@LilacErin I could be but I'm drawing a lot of attention to me right now. If I was mafia I wouldn't do that. I still think I talk too much
Oh you mean this? Scum could say this too though. The specific communication, the "I'm probably sounding scum right now" the emoticon... I'm fairly certain this isn't Joy's first game either.
At the moment I'm leaning towards voting for Skelda, mostly because he (or she?) has a list of good people already and none of the people I have a good feeling about (nor myself) are part of it. He also says that he thinks that there's mostly new people on his team but I think at least Katie and Rosey have some experience. It doesn't make sense as it contradicts with his previous statement. That list also makes me suspicious of Rosey and Sjappie, Katie... I don't know why she's even on there, she hasn't done anything that would make me feel either way about her.
Currently I tend towards AngieSmith and LilacErin being townies. I thought LilacErin was pretending to have a clue but I think she was just confused. AngieSmith participates in the thread just as much as I do. Logically that makes me suspicious of scillakees because LilacErin did say this:
Anyway, I think it's someone who hasn't commented yet. They might be talking to the other mafia.
In my interpretation that was her clue / inkling.
Whut.. that's odd reasoning. I take it you didn't know there's a couple of people who know each other already. Otherwise this statement is just not okay. Also to inform you, first time I plaid I suspected Skelda as well, he has this air around him lol!
I do halfish agree with Skelda, but I'm not sure of Rosey yet. Being as defending as she is now is Roseylike, but she hasn't been around much. But as I said before, it could be because she just isn't as much on the forum anymore as she used to be
I don't suspect you though, you're too townish. Which could be a great strategy but for now I believe you.
@LilacErin I could be but I'm drawing a lot of attention to me right now. If I was mafia I wouldn't do that. I still think I talk too much
Oh you mean this? Scum could say this too though. The specific communication, the "I'm probably sounding scum right now" the emoticon... I'm fairly certain this isn't Joy's first game either.
I know scum could say that and scum regularly do. "If I were Mafia" is actually a fairly popular rhetorical technique. I dunno though, it isn't screaming scum to me.
@LilacErin I could be but I'm drawing a lot of attention to me right now. If I was mafia I wouldn't do that. I still think I talk too much
Oh you mean this? Scum could say this too though. The specific communication, the "I'm probably sounding scum right now" the emoticon... I'm fairly certain this isn't Joy's first game either.
I know scum could say that and scum regularly do. "If I were Mafia" is actually a fairly popular rhetorical technique. I dunno though, it isn't screaming scum to me.
Whoa...I'm so sorry if I upset someone. I just felt Skelda was a bit suspicious from the 'our team' bit. I also just realised mafia would try and post to seem less suspicious, so @Skelda is right.
I thinking going to do a bit more observing before I open my mouth again.
As I said, the posts crossed each other. No matter though, Lilac has the same opinion as me so that makes her look even more like a townsperson since I know I'm good. And I think if I was mafia I wouldn't try something that obvious. I suspect I won't survive the first night anyway but when I'm dead at least the townsfolk has a pretty good idea who to lynch next.
You have to watch the people with the same opinion the closest. Mafia loves to follow a townie as to make the other look suspicious... you have to have an 'innocent friend' so to speak.
Yeah but that would not have been smart. If I were to do something like that, I wouldn't post directly after her. I'd post sometime later. I'm suspecting Rosey right now, who started posting a lot more once I accused you.
I'm not saying you're scumbuddies. You're saying that. I'm just agreeing with you.
@LilacErin I could be but I'm drawing a lot of attention to me right now. If I was mafia I wouldn't do that. I still think I talk too much
Oh you mean this? Scum could say this too though. The specific communication, the "I'm probably sounding scum right now" the emoticon... I'm fairly certain this isn't Joy's first game either.
I know scum could say that and scum regularly do. "If I were Mafia" is actually a fairly popular rhetorical technique. I dunno though, it isn't screaming scum to me.
Agree to disagree?
I'll think about it. I'm not sure who else to vote for.
