Long story short, my appaloosa save broke, due to a burglar and a non existant Policewoman. Resetting the offending burglar didn't help either.. Anyone else having this stupid issue?
Never mind... Started a new save.
Sims 4 Family: Benjamin, Shine, Princess Roddy, Sophia and Hamish Furystrykar and Shelly Heart. Princess Roddy is my avatar, and he's a boy!