    Those are the ones that I love the most that we aren't getting.

    Since we are getting knitting( Didn't want it; I vote dangerous stuff and then the granny vote), I would like to have some small bins to put around or ways to make it look crafty the way I want to.
  • ListentoToppDoggListentoToppDogg Posts: 2,064 Member
    I don't think I saw a change with a desk, but they made a whole blog about another object they changed. It looked like a bookshelf covered with knitting supplies, but they decided to swap out yarn balls for generic paper. I was absolutely disgusted when I saw that. I voted for the initial design with the yarn because it looked like it belonged in a knitting pack. If they had the random paper on it from the start, I would have never voted for it. By changing it, the team is not giving voters what we voted for and expected to be in the pack. And of course they only told us all this after the object has been modeled. I think it's extremely unfair and misleading.
  • OldeseadoggeOldeseadogge Posts: 2,635 Member
    Fully agree. Feels like the old bait and switch ploy. Not at all appreciated.
  • cheescaekscheescaeks Posts: 706 Member
    that's the design process. concept art doesn't have to consider polygons and performance, the actual objects do.

    welcome to game design.
Sign In or Register to comment.
Return to top