Yeah but that would not have been smart. If I were to do something like that, I wouldn't post directly after her. I'd post sometime later. I'm suspecting Rosey right now, who started posting a lot more once I accused you.
Duuudee (female dude probably), stop blaming Rosey. Only Rosey suspects you, why trying to defend so hard. A few people have mentioned this is how Rosey plays. We don't nearly have enough info to go on yet.
This thread is too fast for me. Rosey you're absolutely right. This isn't my first game, it's my... I think it's my third or fourth. I'm not a new player, I'm only new to playing it in this forum and in english. I do tend to take very long to write my posts. This one for example was started as soon as I wrote the last one. In between now and then I'm pretty sure a couple of posts have been made already.
And then there's Sjappie joining the discussion. Right now all the people that are telling me that I'm wrong are people from the list. I wonder why that is? You could even say it's a bandwagon... Ironic, right?
It isn't a bandwagon because we don't all agree that you are suspicious.
This thread is too fast for me. Rosey you're absolutely right. This isn't my first game, it's my... I think it's my third or fourth. I'm not a new player, I'm only new to playing it in this forum and in english. I do tend to take very long to write my posts. This one for example was started as soon as I wrote the last one. In between now and then I'm pretty sure a couple of posts have been made already.
And then there's Sjappie joining the discussion. Right now all the people that are telling me that I'm wrong are people from the list. I wonder why that is? You could even say it's a bandwagon... Ironic, right?
I was only giving advices and little bit of opinion :') if that's what makes you suspect others, woah
SjappielovePaul why are you trying to defend Rosey so much right now? And I gave my thoughts and out comes everyone who I suspected to tell me how wrong I am and that I'm misjudging you as players. My gut tells me that I was completely right with all of you.
Lynch me, I'm okay with that. But right afterwards start lynching the people who are being defensive about one post made by me and who didn't talk too much before that.
Because I know Rosey, and we're only with 11, eventhough it's very probable we'll lynch a townie first day, I try to tell you that Rosey is probably a townie and a not so clever call to suspect her right now.
Also I'm sorry I'm active now it's 11:30 here, I always am on the forum before I go to sleep. I could give you links to previous games if you like to check me out, lol
I really don't want to lynch anyone yet. I'd much rather wait it out.
Do I have to vote for someone every round or not? Sorry i be never played before, im a tad confused.
I don't know Skelda, I was still feeling a little no votish, but Joyful seems panicky. Could be because first time here, could be because she is scum.
Before this post I didn't really attack her I believe, maybe a bold opinion, but never wanted to lynch her and see how she's panicking.
Also Rosey seems townish, but in other games she used to be more active as town. At this moment she gets easy benefit of my doubts as it could have simple reasons.
Lilac seems like a nice townie.
I don't suspect you, Skelda
Katie I don't know, hasn't said much yet.
So at the moment I'm still leaning no vote, but joyful is on my radar.
You "know rosey" isn't a very good defense. That I suspect Rosey had nothing to do with you, you didn't say anything to defend yourself you only said something to defend her. You three, Skelda who made the list and you and Rosey who were on it... If we lynch someone of you it's possible we'll lynch a mafia on the first day. That would give us a good head start.
And Skelda is just backpedaling now, I stick to my original thought.
You are a stubborn person aren't you lol. I could give you links to all previous games here and you'd see this is Rosey her town behaviour. Do you want that? So you'll know us as well?
Why do you want to throw suspicions around so much? Please answer that question. The only reason I suspect you is because you're so panicky, trying to blacktalk three people here who played together before and thus have certain reads on one another. If you just stopped saying 'you three don't have reasons (we do, you just don't want to open your eyes to them) and you three are together' and started giving some good strong statements I wouldn't suspect you at all.
Comments
But like I said, I'm not convinced that it is you.
Who else do your suspect apart from me?
Oh you mean this? Scum could say this too though. The specific communication, the "I'm probably sounding scum right now" the emoticon... I'm fairly certain this isn't Joy's first game either.
My W/list: http://store.thesims3.com/myWishlist.html?persona=rosey1579
Whut.. that's odd reasoning. I take it you didn't know there's a couple of people who know each other already. Otherwise this statement is just not okay. Also to inform you, first time I plaid I suspected Skelda as well, he has this air around him lol!
I do halfish agree with Skelda, but I'm not sure of Rosey yet. Being as defending as she is now is Roseylike, but she hasn't been around much. But as I said before, it could be because she just isn't as much on the forum anymore as she used to be
I don't suspect you though, you're too townish. Which could be a great strategy but for now I believe you.
Some links that helped me a lot:
Missing Store Stencils / Free Kiddy Stuff / Daily Deals / Daily Deals Spreadsheets / The Gifting Directory
I know scum could say that and scum regularly do. "If I were Mafia" is actually a fairly popular rhetorical technique. I dunno though, it isn't screaming scum to me.
My W/list: http://store.thesims3.com/myWishlist.html?persona=rosey1579
Agree to disagree?
My W/list: http://store.thesims3.com/myWishlist.html?persona=rosey1579
I thinking going to do a bit more observing before I open my mouth again.
You have to watch the people with the same opinion the closest. Mafia loves to follow a townie as to make the other look suspicious... you have to have an 'innocent friend' so to speak.
Some links that helped me a lot:
Missing Store Stencils / Free Kiddy Stuff / Daily Deals / Daily Deals Spreadsheets / The Gifting Directory
I'm not saying you're scumbuddies. You're saying that. I'm just agreeing with you.
My W/list: http://store.thesims3.com/myWishlist.html?persona=rosey1579
I'll think about it. I'm not sure who else to vote for.
Duuudee (female dude probably), stop blaming Rosey. Only Rosey suspects you, why trying to defend so hard. A few people have mentioned this is how Rosey plays. We don't nearly have enough info to go on yet.
Just give lists of what you think.
Some links that helped me a lot:
Missing Store Stencils / Free Kiddy Stuff / Daily Deals / Daily Deals Spreadsheets / The Gifting Directory
It isn't a bandwagon because we don't all agree that you are suspicious.
I was only giving advices and little bit of opinion :') if that's what makes you suspect others, woah
I'm also slow typing though, I'm on my phone!
Some links that helped me a lot:
Missing Store Stencils / Free Kiddy Stuff / Daily Deals / Daily Deals Spreadsheets / The Gifting Directory
Because I know Rosey, and we're only with 11, eventhough it's very probable we'll lynch a townie first day, I try to tell you that Rosey is probably a townie and a not so clever call to suspect her right now.
Also I'm sorry I'm active now
Some links that helped me a lot:
Missing Store Stencils / Free Kiddy Stuff / Daily Deals / Daily Deals Spreadsheets / The Gifting Directory
Do I have to vote for someone every round or not? Sorry i be never played before, im a tad confused.
Before this post I didn't really attack her I believe, maybe a bold opinion, but never wanted to lynch her and see how she's panicking.
Also Rosey seems townish, but in other games she used to be more active as town. At this moment she gets easy benefit of my doubts as it could have simple reasons.
Lilac seems like a nice townie.
I don't suspect you, Skelda
Katie I don't know, hasn't said much yet.
So at the moment I'm still leaning no vote, but joyful is on my radar.
Some links that helped me a lot:
Missing Store Stencils / Free Kiddy Stuff / Daily Deals / Daily Deals Spreadsheets / The Gifting Directory
You are a stubborn person aren't you lol. I could give you links to all previous games here and you'd see this is Rosey her town behaviour. Do you want that? So you'll know us as well?
Why do you want to throw suspicions around so much? Please answer that question. The only reason I suspect you is because you're so panicky, trying to blacktalk three people here who played together before and thus have certain reads on one another. If you just stopped saying 'you three don't have reasons (we do, you just don't want to open your eyes to them) and you three are together' and started giving some good strong statements I wouldn't suspect you at all.
Some links that helped me a lot:
Missing Store Stencils / Free Kiddy Stuff / Daily Deals / Daily Deals Spreadsheets / The Gifting Directory